Sarah Cheng

Interim EA Forum Project Lead @ Centre for Effective Altruism
2680 karmaJoined Working (6-15 years)Cambridge, MA, USA

Bio

Participation
4

I worked as a software/product engineer at the Centre for Effective Altruism for three years, and recently became the Interim EA Forum Project Lead. If you'd like to support our work, sign up for a 30 min user interview with someone on our team. Hearing about your experience with the Forum helps us improve the site for everyone.

In general, we'd be happy to hear any feedback you have! :) Feel free to contact us or post in this suggestion thread. You can also give us anonymous feedback via this form.

Comments
189

Topic contributions
81

We've set up a Substack mirror for the Forum digest! 😊

  1. Please share and help us promote it! The primary reason we've set it up is to help with EA comms work and expand the reach of valuable Forum content.
  2. Please give us feedback — I'm not much of a Substack user myself, so any suggestions you have for improving it would be appreciated!
  3. We're still running the existing EA Forum Digest newsletter (via Mailchimp) for various reasons, including the fact that it's cleaner to integrate with the Forum itself. You can edit your subscription to that via the account settings page. (For example, if you prefer to read the Substack version, you can unsubscribe to the Mailchimp one.)

You can read more about this decision in Will's quick take here.

I appreciate you sharing your views on this! I agree that as a whole, this is suboptimal.

I don't currently feel confident enough about the take that "shallow criticism often gets valorized" to prioritize tackling it, though I am spending some time thinking about moderation and managing user-generated content and I expect that the mod team (including myself) will discuss how we'd like to handle critical comments, so this will probably come up in our discussions.

I'm kind of worried that there's not necessarily an objective truth to how shallow/low-quality any particular criticism is, and I personally would prefer to err on the side of allowing more criticism. So it's possible that not much changes in the public discourse, and any interventions we do may need to be behind the scenes (such as our team spending more time talking with people who get criticized).

Habryka, just wanted to say thank you for your contributions to the Forum. Overall I've appreciated them a lot! I'm happy that we'll continue to collaborate behind the scenes, at least because I think there's still plenty I can learn from you. I think we agree that running the Forum is a big responsibility, so I hope you feel free to share your honest thoughts with me.

I do think we disagree on some points. For example, you seem significantly more negative about CEA than I am (I'm probably biased because I work there, though I certainly don't think it's perfect). I also think that the discussions on the Forum do affect real change, though of course it's hard to know how much with any real confidence. I know of at least two specific cases when a person in a position with some power (in the real world, not in the EA community) has taken action based on something they read on the Forum, and my impression is that many people who have power within the EA community continue to read the Forum even if they don't make time to write here. Of course, it's true that they could ignore serious criticism is they wanted to, but my sense is that people actually quite often feel unable to ignore criticism. So I guess I am more optimistic that the Forum, as an extremely public community space, can continue to provide value by playing this role.

By the way, I personally care a lot about EA reaching its future potential for doing the most good. Habryka, I don't know the details of what you went through when trying to make things better, but I'm sorry to hear that it felt so bad. I'll just say that, if anyone feels like they are trying to make things better in EA and are unable to do so, you're welcome to reach out to me directly (you can message me via the Forum). I will at least hear you out and give you my thoughts, and perhaps you can convince me to help.

I'm excited to see an increase in the percentage of respondents doing earning to give! :) A lot of important work still needs funding, and I think effective giving is the most impactful option for many people.

Mini EA Forum Update

We've updated the user menu in the site header! 🎉 I'm really excited, since I think it looks way better and is much easier to use.

We've pulled out all the "New ___" items to a submenu, except for "New question" which you can still do from the "New post" page (it's still a tab there, as is linkpost). And you can see your quick takes via your profile page. See more discussion in the relevant PR.

Let us know what you think! 😊

Bonus: we've also added Bluesky to the list of profile links, feel free to add yours!

I've just updated the doc with a summary of the CEA Online Team's Q1.2 OKRs.

Thanks for the suggestion! This should be relatively quick to add so I'll see if we can do it soon. :) I was also thinking of setting up a bluesky bot account similar to our twitter account. Do you know how active the EA-ish bluesky community is?

I appreciate you saying this Nick — I totally agree with you and couldn't have said it better myself.

Thanks for the suggestion! It's cool to see that people use the vote history feature, since I made it as a random hackathon project. 😄 I like the idea of filtering by reaction! I'll add this to our backlog.

Thanks for flagging! It looks like they took the board down so I've removed the link. (For future reference, I believe anyone who has earned any karma can edit topic descriptions, so I think you could also remove any broken links directly.)

Load more