I'm a Senior Researcher for Rethink Priorities and a Professor of Philosophy at Texas State University. I work on a wide range of theoretical and applied issues related to animal welfare. You can reach me here.
The Arthropoda Foundation exists to produce the science we need to improve the lives of farmed invertebrates. We identify the research questions that we need to answer to make credible asks of industry; then, we coordinate and fund the labs that can answer them. Our current focus is validating humane slaughter and depopulation methods for both farmed insects and shrimps, though we support many other kinds of projects via our semi-annual calls for proposals, which help us to identify talent and build the field of aligned researchers.
Invertebrates are the most numerous farmed animals: many trillions are slaughtered each year, including over 900 billion farmed shrimp, black soldier flies, and mealworms. (Rethink Priorities projects that shrimps, BSF, and mealworms alone could exceed 5 trillion by 2033.) To a first approximation, then, all farmed animals are invertebrates. Moreover, they face all the problems we should expect from other forms of intensive farming: selective breeding for productivity at the expense of welfare; high stocking densities, leading to aggression and disease outbreaks; slaughter largely without stunning. And the solutions aren’t obvious: many changes to producers’ practices that sound reasonable could make welfare worse; many changes that look feasible, aren’t. Finally, industry funds research that serves production goals; traditional science funders spend almost nothing on invertebrate welfare. So, if we’re going to figure out how to help these animals, we have to pay for the science.
I’m not worried about covering our core programming in 2027; we have several months of runway and I expect to be able to raise the rest. However, we can absorb far more than our core programming, as we’re discovering far more opportunities than we can afford. For instance, we’re currently building out a research program on substrate enrichments for shrimps, which can reduce the aggression that compromises the welfare of younger shrimp in particular. We’d like to run a program on honey bee depopulation, which is currently a slow and painful affair (the killing, not the program). We’d like to support work on species that have hardly been studied at all, such as cochineals and lac bugs. Even the pilot versions of each program would cost between $150K and $300K; the full versions would be more like $500K to $1M per year for three years.
Thanks for engaging, James! I agree with all these limitations: we flagged several of them from the start and have mentioned others elsewhere. The only points I'll add are:
The uncertainties cut in different directions. For instance, correcting for the "understudied species" problem would give us higher welfare range estimates for some animals, like fish and flies, whereas correcting for the "scalar not binary traits" problem would give us lower estimates. It's an open question how those corrections would net out. But almost certainly not at the precise numbers we gave! (That's one of many reasons why I've never taken the precise numbers all that seriously.)
One of many comms failures associated with the Moral Weight Project is that we didn't do enough to stress the background considerations that led us to set up the MWP the way we did. The models are toy models; no one should trust them on their own. They make sense, insofar as they do, in the context of (a) more general arguments for thinking that, given hedonism, we're likely to end up with small differences between species, and (b) a particular view about how best to navigate the uncertainties associated with making these estimates in the first place (basically, defaulting to an approach that minimizes differences we can't justify, which we discuss both in the original post and in the book). If you think that, conditional on hedonism, nonhuman animals probably aren't that different from human animals and that we shouldn't give our priors that much weight, so the burden of proof is on any postulated differences, then I think what we did makes some sense.
I agree: low confidence is the right orientation. That being said, we should have low confidence in the alternatives! We're all fumbling in the dark here. My hope is just that we can, as a community, do better over time.
I don’t think it’s worth doing. I don’t think we’d learn anything from the exercise. Skepticism about nematode sentience is driven partially by doubts that they achieve the same behaviors via the same mechanisms. So just establishing sameness of behavior wouldn’t be that helpful. The research agenda for them should focus on how more complex brains achieve the same kinds of things, which might shed light on whether those brains are meaningfully different from simpler ones. Or so I’m inclined to think at this point.
Thanks for your work on this, Guillaume! I should stress that I think of $100K per criterion as the minimum that funders should expect to spend. And as you mention, some criteria are going to be much more expensive to investigate than others. In particular, the behavioral ones that you take to be the most evidentially significant could each cost 3x-5x that baseline. Behavioral work is hard!
I don’t know whether soil microarthropods are the most important to determine the expected change in welfare, but I was assuming that they are when describing biofuel subsidies as attractive to people who are sufficiently suffering-focused. You’re right that other animals could be instead.
Hi Vasco. No, I am not confident that biofuel subsidies decrease the population of invertebrates. These are shallow investigations and I expect that additional research would change our minds about many of the conclusions that people reached.
