Holly Morgan's Quick takes

Holly Morgan's Quick takes

[anonymous]

1 min readJun 4, 2022

Frontpage

Comments 3

Sorted by

New & upvoted

[anonymous]

It's OK to ask "Who can DM me a quick review of [EA-run service]?"

Problem: It's costly for EAs to find out which EA-run services will actually help them.

An increasing number of EAs are offering services to the EA community
- E.g. coaching, therapy, research, training, recruiting, tech support, consulting
And it's useful to read honest reviews of services before using them
- Especially when it's costly to trial/use them
But it's awkward saying negative things about each other's work in public
- Sometimes people do anyway, but usually wrt large orgs where it's less personal

Proposed partial solution: Normalise asking for private reviews of each other's services.

This seems like a relatively low-cost way to access honest reviews that has a good shot at not being too socially awkward with some effort
I think it's generally too awkward at the moment to ask in spaces where the service providers themselves might also be hanging out
So potential users, try it and feel free to link to this Shortform to explain why you're doing A Bit Of An Awkward Thing; service providers, encourage potential users to do it

Thanks to Jennifer Waldmann and Ozzie Gooen for helping me think this through.

Arb

Strong upvote from us.

Two natural places to ask are Bountied Rationality and the EA twitter group.

[anonymous]

Following my own advice: I will not be offended if I see someone asking "Has anyone used Pineapple Operations who can send me a quick review in DM?" on the Forum or on Slack etc (although I think we're pretty low-cost to use at the moment, so maybe not the best example).

Comments

Curated and popular this week

If no one builds it, trillions die

Bruce Friedrich 🔸·1d ago·11m read

...

Instrumental convergence is incoherent (so pls slightly lower your p(extinction))

Arepo·6d ago·24m read

Crossposted to Less Wrong ‘Like most of life’s dangers, the dangers of artificial intelligence are not easily identified from the armchair.’ J Dmitri Gallow Epistemic status I’m not an expert in this field, and herein I make some sweeping generalisations educated guesses about the overall...

How to find out if mental health is ~10× more impactful than we thought

huw·1d ago·10m read

With the AI windfall, mental health may be taken increasingly seriously by mainstream EA. There’s increasingly room to explore the cause area and answer some of the biggest uncertainties; at the same time, costs of the most effective interventions are continuing to fall. StrongMinds is now treating for ~$35, about a third of GiveWell’s best guess from a few years ago, and is expected to...