Hide table of contents

Hi I'm new here so please feel free to let me know if I'm breaking any norms but I'll cut to the chase:

Last year I began freelancing and generated about $50K. Do you think it be weird/ pompous to let them my main clients know I donated 10% of that to Give well's top charities?

I was thinking of slipping a note about that into a holiday gift package. I would love to introduce them to EA charities and maybe get them interested in some but don't want to be strange and hurt my business.

24

0
0

Reactions

0
0
New Answer
New Comment


2 Answers sorted by

Probably depends on how you describe it and frame it. How do you explain why you are telling them this? If you’re willing, you might do a trial on this. Do something like divide your clients into two random groups and send this message to half. See if you observe any difference (try to keep track of the numbers as well as the more qualitative outcomes like how they respond to the card)

"How do you explain why you are telling them this?"

I'd say something like it has been such a pleasure working with you that I feel the need to give back to the less fortunate. X charity seems to me to be the most effiecent way to do that as far as I know and I couldn't have supported it without you.

"Do something like divide your clients into two random groups and send this message to half."

Interesting idea.

2
david_reinstein
Good but I don’t quite see the logic of “ it has been such a pleasure working with you that I feel the need to give back to the less fortunate”. How does one follow from the other?
1
Ebenezer Dukakis
One idea to be less preachy is to frame your donation as a thank you from its recipients to your client. E.g. you could say something like: "I got the money you wired me. Thank you. I thought it might warm your heart to know that I donated 10% of the money to X organization, and as a result Y outcome occurred. So, you have made some Z individuals quite thankful as well!" Basically sort of give them a taste of what it feels like to give effectively. BTW, I suspect communicating this info will work better in live conversation. If you communicate in live conversation, you create a space for them to ask questions and learn more, plus over time you might get better at bringing it up in a way that's not weird.

Probably depends on how you describe it and frame it.

Yeah, I think there are ways to frame it so it isn't super preachy. E.g. have an "About Me" section on your website that mentions your pledge. Or mention your annual donations during chitchat about the holidays.

I guess it is ok to mention it, particularly in a holiday gift. Specifically I would feel it is ok to mention what it achieved without being preachy. Some companies use smaller amounts (1%) to signal social impact.

Thanks for the feedback!

"Some companies use smaller amounts (1%) to signal social impact." 

My company isn't currently big enough for 1% to have any impact though 😅 I was actually thinking of potentially donating 20% of revenue by matching clients' donations to EA's top charities up to 10%.

3
PabloAMC 🔸
If you feel uncomfortable with being preachy perhaps donation matching may feel more so than just highlighting that you are donating a percentage of earnings.
1
David_R 🔸
I hear that. Donation matching shows it's not just preaching for no reason.
Curated and popular this week
TL;DR * Screwworm Free Future is a new group seeking support to advance work on eradicating the New World Screwworm in South America. * The New World Screwworm (C. hominivorax - literally "man-eater") causes extreme suffering to hundreds of millions of wild and domestic animals every year. * To date we’ve held private meetings with government officials, experts from the private sector, academics, and animal advocates. We believe that work on the NWS is valuable and we want to continue our research and begin lobbying. * Our analysis suggests we could prevent about 100 animals from experiencing an excruciating death per dollar donated, though this estimate has extreme uncertainty. * The screwworm “wall” in Panama has recently been breached, creating both an urgent need and an opportunity to address this problem. * We are seeking $15,000 to fund a part-time lead and could absorb up to $100,000 to build a full-time team, which would include a team lead and another full-time equivalent (FTE) role * We're also excited to speak to people who have a background in veterinary science/medicine, entomology, gene drives, as well as policy experts in Latin America. - please reach out if you know someone who fits this description!   Cochliomyia hominivorax delenda est Screwworm Free Future is a new group of volunteers who connected through Hive investigating the political and scientific barriers stopping South American governments from eradicating the New World Screwworm. In our shallow investigation, we have identified key bottlenecks, but we now need funding and people to take this investigation further, and begin lobbying. In this post, we will cover the following: * The current status of screwworms * Things that we have learnt in our research * What we want to do next * How you can help by funding or supporting or project   What’s the deal with the New World Screwworm? The New World Screwworm[1] is the leading cause of myiasis in Latin America. Myiasis “
 ·  · 4m read
 · 
As 2024 draws to a close, I’m reflecting on the work and stories that inspired me this year: those from the effective altruism community, those I found out about through EA-related channels, and those otherwise related to EA. I’ve appreciated the celebration of wins and successes over the past few years from @Shakeel Hashim's posts in 2022 and 2023. As @Lizka and @MaxDalton put very well in a post in 2022: > We often have high standards in effective altruism. This seems absolutely right: our work matters, so we must constantly strive to do better. > > But we think that it's really important that the effective altruism community celebrate successes: > > * If we focus too much on failures, we incentivize others/ourselves to minimize the risk of failure, and we will probably be too risk averse. > * We're humans: we're more motivated if we celebrate things that have gone well. Rather than attempting to write a comprehensive review of this year's successes and wins related to EA, I want to share what has personally moved me this year—progress that gave me hope, individual stories and acts of altruism, and work that I found thought-provoking or valuable. I’ve structured the sections below as prompts to invite your own reflection on the year, as I’d love to hear your responses in the comments. We all have different relationships with EA ideas and the community surrounding them, and I find it valuable that we can bring different perspectives and responses to questions like these. What progress in the world did you find exciting? * The launch of the Lead Exposure Elimination Fund this year was exciting to see, and the launch of the Partnership for a Lead-Free Future. The fund jointly committed over $100 million to combat lead exposure, compared to the $15 million in private funding that went toward lead exposure reduction in 2023. It’s encouraging to see lead poisoning receiving attention and funding after being relatively neglected. * The Open Wing Alliance repor