69:"CommentsListProvider" 6a:I[840128,["$4","$5","$6","$7","$8","$9","$a","$b","$c","$d","$e","$f","$3a","$3b","$3c"],"$69"] 6b:T94f,

Startups aren't good for learning

I fairly frequently have conversations with people who are excited about starting their own project and, within a few minutes, convince them that they would learn less starting project than they would working for someone else. I think this is basically the only opinion I have where I can regularly convince EAs to change their mind in a few minutes of discussion and, since there is now renewed interest in starting EA projects, it seems worth trying to write down.

It's generally accepted that optimal learning environments have a few properties:

You are doing something that is just slightly too hard for you.
- In startups, you do whatever needs to get done. This will often be things that are way too easy (answering a huge number of support requests) or way too hard (pitching a large company CEO on your product when you've never even sold bubblegum before).
- Established companies, by contrast, put substantial effort into slotting people into roles that are approximately at their skill level (though you still usually need to put in proactive effort to learn things at an established company).
Repeatedly practicing a skill in "chunks"
- Similar to the last point, established companies have a "rhythm" where e.g. one month per year where everyone has a priority of writing up reflections on how the sales cycle is going, commenting on each other's writeups, and updating your own. Startups do things by the seat of their pants, which means employees are usually rapidly switching between tasks.
Feedback from experts/mentorship
- Startup accelerators like YCombinator partially address this, but still a defining characteristic of starting your own project is that you are doing the work without guidance/oversight.

Moreover, even supposing you learn more at a startup, it's worth thinking about what it actually is you learn. I know way more about the laws regarding healthcare insurance than I did before starting a company, but that knowledge isn't super useful to me outside the startup context.

This isn't a 100% universal knockdown argument – some established companies suck for professional development, and some startups are really great. But by default, I would expect startups to be worse for learning.

6c:Tf83,

Anonymous Feedback Form

(click "see more")

I'm happy to help

People running EA aligned software projects (about all the normal problems)
EA Software engineers (about.. all the normal problems)

Link to my coaching post.

I'd be happy for help from

People who think about global EA priorities:
- Rewriting arxiv.org: Is this a high impact job?
- Does EA need a really good hiring agency?
Funding my work would be nice

My opinions about hiring

Common mistakes with hiring
Scaring off candidates
An example hiring post I wrote (for CEA)
[more coming]
[please reach out if you'd like help with this]

A better job board

draft 1: 75% of 80k's engineering jobs are unrelated to software development. This board is the other 25%.

Tech community building & outreach

(apparently I'm doing some of this?)

Some ideas I'm working on or strongly considering working on
Are you talking to someone about working on strange neglected problems? Here's how I'd frame it

My opinions about EA software careers

An alternative career guide
Improving CVs (beyond what I saw any professional CV editor doing)
Getting your first paid software job
[more coming]

My personal fit for jobs

Owning the tech of a pre-production (helping with things around it, like some Product)
I really enjoy coaching, user research, explaining tech concepts and tradeoffs simply to non tech people, unclear if this will fit into some future job

Fun

I'm currently reading ProjectLawful and Worth A Candle [26-7-2022]
Big hpmor fan
I like VR
My shirts have cats on them

Contact details

Telegram (though we should probably move to Signal, right?)
Calendly

6d:T407,

Longform's missing mood

If your content is viewed by 100,000 people, making it more concise by one second saves an aggregate of one day across your audience. Respecting your audience means working hard to make your content shorter.

When the 80k podcast describes itself as "unusually in depth," I feel like there's a missing mood: maybe there's no way to communicate the ideas more concisely, but this is something we should be sad about, not a point of pride.^[1]

I'm unfairly picking on 80k, I'm not aware of any long-form content which has this mood that I claim is missing ↩︎

6e:T8e1,

This is a thoughtful post and a really good sentiment IMO!

When the 80k podcast describes itself as "unusually in depth," I feel like there's a missing mood: maybe there's no way to communicate the ideas more concisely, but this is something we should be sad about, not a point of pride.

As you touched on, I’m not sure 80k is a good negative example, to me it seems like a positive example of how to handle this?

In addition to a tight intro, 80k has a great highlight section, that to me, looks like someone smart tried to solve this exact problem, balancing many considerations.

