Hide table of contents

Based on my research, I’m covering some ways you can help people in Palestine and Israel. I think it is worth at least a few hours of every person's time to help people during a war and humanitarian crisis. 

This is not fully comprehensive, so please add comments with other ways to help people in Palestine and Israel and/or thoughts on effectiveness. I focus on what U.S. citizens can do since that’s where I’m from and the U.S. has close ties to Israel. However, there are likely similar actions people from other countries can take. If you know of ways people outside the U.S. can help, please write them in the comments. 

I cover working to stop the deaths of innocent civilians in Palestine, working to get Israeli hostages released, and improving the humanitarian conditions in Palestine. At the end of this post, I included tips on how to effectively reach U.S. politicians, and a summary of the things you can do to help people in Palestine and Israel. 

Stopping and reducing the deaths of civilians in Palestine  

The situation

In their efforts to defeat Hamas, the Israeli government is dropping bombs and leading ground attacks that have killed over 17,000 Palestinians and over 5,000 children. There is no safe place in Gaza, and Palestinians are not allowed to leave Gaza. After Israel told civilians to move to the south, it continued to strike there too

More children have been killed in Gaza in the past 2.5 months than the 2,985 children killed in all the world's major conflict zones combined last year. Casualty and weapons experts say people are being killed in Gaza more quickly than the deadliest moments of U.S.-led attacks in Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan, which were themselves widely criticized by human rights groups.  

How to help

The current Israeli administration’s approach to the war is killing thousands of innocent civilians and children. For people outside Israel, the most effective way to influence the actions of the Israeli government is through political pressure from your own country’s government. I’ll focus on the United States. However, if you live in another country, it would help to pressure your politicians as well.  

The U.S. government has close ties to Israel and gives around $3.3 billion dollars of aid to Israel each year

The United States has influence over Israel. For example, it’s likely that U.S. pressure was a significant factor in the recent decision to open the 'Kerem Shalom' crossing to let in more humanitarian aid to Gaza. U.S. national security advisor Jake Sullivan wrote on December 15, “President Biden raised this issue in recent phone calls with Prime Minister Netanyahu, and it was an important topic of discussion during my visit to Israel…This new opening will ease congestion and help facilitate the delivery of life-saving assistance to those who need it urgently in Gaza.” 

I’ll cover what the U.S. government can do and what U.S. residents can do to influence the U.S. government. 

Members of the U.S. Congress and the Biden administration can

  1. Call for a ceasefire or call for a targeted counterterrorism attack on Hamas instead of indiscriminate bombing 
  2. Make U.S. aid to Israel conditional on ending indiscriminate bombing, 
    1. Bernie Sanders proposed other conditions as well

(If you know of other actions the U.S. government can take to prevent the deaths of civilians in Palestine, please comment them) 

To influence members of the U.S. Congress and Biden administration, you can

  1. Email, call, or send physical mail to your representatives and urge them to act on the above 
    1. You can find their contact information online. 
    2. Many offices log every message and send daily or weekly updates of constituent messages to the representative. 
    3. If many people call or email about an issue and/or the representative reads a compelling message, it increases the likelihood that the representative will prioritize an issue or change their position. 
      1. Of course, there’s only a small likelihood your message will influence your representative, but I think it’s worth the 15 minutes it takes. Like voting, a collective of people doing something can influence major political decisions. 
    4. At the bottom of this post, I include information on how to most effectively contact your representatives 
  2. Email or call the White House using this link 
  3. Attend a protest calling for a ceasefire. According to research by Erica Chenoweth, “Nonviolent protests are twice as likely to succeed as armed conflicts – and those engaging a threshold of 3.5% of the population have never failed to bring about change.” 
    1. You can find a list of protests around the world here

Getting Israeli hostages released 

The situation

There are about 140 hostages still held by Hamas in Gaza. Twenty hostages have died since the Oct. 7 attacks. The hostages are not given enough food. They are living in fear. Since the hostages are in Gaza, they are at risk of being killed during fighting. 

How to help 

For people in Israel, putting pressure on the Netanyahu administration could influence the Israeli government to prioritize the release of hostages. 

In the United States, members of Congress and the Biden administration can

  1. Call for the immediate release of hostages (as most U.S. politicians have already done) 
  2. Use their influence in international diplomacy to start negotiations for the release of the hostages 
  3. Call for a ceasefire or call for a targeted counterterrorism attack on Hamas instead of indiscriminate bombing and fighting that could kill hostages 

To influence members of the U.S. Congress and Biden administration, you can: 

  1. Email, call, or send physical mail to your representatives and urge them to act on the above
    1.  At the bottom of this post, I include information on how to effectively contact your representatives 
  2. Email, call, or text the White House using these links

Improving the humanitarian conditions in Gaza  

The situation 

The 2.3 million people in Gaza do not have enough food, fuel, water, or medical supplies. The World Food Programme declared a “catastrophic hunger crisis” in Gaza on December 5. Most people in Gaza are homeless, and some have moved 3 or 4 times in the past few months. In crowded shelters that do not meet basic sanitation and hygiene needs, disease spreads quickly. Doctors perform amputations by flashlight and without anesthesia.  

