When asking the person to rephrase their comment, it can be useful suggest a rewrite yourself.
Example: Someone noticed a commenter who appeared to be name calling another person. This is how they might have rewritten the comment: "I have this point of view because of this reason. I see other people with this different approach and I find it odd because it seems so much in conflict with what I've learned. I wonder how they got to that conclusion."
I found this suggestion kind of surprising upon re-reading. Do you have experiencing of it working well? I worry it could easily come across as somewhat patronising.
There was a string of writing on on this topic or closely related topics early in the forum's life, especially w.r.t. talking about cause prioritisation, so here are some links to those posts. AFAIK, the advice within largely still holds.
Robert Wiblin, Six Ways To Get Along With People Who Are Totally Wrong*
Jess Whittlestone, Supportive Scepticism
Michelle Hutchinson and Jess Whittlestone, Supportive Scepticism in Practice
Owen Cotton-Barratt, Keeping the Effective Altruism movement welcoming
I should also thank Owen for linking to most of these in his comment on the first link, which made collecting these quite a lot easier.
You can ask commenter(s) who are making unproductive comments to rephrase their comment(s) and express themselves in a friendlier or less confrontational tone.
FWIW, in a discussion about bias, discrimination and/or oppression, if this is done to a member of a marginalized group, this might be perceived as racist/sexist/etc. tone policing, and could make the discussion go worse.
The extraordinary value of ordinary norms by Emily Tench is a bit related. Several of the norms she covers concern good discussions and adjacent issues.
I’ve just noticed that the epistemic modesty section links to a less wrong tag on epistemic humility and talks about the distinction between the two terms (were epistemic modesty as a view is basically bad) I think this should be corrected to practice epistemic humility and not use modest epistemology or whatever it currently is.
I've linked to a few of these headings in an update to the Forum's About page. Thanks for writing this post!
Another solution: Expect everyone to be responsible for their own emotional experience of the Internet. Ignore all victim claims except in extreme circumstances such as death threats etc.
If someone says something to me and I get upset, I'm the one who chose to be upset. I'm the only person who can fix that.
There aren’t many resources on online discussion norms within the EA community, particularly for Facebook. Recently there have been some thoughtful discussions on online discussion norms and I thought it would be useful to compile some of the advice that has been shared in the last few months in one place, since I learnt a lot of helpful advice from those posts.
This is meant to be a collaborative post, so I’d be keen to hear further suggestions in the comments or directly to this google doc. Thank you to Sky Mayhew, Julia Wise, John Maxwell, David Nash and Geoffrey Yip for valuable contributions to the first version of this post.
Community members can help uphold and model good discussion norms, and also intervene when a discussion gets heated. Below are suggestions for what to do in both scenarios:
The following are some standard communication advice, most of which apply to many different kinds of discussion (in-person, online, 1-1, group). Each of these are tools that will be useful some of the time, but you don't have to do all of them every time. They may come in more useful when discussing particularly controversial topics.
“The drive not to make one idea win or another lose, but to see what’s there as honestly and accurately as you can.” (Julia Galef)
Some specific ways to do this:
Stop the conversation if you believe it is not productive or you don't wish to engage anymore. Sometimes, this may be the best outcome.
Some topics of conversation are best had in face-to-face, or real-time conversations. Consider taking the discussion to a private message or a call where you can work through information with more vulnerability.
Private 1-on-1 communications are much higher bandwidth, less ego-driven, and more amenable to the resolution of misunderstandings. You could post afterwards about what you learned and whether you changed your mind on anything. More on this.
If you are frustrated or angry by an online discussion, or don’t know what the best thing to do is, take some time before posting to reflect on the conversation, what your response might be and how it would be received, and how all of this would affect you.
You could talk to online discussion group moderators, local group organisers, trusted friends, colleagues, or CEA's community health team.
Note: You can find Facebook group moderators via the “Members” tab of each group and message them from there. When you report a post or comment, the moderators are notified. Since most moderators are volunteers, keep in mind they may be slow to respond.
If you’re not directly involved, you may be able to help defuse a situation or prevent it from escalating. It will likely be easier to de-escalate a conversation before it gets too heated, and the main thing you could do here is to change the tone of the conversation as early as possible, since combativeness can beget combativeness.
Read Moderating Online Spaces by Julia Wise (CEA) about starting and moderating groups. It contains tips on the audience, topics of discussion, group policies and moderation.
I made two visual guides that could be used to improve online discussions. These could be dropped into any conversation to (hopefully) make the discussion more productive.
The first is an update on Grahams hierarchy of disagreement
I improved the lay-out of the old image and added a top layer for steelmanning. You can find my reasoning here and a link to the pdf-file of the image here.
The second is a hierarchy of evidence:
I added a bottom layer for personal opinion. You can find the full image and pdf-file here.
Lastly I wanted to share the Toulmin method of argumentation, which is an excellent guide for a general pragmatic approach to arguments
Hi Bob,
The 1st 2 images are not loading for me.
The last image is fine.
Hi Vasco,
Thanks for notifying me, it's probably because the EA forum switched editors (and maybe also compression algorithm) a while back. I remember struggling with adding images to the forum in the beginning, and now it's easy.
I looked at some old posts and it seems like those that used .png and .jpg still displayed them, so people don't need to check up on their old posts. I looked at older comments and both .jpg and .png still work from three years back. I also found an .png in a comment from five years back. Hopefully this helps the devs with debugging, and maybe people should check on their .jpg comments from four years ago or older (mine were jpegs). I reuploaded them and they were visible in another browser, so I think it should be good now.
Thanks, Bob! Yes, I can see the images now.
I just added the first of these images to the Forum's About page. These are some of my favorite EA-produced infographics; thanks so much for making them!
This is late but thanks for this Bob! these are really helpful. I've added them to the Google Doc as well.