Both fair, and I think we're mostly agreeing on substance.

Regarding your second point, the "high CE" in my original sentence referred to the CE of solving the policy issue itself, not the marginal CE of the next dollar. So, funding may still shift the probability of winning, just deferred to when a window opens rather than at the moment of funding, because it may fund prep work and exploratory research on a high-suffering issue.

Thanks Vasco, this is a fair critique.

On marginal cost-effectiveness, you’re right that the factors I listed are exactly what determines marginal CE.

So the framing in that paragraph is imprecise.

What I was trying to point at was that the typical “one more dollar at the margin” thinking works well for funding ongoing work where each extra dollar buys more of the same thing.

But it doesn’t work as well in two situations.

The first is contexts where the ongoing work itself hasn’t been built out yet, so there isn’t a stable field at the margin to fund. The second is one-off events like passing a regulation, where extra funding may not change the probability of winning at all, or might only at a specific moment, but still maybe worth taking the bet given high CE.

And these are exactly the judgments the EA ecosystem is less equipped to make at arm’s length, which is part of why fewer such grants get made overall.

I should have written the paragraph that way.

On scoring did the rough back-of-the-envelope calculations which informed the subjective scoring of 1-10 in an area. For some data/evidence poor interventions we just did subjective scoring.

On your offer to review CEAs, we’d love help on that for the next round and I’ll DM you to follow up.

I'd appreciate it if it said

Impactful Giving is building India’s effective giving ecosystem by making evidence-based, scope-sensitive, and counterfactual philanthropy easier for new and emerging high-net-worth donors. We combine rigorous research, funding circles, and bespoke advisory to unlock more high-impact philanthropy in India.

FYI, the post provides an inaccurate and incomplete representation of our work at Impactful Giving

If you’re interested in learning about our work, check our manifund page https://manifund.org/projects/building-ea-ecosystem-in-india?tab=comments

Yes! We anticipate attracting new funding to the Indian animal welfare space through family offices and foundations committing more funds than they'd have previously, and new value-aligned donors joining the funding circle.