As reported by The New York Times, “Before the war, some 500 trucks with essential supplies came into Gaza every day, many from Egypt via the Rafah crossing. Far fewer have made it across since the bombardment began, even during the ceasefire. The trucks slowed to a trickle once the fighting resumed.” It is extremely difficult to distribute and restock aid amidst fighting and bombing. 

How to help  

Pressure politicians 

In the United States, members of the U.S. government can: 

  1. Demand a ceasefire or a targeted, counterterrorism attack on Hamas  
    1. Palestinians are living in these awful conditions because of the war and Israel’s approach to the war. The war is forcing them to move often, live in shelters, and not be able to grow or make food. It is difficult for aid to get through due to heavy bombing and fighting. 
  2. Work with Israel, Egypt, and international organizations to get more humanitarian aid into Gaza 
    1. Israel committed to letting in 200 trucks/day in the hostage deal. They recently opened the Kerem-Shalom crossing since the Rafah crossing could only security check and let pass 100 trucks/day. However, 200 trucks/day is not enough. Before the war, some 500 trucks with essential supplies came into Gaza every day.
    2. When trucks get into Gaza, they face the challenge of distributing the aid to 2.3 million people. A U.S. official from COGAT, the branch of the military which coordinates humanitarian aid to Palestine, said that the UN and other humanitarian agencies have not increased their collection and distribution capacities to meet the needs of Gazans who have fled to the South on Israeli advice. Juliette Touma, communications director of the U.N. Palestinian refugee agency, pushed back, saying on X "You cannot deliver aid under a sky full of airstrikes."

You can pressure members of your government to act on the above through calling/emailing them and going to protests. I included information about how U.S. residents can effectively contact their representatives and the Biden administration at the bottom of this post. 

Donating to GiveWell-recommended organizations is most likely more effective at saving and improving lives than donating to organizations in Gaza. Malaria kills over 600,000 people annually. 

However, I know many EAs set aside some of their money for donating to causes they feel strongly about that might not be the most cost-effective. I’ve done some research on a few organizations, but please comment below if you know of other organizations that are good to donate to. 

  1. Palestine Children’s Relief Fund is delivering food, water, and medical supplies to Gaza. They post updates on their website of the aid getting delivered to Gaza. They have a Charity Navigator rating of 97% which indicates high financial  efficiency, sustainability, and trustworthiness. 
  2. You can donate eSIMs to Gaza through the non-profit Connecting Humanity. This helps Palestinians connect to the Internet and contact their family members.  
    1. Each eSIM costs $10-$50 and the process takes about 15 minutes. 
    2. You can read the guide on how to donate here and read about the initiative here.  
  3. The Egyptian Food Bank is delivering aid to Gaza. Since most aid comes from the Rafah and Kerem Shalom crossings between Egypt and Gaza, I think it’s more likely that this aid will be delivered quickly compared to Western organizations. 
  4. Some Doctors Without Borders staff are still operating in Gaza. They donated 26 tons of medical equipment which arrived in Egypt on October 29, but their website doesn’t share any updates about if these medical supplies were delivered to Gaza. GiveWell has recommended Doctors without Borders as a good disaster relief organization before. 

How to effectively reach U.S. politicians 

I think the best way to influence the Biden administration is to protest (see a list of protests here), email, and text. 

I think the best way to influence Congress is to protest and contact the member of Congress for your district. Offices prioritize messages from people in their district. 

I remember feeling some hesitation to contact my members of Congress about the Israel-Hamas war because I’d never called the offices of my members of Congress before. However, I think after one or two calls or emails, it begins to feel natural. 

As I mentioned, if many people send a message about an issue and/or the representative reads a compelling message, it increases the likelihood that the representative will prioritize an issue or change their position. Of course, there’s only a small likelihood your message will influence your representative, but I think it’s worth the 15 minutes it takes. Like voting, a collective of people doing something can influence major political decisions. 

You can reach your Congress member through 

  1. Phone call 
  2. Email 
  3. Physical mail (see a video on how to send mail with photos from the war to your Congress member here)
  4. Fax 

Most congressional offices will send daily or weekly reports to their member of Congress. These reports typically include the number of messages received about an issue and some or all of the messages. 

You can Google the office numbers, emails, and addresses of your congressional representatives. 