This highlight section has good takeaways and is well organized with headers. I guess this is useful for 90% of people who only browse at the content for 1 minute.

6f:T887,

I'm a researcher at Forethought; before that, I ran the non-engineering side of the EA Forum (this platform), ran the EA Newsletter, and worked on some other content-related tasks at CEA. [More about the Forum/CEA Online job.]

Selected posts

Background

I finished my undergraduate studies with a double major in mathematics and comparative literature in 2021. I was a research fellow at Rethink Priorities in the summer of 2021 and was then hired by the Events Team at CEA. I later switched to the Online Team. In the past, I've also done some (math) research and worked at Canada/USA Mathcamp.

70:Taa6,

The Forum moderation team has been made aware that Kerry Vaughn published a tweet thread that, among other things, accuses a Forum user of doing things that violate our norms. Most importantly:

Where he crossed the line was his decision to dox people who worked at Leverage or affiliated organizations by researching the people who worked there and posting their names to the EA forum

The user in question said this information came from searching LinkedIn for people who had listed themselves as having worked at Leverage and related organizations.

This is not "doxing" and it’s unclear to us why Kerry would use this term: for example, there was no attempt to connect anonymous and real names, which seems to be a key part of the definition of “doxing”. In any case, we do not consider this to be a violation of our norms.

At one point Forum moderators got a report that some of the information about these people was inaccurate. We tried to get in touch with the then-anonymous user, and when we were unable to, we redacted the names from the comment. Later, the user noticed the change and replaced the names. One of CEA’s staff asked the user to encode the names to allow those people more privacy, and the user did so.

Kerry says that a former Leverage staff member “requests that people not include her last name or the names of other people at Leverage” and indicates the user broke this request. However, the post in question requests that the author’s last name not be used in reference to that post, rather than in general. The comment in question doesn’t refer to the former staff member’s post at all, and was originally written more than a year before the post. So we do not view this comment as disregarding someone’s request for privacy.

Kerry makes several other accusations, and we similarly do not believe them to be violations of this Forum's norms. We have shared our analysis of these accusations with Leverage; they are, of course, entitled to disagree with us (and publicly state their disagreement), but the moderation team wants to make clear that we take enforcement of our norms seriously.

We would also like to take this opportunity to remind everyone that CEA’s Community Health team serves as a point of contact for the EA community, and if you believe harassment or other issues are occurring we encourage you to reach out to them.

71:T25d9,

Hi Ben,

Thank you for your attention to this matter. I must confess that I found the response confusing as you seem to be responding to claims slightly (though importantly!) different from the ones I made in my Twitter post.

Specifically, my view is (1) you are mistaken about the definition of doxing and have instead provided a definition of deanonymization; (2) this person’s behavior meets the definitions of doxing; (3) norms that allow these posts would also allow more serious abuses.

I’d also like to clarify that I am not at the moment accusing you or the EA Forum moderators of failing to enforce EA Forum rules or norms in this case. I am not deeply familiar with the EA Forum rules or norms, so I am indifferent on this question.

This poster violated the norms that I think would be reasonable for a high-quality discussion forum. I also think this poster violated standards of reasonable behavior for a person with high-status membership in an intellectual community. I leave the question of EA Forum rules and norms to you and your team.

Additionally, while I alluded to but did not directly discuss this in the Twitter thread, the EA Forum moderation team took several actions that lessened the harm this poster intended to cause. While I think further actions are warranted, I would nevertheless like to express my gratitude to the team for what they have already done.

On the definition of doxing

The user in question said this information came from searching LinkedIn for people who had listed themselves as having worked at Leverage and related organizations. This is not "doxing" and it’s unclear to us why Kerry would use this term: for example, there was no attempt to connect anonymous and real names, which seems to be a key part of the definition of “doxing”.

This is not the definition of doxing.

A simple internet search reveals the following definitions:

Wikipedia: “Doxing or doxxing is the act of publicly providing personally identifiable information about an individual or organization, usually via the Internet. . . . Doxing may be carried out for reasons such as online shaming, extortion, and vigilante aid to law enforcement”

Urban Dictionary: “Using private information gleaned from the internet to attack someone with whom you disagree, often by publishing their personal info, opening them to abuse and possibly, danger.”

What you provide is the definition of the much narrower activity of deanonymization. I agree that the poster’s behavior is not deanonymization. I never indicated otherwise.

