CEO of Fairer Fields. I have a blog where I write about nonprofit ops and strategy, and sometimes animal welfare.
I previously co-founded and served as Executive Director at Wild Animal Initiative, was the COO of Rethink Priorities, and was the Director of Operations at GovAI.
Ah, just me trying to add some flair and intending to mean wild animals that reside in and around crops :). On cropland, around 50% are mammals, mostly rodents, but it's also a lot of nesting ground birds, reptiles, etc. In rice paddies, a lot more fish and amphibians too!
Insecticides kill more animals directly than any other human activity. What should we do about it?
Insecticide use on agricultural land kills more animals directly than any other human activity, plausibly in the quadrillions of animals (not including springtails, mites, and other very small invertebrates, which might push these figures much higher). Despite this, there is practically no research or work on the animal welfare impacts of these practices. And insecticides aren't the only highly neglected animal welfare issue on agricultural land — other agricultural practices use or kill billions or trillions of animals annually, such as the use of parasitoid wasps for biological control, managed honey bees used for pollination services, and wild residents of cropland killed by harvesting practices or stubble burning.
I've started a new organization that works to reduce the harms of these practices on animals. Our initial planned intervention is a large-scale program to induce farmers to use less painful insecticides. Our work is complicated to talk about publicly so we aren’t making a top-level post, but we think that helping animals on agricultural land is plausibly among the most cost-effective things that can be done to help animals, and that very promising interventions are on the near horizon.
We’d love to share more about our work with donors interested in learning more. Our core budget funding gap is around $350k for 2027, our ambitious budget gap is much larger, and we’re aiming to deploy initial interventions in the near future. Complete this brief form, and we’ll share a document with more information. You can also support us directly here.
I think it would have!
I agree with all these points! I think I under emphasized in my original that I think working with designers is still really valuable, and definitely agree that Claude will make a better website than me by default. I think I just see risks around design going the same way as AI-generated writing, where if it is too obvious, people will just write it off. E.g. when I see a service provider with an AI-generated website, my mind does a slight discounting on them being real/legitimate, because I have a bit less of a sense of a human having done the work to make the thing.
Useful! And to be clear, I think the website looks great and much better than anything I linked - sorry if that didn't come through! I think my point was something like, there are these design trends here that might start to cause people to react negatively to AI-designed stuff, if it is too obvious, in the same way that many people react to obviously negatively to AI writing, so I am much more excited about everyone working with designers who vibe design still, over making their own websites (which is the same pitch you're making!) as I still think designers are adding a very helpful eye.
FWIW, I think there are some comms risks here — I've noticed that Claude sites in particular start looking really same-y without a good design eye editing them. The new User-Friendly site I would have immediately clocked as Claude-made (and applied some automatic discount to it based on this had you not said it, based on things like):
Little glyphs and words above headings
Random italicized words for emphasis
Using 01, 02, 03 in things that don't need numbering, with the leading 0.
Along with the neutral color palette.
Here are some examples of sites that are clearly made by Claude, and have a lot of these features:
Claude Academy's example websites also look this way: https://academy.claude.com/use-cases/create-a-custom-webpage
I used Claude design with just this prompt: "Can you make me some slides? Don't use my design system - just use whatever you feel like. Fill them in with filler content."
Here are some screenshots of that:
I think that working with a good designer (like you!) seems great for folks doing this, but also, if we're already concerned about EA websites being really same-y, this poses the same kind of risk, or at least for me, as someone who has starting feeling negative about seeing endless amounts of Claude-designed things.
I agree that it is useful! I think it is also just niche to some specific people's needs, and I probably should have just kept it on my Substack (e.g. I like the Forum being about cause prioritization and making the world better, and while starting nonprofits is tangentially related, it isn't really on topic). I think I like the idea of a linkpost sidebar type thing for this sort of content.
Also worth explicitly noting that it seems good that you're posting on the Forum a bunch lately! I think people in leadership roles at organizations engaging with the discourse actively is so good for EA, so thanks for doing that!
I agree about the community drama! I sometimes wonder if the explicit carving out of the community section, while probably good for reducing some kinds of fatigue, also isolated interesting posts that kept people engaged with the Forum.
I'm fairly certain you aren't the common factor :).
I think that I agree — I guess there is some possibility that EA just had way more low hanging fruit in the early days, so it was easier to write pieces that significantly moved discourse forward, or be the first to explicitly state an idea that might look obvious in retrospect, and this was good for conversation.