Oh sure. I would certainly run one on ant or termite welfare for $50,000, again only speaking for myself and needing to talk to the board before it is a claim about what the organization would do. Possibly less. It’s just important to have enough to be able to support a handful of small projects.
That is a hard question. I think the truth is that you could easily spend several hundred thousand dollars just to get decent evidence of any one of the eight Birch criteria being met in a single species. Trying to get evidence good enough that would allow you to make generalizations about soil animals is certainly a multi-million-dollar project. So, I am very concerned that any gettable number is too low to provide the kind of evidence that I would trust. That said, and speaking only for myself (not the board), I'd be willing to run a grant round for $100,000. I'm not sure about numbers lower than that.
The Arthropoda Foundation exists to produce the science we need to improve the lives of farmed invertebrates. We identify the research questions that we need to answer to make credible asks of industry; then, we coordinate and fund the labs that can answer them. Our current focus is validating humane slaughter and depopulation methods for both farmed insects and shrimps, though we support many other kinds of projects via our semi-annual calls for proposals, which help us to identify talent and build the field of aligned researchers.
Invertebrates are the most numerous farmed animals: many trillions are slaughtered each year, including over 900 billion farmed shrimp, black soldier flies, and mealworms. (Rethink Priorities projects that shrimps, BSF, and mealworms alone could exceed 5 trillion by 2033.) To a first approximation, then, all farmed animals are invertebrates. Moreover, they face all the problems we should expect from other forms of intensive farming: selective breeding for productivity at the expense of welfare; high stocking densities, leading to aggression and disease outbreaks; slaughter largely without stunning. And the solutions aren’t obvious: many changes to producers’ practices that sound reasonable could make welfare worse; many changes that look feasible, aren’t. Finally, industry funds research that serves production goals; traditional science funders spend almost nothing on invertebrate welfare. So, if we’re going to figure out how to help these animals, we have to pay for the science.
I’m not worried about covering our core programming in 2027; we have several months of runway and I expect to be able to raise the rest. However, we can absorb far more than our core programming, as we’re discovering far more opportunities than we can afford. For instance, we’re currently building out a research program on substrate enrichments for shrimps, which can reduce the aggression that compromises the welfare of younger shrimp in particular. We’d like to run a program on honey bee depopulation, which is currently a slow and painful affair (the killing, not the program). We’d like to support work on species that have hardly been studied at all, such as cochineals and lac bugs. Even the pilot versions of each program would cost between $150K and $300K; the full versions would be more like $500K to $1M per year for three years.
Questions? You can contact me at [email protected]. You can also give here.
Thanks for engaging, James! I agree with all these limitations: we flagged several of them from the start and have mentioned others elsewhere. The only points I'll add are:
If you’re interested in this work, then let me point out that RP is hiring.
I don’t think it’s worth doing. I don’t think we’d learn anything from the exercise. Skepticism about nematode sentience is driven partially by doubts that they achieve the same behaviors via the same mechanisms. So just establishing sameness of behavior wouldn’t be that helpful. The research agenda for them should focus on how more complex brains achieve the same kinds of things, which might shed light on whether those brains are meaningfully different from simpler ones. Or so I’m inclined to think at this point.
Guillaume would know better than me! I don’t know how long he spent on this project.
Thanks for your work on this, Guillaume! I should stress that I think of $100K per criterion as the minimum that funders should expect to spend. And as you mention, some criteria are going to be much more expensive to investigate than others. In particular, the behavioral ones that you take to be the most evidentially significant could each cost 3x-5x that baseline. Behavioral work is hard!
I don’t know whether soil microarthropods are the most important to determine the expected change in welfare, but I was assuming that they are when describing biofuel subsidies as attractive to people who are sufficiently suffering-focused. You’re right that other animals could be instead.
Hi Vasco. No, I am not confident that biofuel subsidies decrease the population of invertebrates. These are shallow investigations and I expect that additional research would change our minds about many of the conclusions that people reached.
Oh sure. I would certainly run one on ant or termite welfare for $50,000, again only speaking for myself and needing to talk to the board before it is a claim about what the organization would do. Possibly less. It’s just important to have enough to be able to support a handful of small projects.
That is a hard question. I think the truth is that you could easily spend several hundred thousand dollars just to get decent evidence of any one of the eight Birch criteria being met in a single species. Trying to get evidence good enough that would allow you to make generalizations about soil animals is certainly a multi-million-dollar project. So, I am very concerned that any gettable number is too low to provide the kind of evidence that I would trust. That said, and speaking only for myself (not the board), I'd be willing to run a grant round for $100,000. I'm not sure about numbers lower than that.