Tips for reaching your Congress member effectively

  1. Write your message as if the Congress member will actually read your message or the notes from your phone call. Many members of Congress get regular updates with constituent messages. 
    1. Have clear asks  (Ex. Please make aid to Israel conditional on stopping their indiscriminate bombing)  
    2. Include specific reason (or reasons) for what you are urging your member of Congress to do. Phone calls that rely on scripts from advocacy organizations tend to be downgraded
      1. Since the Congress member has access to these messages, it’s likely more effective to put your reasons than to just state your position. 
    3. Do your research on the current position of your member of Congress. You can read their press releases and X/Twitter feed. 
      1. If their actions align with your position, you can call, express appreciation for what they did, and iterate the importance of this issue to you. 
      2. If their actions do not align with your position, you can acknowledge their position while advocating for your own. (Ex. "Israel needs to be safe, but the response to Hamas’s horrifying attacks on civilians in Israel should not have been horrifying attacks on civilians in Gaza.")
  2. If no one picks up when you call, try calling at another time. 
    1. The offices of my representatives are more likely to pick up calls in the afternoon. 
  3. Call the office and ask the congressional staffer about how messages get to the Congress member and if it is more likely that a call or email will reach the Congress member
    1. This will give you insight into how to most effectively reach the Congress member 

Summary of things you can do to help people in Palestine and Israel

  1. Call or email your members of Congress (or the equivalent in your own country) with the following demands. (Of course, only call with the demands that you agree with. If you disagree with one of these demands, I'd be interesting in reading your reasoning in the comments.) 
    1. a ceasefire or pressuring Israel to conduct a targeted, counterterrorism attack on Hamas instead of indiscriminate bombing 
    2. making aid to Israel conditional on ending indiscriminate bombing and fighting 
    3. the release of the hostages
    4. more humanitarian aid for Gaza
  2. Email, call, or text the Biden administration(or the equivalent in your own country) with the following demands:
    1. a ceasefire or pressuring Israel to conduct a targeted, counterterrorism attack on Hamas
    2. making aid to Israel conditional on ending indiscriminate bombing and fighting 
    3. the release of the hostages
    4. more humanitarian aid for Gaza
  3. Go to a protest calling for a ceasefire
    1. See this list of protests around the world here
  4. Donate eSIMs to Gaza through non-profit Connecting Humanity. This helps Palestinians connect to the Internet and contact their family members.  
    1. You can read the guide on how to donate here and read about the initiative here 
  5. Donate to aid organizations
    1. Palestine Children’s Relief Fund is delivering food, water, and medical supplies to Gaza. They post regular updates of the aid getting delivered to Gaza. 
    2. You can donate eSIMs to Gaza through the non-profit Connecting Humanity. This helps Palestinians connect to the Internet and contact their family members.  
      1. Each eSIM costs $10-$50 and the process takes about 15 minutes. 
      2. You can read the guide on how to donate here and read about the initiative here.  
    3. The Egyptian Food Bank is sending aid to Gaza. Since aid comes from crossings between Egypt and Gaza, I think it’s more likely that this aid will be delivered quickly compared to Western organizations. 
    4. Some Doctors Without Borders staff are still operating in Gaza. They donated 26 tons of medical equipment which arrived in Egypt on October 29, but their website doesn’t share any updates about if these medical supplies were delivered to Gaza. GiveWell has recommended Doctors without Borders as a good disaster relief organization before. 
Comments4


Sorted by Click to highlight new comments since:

I think it is worth at least a few hours of every person's time to help people during a war and humanitarian crisis. 

 

I don't think this is true, and I don't see an a priori reason to expect cause prioritization research to result in that conclusion. I also find it a little weird how often people make this sort of generalized argument for focusing on this particular conflict, when such a generalized statement should apply equally well to many more conflicts that are much more neglected and lower salience but where people rarely make this sort of argument (it feels like some sort of selective invocation of a generalizable principle).

That makes sense, I now think I made this statement too general.

In the case of the Israel-Hamas war, how would you decide if it's worth a few hours to help? 

Thanks for writing this! I always wonder how often to call about the same issue. Did you find anything about this in your research? 

Executive summary: The post covers ways to help people in Palestine and Israel during the war by stopping civilian deaths in Palestine, freeing Israeli hostages, and improving humanitarian conditions in Gaza.

Key points:

  1. Pressure U.S. politicians to call for a ceasefire, conditional aid to Israel, hostage release, and more humanitarian aid.
  2. Protest, call, email, or mail Congress and the White House with these demands.
  3. Donate to organizations providing medical and connectivity aid in Gaza.
  4. Reach politicians effectively by personalizing asks, doing research, and following up.
  5. Main goals are stopping indiscriminate bombing, freeing hostages, and allowing humanitarian aid into Gaza.

 

 

This comment was auto-generated by the EA Forum Team. Feel free to point out issues with this summary by replying to the comment, and contact us if you have feedback.