Deanonymization is neither a necessary nor sufficient condition for doxing. It is possible to dox someone even if they maintain no anonymous identities (e.g., by publishing non-public information that does not pertain to an anonymous identity for the purposes of harassment). It is also possible to reveal a person’s anonymous identity without doxing them if the reveal involves neither ill intent nor ill effects.

Why the poster’s behavior is doxing

Doxing has two important components: (1) revealing private information; (2) with ill-intent. Below I argue that the poster’s behavior meets both of these standards.

The information was private

In the EA Forum comment where the doxing occurred, the poster says the following (emphasis mine):

Paradigm Academy does not list its team on its website. However, a quick search on Linkedin yields 16 results (13 with public profiles) for people at Paradigm Academy. Of these 13 profiles, 7 include experience at Leverage Research or allied organizations, and a further 4 are well-known to have worked for Leverage Research.

The term “well-known” indicates that the information is not on their LinkedIn profiles, but is known to the poster. Thus, they relied on non-public information to associate the people with the organizations.

However, even if the poster had used only information from LinkedIn profiles and not their own knowledge, this would still constitute a reveal of private information because “private information” is context-dependent. Almost all canonical cases of doxing involve taking information that is findable on the public internet (albeit with difficulty) and then revealing that information in an adversarial context.

Consider, for example, the high-profile case of the doxing of Scott Alexander. Scott Alexander’s real name was not private in the sense of “not findable on the public internet.” Indeed, it could be revealed with a little bit of dedicated Googling. It was also widely known inside the EA and Rationality community. The Times’ threat to publish his real name was nevertheless a threat to dox him because it was not well-known to the readership of The Times.

Who was employed at Leverage and Paradigm was not well-known to the members of the EA community. Most of those who worked at Leverage and Paradigm had little interaction with the EA community. Thus, the information revealed was private in the relevant sense.

The poster acted with ill-intent

There are several ways to see that the poster acted with ill intent.

(1) The social context of this post is that there was a deterioration of the relationship between the Effective Altruism and Leverage Research communities. This is easy to see by reviewing the comments on the “Basic Facts” post, which are substantially negative. While one might dispute that the negativity is fair, accurate, or deserved, it was not considered so by members of Leverage or Paradigm staff. Thus, the EA Forum is an adversarial context from the perspective of Leverage and Paradigm employees.

(2) A review of the posting history of the anonymoose and throwaway accounts indicates that their primary goal was to spread negative information about Leverage and Paradigm.

(3) The context in which the people are doxed is in response to the following “question:” “To what extent is Paradigm Academy a front organization for, or a covert rebrand of Leverage Research?”

This is, of course, a quite blatant attempt to insulate nefariousness where none is warranted. There was never any attempt to conceal the relationship between Leverage and Paradigm by the staff of either organization. No information to indicate otherwise is ever presented by the poster.

(4) There is simply no reason to include the people’s names except for the purposes of doxing. The point of the comment is that there is a heavy association between people that worked at Paradigm and those that worked at Leverage. There is no reason that specific names need to be included to make this point.

(5) The post violated the letter and spirit of Cathleen’s request.

On this point, Ben indicates the following:

Kerry says that a former Leverage staff member “requests that people not include her last name or the names of other people at Leverage” and indicates the user broke this request. However, the post in question requests that the author’s last name not be used in reference to that post, rather than in general. The comment in question doesn’t refer to the former staff member’s post at all, and was originally written more than a year before the post. So we do not view this comment as disregarding someone’s request for privacy.

However, the full request by Cathleen is as follows (emphasis mine):

In discussions of this post (the content of which I can’t predict or control), I’d ask that you just refer to me as Cathleen, to minimize the googleable footprint. And I would also ask that, as I’ve done here, you refrain from naming others whose identities are not already tied up in all this.

As there is some confusion on this point, it is important to be clear. The central complaint in the Twitter thread is that *5 days* after Cathleen’s post, the poster edited their comment to add the names of Leverage and Paradigm employees back to the comment, including Cathleen’s last name. This violates Cathleen’s request.

Ben is correct that the comment originally occurred substantially before Cathleen’s post. But this is immaterial. The point is that the poster re-added the names after the request had been made.

