NS

Nitin Sekar

Conservation Scientist @ Conservation X Labs
171 karmaJoined Working (6-15 years)

Comments
6

Hey Aaron,

So we definitely appreciate Dr. Mayer's efforts, but we are yet to see rigorous peer-reviewed evidence that the interventions associated with her work are effective, and field implementation has not been designed in such a way that allows experts to isolate the effects of contraceptives from rodenticides. Some cities have already suspended their implementation of these contraceptives out of concerns that they are ineffective. It is certainly possible that these interventions work-- but even then, there is almost certainly room for improvement (particularly for the island conservation context), which our open innovation program could help facilitate. Finally, given that any fertility control intervention will exert heavy selection pressures on rodents to evolve resistance, having multiple tools is likely necessary for lasting success. 

Hello everyone-- I have a brief update: since posting this, I have received a number of positive indications and inquiries. If the behavior of other donors is relevant to your decision making, feel free to reach out and I can provide more information on our current fundraising status. That said, there is a lot we could do with even more funding beyond the amount requested here, so any additional donations would not be wasted.

Thanks Kestrel! We did submit an application there as well. But since, as you noted, our budget is a bit on the high side (and, obviously, all applications are uncertain), we thought it would be prudent to post here as well.

I appreciate Cam putting the potential benefits of this work so effectively and succinctly.

I do want to add one thing here though: the plant-based policy at CXL, as well as the interest in this work, is not just a function of me-- it's a function of CXL. My colleagues are excited by the idea of finding win-wins for biodiversity and animal well-being, presenting what to me is a unique opportunity to help bring animal welfare concerns into mainstream conservation. 

Hey Toby, yes I have! They declined to fund this but, due to the volume of applications they are dealing with post-merger, they were unable to make time to explain why. 

Thanks for the suggestion.