Hi!
Is the University Group Organizer Fellowship open to Singaporeans?
I'm Minh, a Singaporean undergraduate freshman with 5+ years experience founding and scaling various student groups. These groups have have worked directly with policymakers on education policy initiatives, garnered international press coverage, fundraised a total of >$330,000 and created a student forum with >300,000 active monthly users. This is in the areas of education reform and climate advocacy (which are the only places that let teenagers actually do anything). My university, Singapore Management University (SMU), has a Centre for AI and Data Governance and puts out a lot of research on AI Safety, so going into that seems viable as well.
I've been in the EA community since ~2015 and am keen on applying. However, the second footer on the Fellowship page seems to imply Singapore is not an eligible location. Is this accurate? Seems counterintuitive since Singapore (in fact, SMU specifically) is the location of this year's EAGx conference.
Hi Minh– sorry for the confusion! That footer was actually from an older version of the page that referenced eligible locations for the Centre for Effective Altruism’s city and national community building grant program; I’ve now deleted it.
I encourage organizers from any university to apply, including those in Singapore.
A few questions mostly not relevant to me:
i) If I imagine I'm still leading a student group, a few things come to mind:
ii) For the Century Fellowship:
i)
ii)
For both programs, we don’t have an explicit referral system, but we do take into account what references have to say about the applicant (if the applicant provides references).
Yeah, agree with this as a student. I'm very keen on applying, but I have no reference for what the expectations are. I get that the Fellowship is flexible by design, but a point of reference (such as a hypothetical or real life example) would really help.
WRT to your second point, I actually dont think paying is as big of a deal as people are implying. I worked with very competent national-level student organisers who were willing to put in wayyyyyyyyyy more than 40 hours a week for their causes and even get arrested or forgo prestigious awards/school for them. However, the types of people who are active in this way are also mindful of academic and career expectations.
It's slightly taboo to treat social causes as sources of money, but I find that young people are forced to make this decision eventually. Society tells them any level of societal impact is subordinate to any level of career progression, so it's practically inevitable to lose competent organisers who take the first part time job that they're way overqualified for in practice. I've seen it happen plenty.
This of course changes the way you approach recruitment, but IMO that's a good (and not entirely different) problem from what you had relying solely on volunteers.
The page for the Century Fellowship outlines some things that fellows could do, which are much broader than just university group organizing:
When assessing applications, we will primarily be evaluating the candidate rather than their planned activities, but we imagine a hypothetical Century Fellow may want to:
- Lead or support student groups relevant to improving the long-term future at top universities
- Develop a research agenda aimed at solving difficult technical problems in advanced deep learning models
- Start an organization that teaches critical thinking skills to talented young people
- Run an international contest for tools that let us trace where synthetic biological agents were first engineered
- Conduct research on questions that could help us understand how to to make the future go better
- Establish a publishing company that makes it easier for authors to print and distribute books on important topics
Partly this comment exists just to give readers a better impression of the range of things that the century fellowship could be used for. For example, as far as I can tell, the fellowship is currently one of very few options for people who want to pursue fairly independent longtermist research and who want help with getting work authorization in the UK or US.
But I'm also curious if you have any comments on the extent to which you expect the century fellowship to take on community organizers vs researchers vs ~entrepeneurs. (Is the focus on community organizing in this post indicative, or just a consequence of the century fellowship being mentioned in a post that's otherwise about community organizing?)
When we were originally thinking about the fellowship, one of the cases for impact was making community building a more viable career (hence the emphasis in this post), but it’s definitely intended more broadly for people working on the long-term future. I’m pretty unsure how the fellowship will shake out in terms of community organizers vs researchers vs entrepreneurs long-term – we’ve funded a mix so far (including several people who I’m not sure how to categorize / are still unsure about what they want to do).
Thanks for all the work you are doing here, I think some really amazing groups could come out of this. I am cautiously excited about many different kinds of groups starting.
I found it a bit surprising that the list of criteria for group organizers (including "nice to have") doesn't seem to have anything like "really cares about the objectives of their group," "really cares about improving the long term future," "is altruistic to some degree"
- Being truth-seeking and open-minded
- Having a strong understanding of whatever topic their group is about, and/or being self-aware about gaps in understanding
- Being socially skilled enough that people won’t find them highly offputting (note that this is a much lower bar than being actively friendly, extroverted, etc.)