Norms that allow these posts would also allow more serious abuses

A further issue with this understanding of EA norms is that it would allow more serious abuses on the EA Forum. If this is not clear, I can provide some examples.

72:T514,

However, even if the poster had used only information from LinkedIn profiles and not their own knowledge, this would still constitute a reveal of private information because “private information” is context-dependent.

If you list your organizational affiliation on LinkedIn (and if you are indeed correct that Paradigm Academy was not trying to be a cover for Leverage Research that shielded it from public scrutiny), then I don't think you get to complain when someone quickly googles you and finds your LinkedIn profile.

Like, if Scott Alexander had listed his real name on his about page, or on LinkedIn, connected to his pseudonym, then yeah, I would have also had very little sympathy for the objections to the New York Times. There clearly are degrees of what kind of connections you can make here, and searching an organization on LinkedIn really does not cross any obvious line here.

Maybe you are objecting to drawing a connection between Leverage Research and Paradigm Academy, but you are also saying that nobody was saying that Paradigm Academy was intentionally trying to not appear to be part of what was broadly known as "Leverage", so I don't understand how you can make both of these arguments at the same time.

73:Tcf3,

[Disclaimer, I have very little context on this & might miss something obvious and important]

In discussions of this post (the content of which I can’t predict or control), I’d ask that you just refer to me as Cathleen, to minimize the googleable footprint. And I would also ask that, as I’ve done here, you refrain from naming others whose identities are not already tied up in all this.
As there is some confusion on this point, it is important to be clear. The central complaint in the Twitter thread is that *5 days* after Cathleen’s post, the poster edited their comment to add the names of Leverage and Paradigm employees back to the comment, including Cathleen’s last name. This violates Cathleen’s request.

AFAICT the disagreement between Kerry and Ben stems from interpreting the second part of Cathleen's ask differently. There seem to be two ways of reading the second part:
1. Asking people to refrain from naming others who are not already tied into this in general.
2. Asking people to refrain from naming others who are not already tied into this in discussions of her post.

To me, it seems pretty clear that she means the latter, given the structure of the two sentences. If she was aiming for the first interpretation, I think she should have used a qualifier like "in general" in the second sentence. In the current formulation, the "And" at the beginning of the sentence connects the first ask/sentence very clearly to the second.
I guess this can be up for debate, and one could interpret it differently, but I would certainly not fault anyone for going with interpretation 2.^[1]

If we assume that 2 is the correct reading, Kerry's claim (cited above) does not seem relevant anymore / Ben's original remark (cited below) seems correct. The timeline of edits doesn't change things. Ben's original remark (emphasis mine):

The comment in question doesn’t refer to the former staff member’s post at all, and was originally written more than a year before the post. So we do not view this comment as disregarding someone’s request for privacy.

^{^}
Even if she meant interpretation 1, it is unclear to me that this would be a request that I would endorse other people enforcing. Her request in interpretation 2 seems reasonable, in part because it seems like an attempt to avoid people using her post in a way she doesn't endorse. A general "don't associate others with this organisation" would be a much bigger ask. I would not endorse other organisations asking the public not to connect its employees to them (e.g. imagine a GiveWell employee making the generic ask not to name other employees/collaborators in posts about GiveWell), and the Forum team enforcing that.

74:T626,

If you list your organizational affiliation on LinkedIn (and if you are indeed correct that Paradigm Academy was not trying to be a cover for Leverage Research that shielded it from public scrutiny), then I don't think you get to complain when someone quickly googles you and finds your LinkedIn profile.

First, as I noted in my response to Ben, some of the information included in the doxing was from the poster's personal knowledge and not from the people's LinkedIn profiles. Thus, you can't defend the doxing by saying that the information was publicly available. It simply wasn't.

Second, I am not complaining about someone quickly googling anyone and finding their LinkedIn profile. I am complaining about making it easier to harass people by posting a central repository of information about those people on a forum frequented by people with a history of harassing them.

It is certainly the case that former Leveragers took the release of their names on the EA forum as an attempt to invite harassment by members of the EA community. We were contacted by former Leveragers to see if there was anything we could do to get the names removed for this very reason.

I suspect the actual crux of the discussion here is that most EAs are unaware of the history of poor and bizarre behavior towards Leverage/Paradigm by members of the EA community. To help with the knowledge gap, I’m considering writing a Twitter thread that will share some of the most egregious examples.