Curated and popular this week
 ·  · 2m read
 · 
I can’t recall the last time I read a book in one sitting, but that’s what happened with Moral Ambition by bestselling author Rutger Bregman. I read the German edition, though it’s also available in Dutch (see James Herbert's Quick Take). An English release is slated for May. The book opens with the statement: “The greatest waste of our times is the waste of talent.” From there, Bregman builds a compelling case for privileged individuals to leave their “bullshit jobs” and tackle the world’s most pressing challenges. He weaves together narratives spanning historical movements like abolitionism, suffrage, and civil rights through to contemporary initiatives such as Against Malaria Foundation, Charity Entrepreneurship, LEEP, and the Shrimp Welfare Project. If you’ve been engaged with EA ideas, much of this will sound familiar, but I initially didn’t expect to enjoy the book as much as I did. However, Bregman’s skill as a storyteller and his knack for balancing theory and narrative make Moral Ambition a fascinating read. He reframes EA concepts in a more accessible way, such as replacing “counterfactuals” with the sports acronym “VORP” (Value Over Replacement Player). His use of stories and examples, paired with over 500 footnotes for details, makes the book approachable without sacrificing depth. I had some initial reservations. The book draws heavily on examples from the EA community but rarely engages directly with the movement, mentioning EA mainly in the context of FTX. The final chapter also promotes Bregman’s own initiative, The School for Moral Ambition. However, the school’s values closely align with core EA principles. The ITN framework and pitches for major EA cause areas are in the book, albeit with varying levels of depth. Having finished the book, I can appreciate its approach. Moral Ambition feels like a more pragmatic, less theory-heavy version of EA. The School for Moral Ambition has attracted better-known figures in Germany, such as the political e
 ·  · 6m read
 · 
Cross-posted from Otherwise. Most people in EA won't find these arguments new. Apologies for leaving out animal welfare entirely for the sake of simplicity. Last month, Emma Goldberg wrote a NYT piece contrasting effective altruism with approaches that refuse to quantify meaningful experiences. The piece indicates that effective altruism is creepily numbers-focused. Goldberg asks “what if charity shouldn’t be optimized?” The egalitarian answer Dylan Matthews gives a try at answering a question in the piece: “How can anyone put a numerical value on a holy space” like Notre Dame cathedral? For the $760 million spent restoring the cathedral, he estimates you could prevent 47,500 deaths from malaria. “47,500 people is about five times the population of the town I grew up in. . . . It’s useful to imagine walking down Main Street, stopping at each table at the diner Lou’s, shaking hands with as many people as you can, and telling them, ‘I think you need to die to make a cathedral pretty.’ And then going to the next town over and doing it again, and again, until you’ve told 47,500 people why they have to die.” Who prefers magnificence? Goldstein’s article draws a lot on author Amy Schiller’s plea to focus charity on “magnificence” rather than effectiveness. Some causes “make people’s lives feel meaningful, radiant, sacred. Think nature conservancies, cultural centers and places of worship. These are institutions that lend life its texture and color, and not just bare bones existence.” But US arts funding goes disproportionately to the most expensive projects, with more than half of the funding going to the most expensive 2% of projects. These are typically museums, classical music groups, and performing arts centers. When donors prioritize giving to communities they already have ties to, the money stays in richer communities. Some areas have way more rich people than others. New York City has 119 billionaires; most African countries have none. Unsurprisingly, Schil
Sarah Cheng
 ·  · 2m read
 · 
TL;DR: The EA Opportunity Board is back up and running! Check it out here, and subscribe to the bi-weekly newsletter here. It’s now owned by the CEA Online Team. EA Opportunities is a project aimed at helping people find part-time and volunteer opportunities to build skills or contribute to impactful work. Their core products are the Opportunity Board and the associated bi-weekly newsletter, plus related promos across social media and Slack automations. It was started and run by students and young professionals for a long time, and has had multiple iterations over the years. The project has been on pause for most of 2024 and the student who was running it no longer has capacity, so the CEA Online Team is taking it over to ensure that it continues to operate. I want to say a huge thank you to everyone who has run this project over the three years that it’s been operating, including Sabrina C, Emma W, @michel, @Jacob Graber, and Varun. From talking with some of them and reading through their docs, I can tell that it means a lot to them, and they have some grand visions for how the project could grow in the future. I’m happy that we are in a position to take on this project on short notice and keep it afloat, and I’m excited for either our team or someone else to push it further in the future. Our plans We plan to spend some time evaluating the project in early 2025. We have some evidence that it has helped people find impactful opportunities and stay motivated to do good, but we do not yet have a clear sense of the cost-effectiveness of running it[1]. We are optimistic enough about it that we will at least keep it running through the end of 2025, but we are not currently committing to owning it in the longer term. The Online Team runs various other projects, such as this Forum, the EA Newsletter, and effectivealtruism.org. I think the likeliest outcome is for us to prioritize our current projects (which all reach a larger audience) over EA Opportunities, which