I'm an iOS and Deep-Learning Engineer. I'm currently on a career transition looking in to a variety of impactful career paths.
Outside of work I'm a British nomad who likes chess, gaming, bouldering, anime and pretty much any other stereotypical hobby for a software engineer.
Thanks, I suspect this will be a better proxy of the best coding model than SWE-Bench-Pro is. FrontierSWE which it uses looks particularly interesting.
Does an increase in Anthropic's benchmark index accurately represent an equivalent rate of capability increase in well specified tasks?
As a SWE I've yet to find a reliable benchmark to compare different SWE capabilities between models. This year OpenAI stopped using SWE-Bench-Verified and a few months later ditched SWE-Bench-Pro. A large portion of the questions were broken or had been trained on.
I hesitated to comment as I've no background of Animal welfare campaigning and only learnt about most of these projects this summer myself. Given the downvoting and lack of responses though my reply is probably better than nothing and might encourage someone with more knowledge on this to improve upon my response.
The people and orgs you mention have the same aims as yourself, to reduce or eliminate the suffering factory farmed animals face and no doubt are putting a lot of their time and energy in to trying to accomplish this. I get that this is a repost intended for a different audience but I think some editing to make this more of a debate than a call to resistance would have been more fruitful.
Your analysis of who is behind them seems accurate to me and you're posting in the right place to have the people and orgs you mention see this post but you haven't really engaged with their ideas, made a case for why they're bad, and in some cases may be misrepresenting these initiatives.
Are you aware of whether the match was met last time? For tax reasons and because these aren't my usual charities this donation wouldn't be optimal for me but if this target is unlikely to be met it would be worth my time to research the charities and loss of tax return income in order to consider this.
It may be better to reframe this as: "this is great, please do more of this could you consider charity x and y for a future round." rather than a "I'm not donating this time please consider charity x and y instead"
I think the greater impact is to encourage them towards any EA charities rather than try to get them to replace one EA charity with our own personal preferences. I'm worried that them getting dozens of conflicting messages telling them to use different charities could even encourage them away from EA charities.
The opposite could be argued, that additional participation from small donors or publicity (such as this post) around the match scheme might encourage the large donor to allocate more of their giving budget to EA funds in future.
How do you call up HMRC to adjust your tax code? Do you need to know how much you will make / donate in advance to do this?
I've been filling out self assessments each year to do this and it's been getting more difficult each year. 2 years ago the online repayments stopped going through and I needed to call up their helpline. last year the helpline couldn't help me and I needed to write a letter to HMRC.
It seems like there would be a lot of benefits to having public impact assessments.
It verifies it's taken place, assures applicants a given talent programme is worth their time, gives talent programme orgs visibility on who's most effective and why, can be seen by other potential donors, and would allow the impact assessment process to be scrutinised and improved upon.
Maybe cG can't do this as making how they make donation decisions might corrupt their process. In this case the independent analysis fulfills a different purpose rather than being better or worse.
I think informing rejected candidates of how many people applied is another quick-win. The only time I've got figures on applicants is when I've got in to a fellowship or role and never when I've been rejected.
So far I've seen:
* Spar Projects with 1/50 applicants and 6/75 applicants accepted. (I've never got in to SPAR but have worked in an office with a SPAR mentor).
* Two fellowships where 20/140 and 15/170 were accepted respectively.
These were all unpaid positions (bar the last one which covered living expenses), I can only imagine applying for paid roles would be even more competitive.
I think having rejected candidates know how competitive these roles/courses/fellowships are would likely reduce the drop-out from the AIS talent pool so would be a win-win for both the applicants and the orgs.
The text is a bit hard to read when you zoom in on the images linked in this post.
The google drive link was high enough res, mostly commenting to make your work more accessible to people scanning the article.