75:T463,

Hi Ben,

Another question I wanted to ask is whether the EA Forum has rules against creating sock puppet accounts. This is defined as follows:

Wikipedia: “Online, it came to be used to refer to a false identity assumed by a member of an internet community who spoke to, or about, themselves while pretending to be another person.”

Urban dictionary: “A false identity adopted by trolls and other malcontents to support their own postings.”

I ask because it appears to me that the poster acted deceptively in managing their multiple anonymous accounts by (1) using a second anonymous account to reply to their first anonymous account; (2) promoting the actions of their anonymous account from their public account without disclosing that they were behind the anonymous account.

Most forums I’ve been a part of have rules against sockpuppeting, but reviewing the EA Forum rules and guidelines, I did not see anything about that.

76:T4967,

How I wish the EA Forum had responded

I’ve found that communicating feedback/corrections often works best when I write something that approximates what I would’ve wished the other person had originally written.

Because of the need to sync more explicitly on a number of background facts and assumptions (and due to not having time for edits/revisions), my draft is longer than I think a moderator’s comment would need to be, were the moderation team to be roughly on the same page about the situation. While I am the Cathleen being referenced, I have had minimal contact with Leverage 2.0 and the EA Forum moderation team, so I expect this draft to be imperfect in various ways, while still pointing at useful and important parts of reality.

Here I’ve made an attempt to rewrite what I wish Ben West had posted in response to Kerry’s tweet thread:

The Forum moderation team has been made aware that Kerry Vaughn published a tweet thread that, among other things, accuses a Forum user of doing things that violate our norms. Most importantly:

Where he crossed the line was his decision to dox people who worked at Leverage or affiliated organizations by researching the people who worked there and posting their names to the EA forum.

We care a lot about ensuring that the EA Forum is a welcoming place where people are free to discuss important issues related to world improvement. While disagreement and criticism are an important part of that, we want to be careful not to allow for abuse to take place on our platform, and so we take such reports seriously.

After reviewing the situation, we have compiled the following response (our full review is still in process but we wanted to share what we have so far while the issue is live):

While Leverage was not a topic that we had flagged as “sensitive” back in Sept 2019 when the then-anonymous user originally made his post, the subsequent discussion around the individuals and organizations who were part of the Leverage/Paradigm ecosystem prior to its dissolution in June 2019 has led it to be classified as a sensitive topic to which we expend more scrutiny and are more diligent about enforcing our norms.

In reviewing the particular post referenced above, we found a number of odd elements:

In posing and then answering his own "Question" on the EA Forum, the user makes his accusation of Paradigm (the org) being a front or a secret replacement for Leverage (the org) despite having previously acknowledged the recent dissolution of the Leverage/Paradigm ecosystem (and in a context where the two organizations were publicly known to be closely connected).
The user largely acts as if he is sharing work history discovered on LinkedIn as his primary argument despite only 2 of the 13 named individuals having Leverage listed on their LinkedIn profiles.
The user names 4 additional people as having worked at Leverage despite citing no evidence of that fact (they did not have Leverage on their LinkedIn profiles).
The user then names 7 additional individuals who did not have Leverage on their LinkedIn profiles and who the user also did not believe to have originally worked at Leverage.
The user neglects to include any context or timelines from LinkedIn, e.g. whether there had been a recent change in work history at the point of the ecosystem dissolution, whether the individuals in question started at Leverage and then moved to Paradigm, started at Paradigm and then moved to Leverage, or started at either Leverage or Paradigm and then moved on to other projects. It is also unclear which, if any, continued to work at either Leverage or Paradigm after the ecosystem dissolution.
More than 2 years later, after reading a clarifying and detailed post about the relevant history of Leverage and Paradigm (which included a request to protect people's identities) and discovering that the Forum mods had removed the named individuals from his comment, the only edit the user decided to make was to deanonymize the names he’d compiled of people previously affiliated with the Leverage ecosystem.

When this post was initially brought to our attention in July of 2020, along with an explanation of possible negative consequences for the people listed (including ~4 individuals who the user was spreading potential misinformation about), we tried to get in touch with the then-anonymous user, and when we were unable to, we redacted the names from the comment and left an explanation for how the comment could make its point without using the personal information of the named individuals.

