After a while of just reading passively this forum, I finally felt compelled to join the discussion today! I am trying to find my way as to how to work/where to give to support the animals best, and found this piece interesting and thought-provoking (even if that's a lot of information and concepts to take in for me).
I see a lot of downvotes under this post but no comment nor response? That's really unfortunate, I would like to see what this community thinks of it and hopefully informative debates... Hope someone reads this!
Thank you Marie. It is disappointing that a community that prides itself on rational thinking, open debate, and radical transparency would simply downvote and bury this piece.
The people and orgs you mention have the same aims as yourself, to reduce or eliminate the suffering factory farmed animals face and no doubt are putting a lot of their time and energy in to trying to accomplish this. I get that this is a repost intended for a different audience but I think some editing to make this more of a debate than a call to resistance would have been more fruitful.
Your analysis of who is behind them seems accurate to me and you're posting in the right place to have the people and orgs you mention see this post but you haven't really engaged with their ideas, made a case for why they're bad, and in some cases may be misrepresenting these initiatives.
I hesitated to comment as I've no background of Animal welfare campaigning and only learnt about most of these projects this summer myself. Given the downvoting and lack of responses though my reply is probably better than nothing and might encourage someone with more knowledge on this to improve upon my response.
I’ve seen several articles & posts aghast at news that the Effective Altruism movement is funding, developing, and steering movement focus & finances away from veganism/animal rights and into innovations for the factory farming industry (including vegan-operated factory farms and labs and AI-enabled bio-engineering).
This includes: funding an organization (Spring Innovation Fund) to invest in, create, test, improve, market, & sell new factory farming technologies (and eventually sell the companies developing them).
Innovate Animal Ag is also launching an “Accelerator Farm” to similarly research new factory farming technologies on behalf of industry:
Innovate Animal Ag CEO Robert Yaman describing the animal welfare nonprofit’s factory farm during an interview with Niko McCarty on The New Biology.
There is also a proposal by Aidan Kankyoku(Anima International/Sentient Futures/Phauna Foundation/Direct Action Everywhere/Simple Heart/Save the Dogs/Pro-Animal Future/Pax Fauna) for vegans to give up the fights for animal liberation, veganism, & animal rights and instead join the factory farming industry to use artificial intelligence in bioengineering brainless chickens incapable of suffering.
I haven’t seen any in-depth discussion of who exactly is leading, funding, and promoting these initiatives (and relationships with some of its prominent vocal critics).
When I first heard that former vegan/animal rights/animal welfare activists were starting their own factory farm/slaughterhouse and developing factory farm tech on behalf of the animal ag industry, I assumed it was just some fringe relatively unknown newcomers.
In researching this article, I found a deeply entangled network of funders, fundees, and leaders involved with these current and growing initiatives. And the entangled relationships show a who’s who of animal rights/vegan/animal welfare advocacy leadership and funding from the past few decades.
The leaders, funders, and promoters of these initiatives and their financial and leadership entanglements include some of the most prominent public relations, lobbying, funding, and advocacy organizations in the animal welfare/veganism/animal rights movements.
When I looked closely, I was shocked to see the credentials of Spring Innovation Fund’s leaders & their deep connections into the big vegan/animal rights/animal welfare funders, organizations, and conferences (e.g. founders of Mercy For Animals and Animal Charity Evaluators; JUST, Beyond Meat, Mission Barns, Good Food Institute, Coefficient Giving/Dustin Moskovitz, Effective Ventures, Peter Singer, Manifold For Charity, etc).
It’s the same with Innovate Animal Ag (Mission Barns, Animal Charity Evaluators, Mercy For Animals, Effective Ventures, Dustin Moskovitz).
There are ultra-wealthy funders backing these initiatives…with premonitions of even greater windfalls to come with the OpenAI (ChatGPT) and Anthropic (Claude) AI IPO’s predicted for 2027.
However, there is also opposition from many prominent funders, leaders, media, and organizations.
The purpose of this article is to plainly lay out these connections and a call to durable, sustained, institutional and individual collective resistance to these initiatives.
I don’t hold out hope that these initiatives will be permanently shelved. But, in resistance, we can retain and reinforce parts of the movement that still put animal liberation, veganism, and animal rights ahead of animal welfare alone, industry relationships, prominence, and financial investments (organizational and individual).
Note: This article is based on publicly available sources from organizations’ own websites, social media, legally required financial filings, and other public journalism.
We do not yet have some organizations’ financial filings for 2024 to 2026.
This month effective altruism has gotten lots of attention, including a cover story in The Economist. It feels pretty surreal to be on the receiving end of it. But I feel grateful these ideas have caught on, and even more grateful for the drive, earnestness, and compassion of so many people who took strange but well-argued ideas seriously and then actually acted on them....
We’re the co-founders of Better Futures Guide (BFG), a charity evaluator specifically focused on livelihoods. We were founded last year through Ambitious Impact’s Charity Entrepreneurship Incubation Program. We welcome questions, criticism and opportunities for collaboration, in the comments or at [email protected].
...
TL;DR
* We recently set out RP’s strategic priorities and the three new bets we’re making in 2027.
* In this post, we outline what we need to make them happen.
* We need more support from individual donors, this year in particular.
* We’ve redirected roughly three-quarters of our 2026 unrestrict...
After a while of just reading passively this forum, I finally felt compelled to join the discussion today! I am trying to find my way as to how to work/where to give to support the animals best, and found this piece interesting and thought-provoking (even if that's a lot of information and concepts to take in for me).
I see a lot of downvotes under this post but no comment nor response? That's really unfortunate, I would like to see what this community thinks of it and hopefully informative debates... Hope someone reads this!
Thank you Marie.
It is disappointing that a community that prides itself on rational thinking, open debate, and radical transparency would simply downvote and bury this piece.