Secondary “nice-to-have” desiderata include:
- Taking ideas seriously
- Being conscientious
- Being ambitious / entrepreneurial
- Being friendly / outgoing
- Having good strategic judgment in what activities their group should be doing
- Actively coming off as sharp in conversation, such that others find them fun to have object-level discussions with
Maybe this is just implicit? But it seems useful to make it explicit. Otherwise, this list kind of makes me think of really nice, friendly, hardworking philosophers who do not actually behave any more ethically. Great understanding and leadership is not enough; group leaders need to actually care about whatever the thing is. Maybe this is what "taking ideas seriously" is supposed to mean (I never quite understand that phrase, people seem to use it in different ways)? If so, it seems like a must have, not a nice to have.
Sorry about the delay on this answer. I do think it’s important that organizers genuinely care about the objectives of their group (which I think can be different from being altruistic, especially for non-effective altruism groups). I think you’re right that that’s worth listing in the must-have criteria, and I’ve added it now.
I assume the main reason this criteria wouldn’t be true is if someone wanted to do organizing work just for the money, which I think we should be trying hard to select against.
Here are answers to some other common questions about the University Organizer Fellowship that I received in office hours:
If I apply and get rejected, is there a “freezing period” where I can’t apply again?
We don’t have an official freezing period, but I think we generally won’t spend time reevaluating someone within 3 months of when they last applied, unless they give some indication on the application that something significant has changed in that time.
If you’re considering applying, I really encourage you to not to wait– I think for the vast majority of people considering applying, it won’t make a difference whether you apply now or a month from now.
Should I have prior experience doing group organizing or running EA projects before applying?
No – I care primarily about the criteria outlined here. Prior experience can be a plus, but it’s definitely not necessary, and it’s generally not the main factor in deciding whether or not to fund someone.
What is the timeline of the Century Fellowship/application? Is there a time when applications will be closed?
Who is responsible for evaluating the success of the Century Fellowship?
Interpreting this as “who is responsible for evaluating whether the Century Fellowship is a good use of time and money”, the answer is: someone on our team will probably try and do a review of how the program is going after it’s been running for a while longer; we will probably share that evaluation with Holden, co-CEO of Open Phil, as well as possibly other advisors and relevant stakeholders. Holden approves longtermist Open Phil grants and broadly thinks about which grants are/aren’t the best uses of money.
What role do different people in reviewing applications for the fellowship, and who fills those roles?
Each application has a primary evaluator who is on our team (current evaluators: me, Bastian Stern, Eli Rose, Kasey Shibayama, and Claire Zabel). We also generally consult / rely heavily on assessments from references or advisors, e.g. other staff at Open Phil or organizations who we work closely with, especially for applicants hoping to do work in domains we have less expertise in.
Edited.
I’m curious why you think that EA struggles to build a mainstream following ?
Open Philanthropy recently launched two new fellowships intended to provide funding for university group organizers: the University Group Organizer Fellowship (apply here), and the Century Fellowship (apply here). This post is intended to give some more color on the two programs, and our reasoning behind them. In the post, we cover:
We’d also like this post to function as an AMA for our university student-focused work. We’ll be answering questions August 4 - August 6, and will try to get through most of the highest-voted questions, though we may not get to everything. We welcome questions at any level, including questions about our future plans, criticisms of our funding strategy, logistical questions about the programs, etc.
If you’re a university group organizer or potential university group organizer and want to talk to us, I (Asya) will also be hosting virtual office hours August 5th and 6th (edit: added some time August 7th) – sign up to talk to me for 10 minutes here.
[Note about this post: The first two sections of this post were written by Asya Bergal, and the latter two were written by Claire Zabel; confusingly, both use the first-person pronouns “I” and “my”. We indicate in the post when the author switches.]
[The following sections of this post were written by Asya Bergal.]
The University Group Organizer Fellowship provides funding for organizers and group expenses for part-time and full-time organizers helping with student groups focused on effective altruism, longtermism, rationality, or other relevant topics at any university.
Unlike CEA’s previous program in this space:
More on the last point: while we ourselves are not providing this kind of support, we have and expect to refer groups we fund to others who are, including CEA’s University Group Accelerator Program, the Global Challenges Project, EA Cambridge, and other one-off programs and retreats.
Our current aim is to provide a smooth funding experience for strong group organizers who want to do this work, while mitigating potential negative impact from organizers who we don’t think are a good fit. We don’t plan or intend to “cover” the groups space, and actively encourage others in the space to consider projects supporting university groups, including projects that involve running groups, or providing more hands-on support and funding themselves. That being said, while we think there is room for many actors, we also think the space is sensitive, and it’s easy to do harm with this kind of work by giving bad advice to organizers, using organizer time poorly, or supporting organizers who we think will have a negative impact. We expect to have a high bar for supporting these projects, and to encourage the relevant teams to start by proving themselves on small scales.
We think there are a number of projects that we think could be valuable but have no clear “owner” in the student groups space right now, including:
Individuals looking to start projects supporting university groups can apply for funding from our team at Open Phil through our general application form.
The Century Fellowship is a selective 2-year program that gives resources and support (including $100K+/year in funding) to particularly promising people early in their careers who want to work to improve the long-term future. We hope to use it (in part) to support exceptionally strong full-time group organizers, and to make community building more broadly a more compelling career path (see below).
These criteria are the ones that I think are most important in a group organizer (and consider most strongly when making funding decisions):
Secondary “nice-to-have” desiderata include:
Notably, (and I think I may feel more strongly about this than others in the space), I’m generally less excited about organizers who are ambitious or entrepreneurial, but less truth-seeking, or have a weak understanding of the content that their group covers. In fact, I think organizers like this can be more risky than less entrepreneurial organizers, as they have the potential to misrepresent important ideas to larger numbers of people, putting off promising individuals or negatively affecting community culture in disproportionate ways.
Overall, I think student organizers have an outsized effect on the community and its culture, both by engaging other particular individuals, and more broadly by acting as representatives on college campuses, and we should accordingly have high standards for them. I similarly encourage student leaders to have high standards for the core members of their groups. I think groups will generally do better by my lights if they aim to have a small core membership with lots of high-quality object-level discussions, rather than focusing most of their attention on actively trying to attract more people. (I think it’s still worth spending substantial time doing outreach, especially at the beginning of the year.)
All of the above being said, my current policy is to be somewhat laxer on the “truth-seeking” and “strong understanding” criteria for a given organizer when:
So far, most of the organizers who have applied to us have met the conditions above — we’ve offered funding to 47 out of the 78 organizers who we’ve evaluated directly as part of the University Organizer Fellowship program.
[The following sections of this post were written by Claire Zabel.]
In addition to growing and expanding EA groups, we’re excited to see student groups experiment with other longtermist-relevant formats, such as AI safety reading groups or groups on existential risk or applied rationality. I think there are a couple reasons this is promising:
I want to make community-building a highly compelling career path, commensurate with the impact I think it’s had historically.
With the Century Fellowship especially, we hope to support particularly promising people (organizers and others) to flexibly explore and build towards different ambitious longtermist projects, with the security of longer-term support for themselves and collaborators.
I worry (and I think others have expressed concerns along these lines too) about potential downsides of funding in the student group space. There are at least a few different potential issues:
[Added by Asya:] We have our own views on who should and shouldn’t be funded to do this work, but those views could of course be mistaken. I don’t think it’s implausible that we come to believe we’ve made a mistake in either direction, e.g.:
Overall, we’re excited to support strong university groups, and to be able to offer more and more help to group organizers in the future! Thanks for bearing with us, and please share your questions and thoughts.
With some exceptions for jurisdictions where it is sensitive or prohibitively difficult for us to make grants. We encourage all groups to apply, and we can make the ultimate call about whether this is the case for us (and in some cases, may be able to connect groups with other suitable funders).
Do you feel that you'd rather have the existing population of community builders be a bit more ambitious or a bit more truth-seeking? Or: if you could suggest improvement on only one of these virtues to community builders, which would you choose? ETA: Does the answer feel obvious to you, or is it a close call?
(The cop-out answer is “I would like the truth-seeking organizers to be more ambitious, and the ambitious organizers to be more truth-seeking”.)
If I had to choose one, I think I’d go with truth-seeking. It doesn’t feel very close to me, especially among existing university group effective altruism-related organizers (maybe Claire disagrees), largely because I think there’s already been a big recent push towards ambition there, so I think people are generally already thinking pretty ambitiously.
I feel differently about e.g. rationality local group organizers, I wish they would be more ambitious.
Makes sense - thanks Asya!