At the time, we had been informed that the user was mistaken about the work history for some of the people he listed, in large part due to relying on his incorrect personal assumptions. We did not consider the way that some of the 4 (and possibly others) might’ve intentionally excluded Leverage from their work histories, as we were focused on the ones who were incorrectly identified as having worked at Leverage and the potential consequences of that misinformation. Without yet knowing or investigating the full extent of the anonymous user’s posting history across multiple accounts, we did not suspect a pattern of hostile posts. Because of these factors, we did not evaluate whether this post might be a case of doxing.

In Dec 2021, Cathleen, one of the 4 who had been listed as working at Leverage (despite no record on LinkedIn), published a detailed account of her experience at Leverage/Paradigm. In it, she shared her perspective on harassment and ill-will that had come from the EA and Rationalist community members, and the negative effects of misinformation spread via public community forums. She explained why she had intentionally excluded Leverage from her LinkedIn many years prior and asked that people protect her identity as well as the identities of others from the Leverage ecosystem due to the risk of cancellation and harassment.

A few days later, the EA Forum user (who had revealed his real identity a couple months prior) returned to his anonymous post from Sept 2019 and deanonymized the first and last names of all 13 individuals he had previously named. This included Cathleen as well as the other 3 individuals who he attributed to Leverage (despite no record on LinkedIn). He accompanied the edits with a false/misleading comment (using the anonymous account) minimizing the substantive merit of prior requests for corrections to his post and claiming that all of the relevant information had actually been originally drawn from LinkedIn.

(At a cursory glance, it’s difficult to determine the most natural interpretation of the scope of Cathleen’s request, in order to assess the likelihood that the user was knowingly violating her wishes. We initially had a quite narrow interpretation, reading the quote out of context, but I think the situation becomes clearer if you take the time to read her entire post or the section that the quote was pulled from, entitled "We want to move forward with our lives (and not be cancelled)", which includes a direct reference to LinkedIn/her intent to keep her work history private.)

After receiving a new complaint about the potential harm of listing individuals' names, including the spread of misinformation caused by the user’s updated post, we reviewed the case and this time found no violation. As a compromise, we did offer to ask the user if they would be willing to encode the full names to help protect the individuals from potential negative effects arising from a simple google search.

We have since realized that many people (including people on our moderation team) took the user at his word without carefully reviewing the post. We had become confused about the specifics (falsely believing that he was sharing publicly available information from LinkedIn and thus believing that the information could be reasonably treated as true and that the objections raised were splitting hairs). We also did not accurately recognize the general nature/intent of his original post nor the potential negative effects of allowing the information to stand, and we did not evaluate the deanonymizing edits in the context of Cathleen’s recent public request and voiced concerns.

In Oct 2021, when the user had revealed his identity and his use of multiple anonymous accounts, we also failed to review the complete body of evidence and the ways that his actions had potentially violated our norms (e.g. using multiple anonymous accounts to convey similar views on a topic), as well as notice that the full pattern of posts indicated a type of ill-will that we discourage and that is especially relevant given the sensitive nature of the topic of Leverage/Paradigm.

In retrospect, we recognize that while we would like to give users the benefit of the doubt, when there are complaints of doxing, harassment, or other poor behavior, it makes sense for us to look more carefully at the situation and potentially draw on CEA’s Community Health team’s expertise in assisting individuals who flag that they’ve been wronged by a user on the Forum.

Something else we did not consider (because we unfortunately don’t have the bandwidth to track all the goings on in the EA and Rationalist communities) is that the level of threat experienced by people who had previously been part of the Leverage ecosystem had become quite high. In evaluating cases of disclosing private information or even assembling and publishing public information, context matters.

As an example:

On the face of it, it seems fine to have openly communist views or be LGBTQ, but history has shown us that during certain eras, e.g. the Second Red Scare in the US, creating and posting lists of such people (even if true or otherwise individually knowable) would likely subject them to harassment or worse.

It is not an excuse if someone else could create a similarly damaging list, and it doesn’t seem right to ask people to hide their work history from potential employers on a professional networking platform for the sole purpose of protecting themselves from being subject to defamatory public posts from ill-willed and/or ill-informed EAs and Rationalists. It is already unfortunate that the damage to the reputation of the relevant orgs has made it difficult for individuals to decide when and how to associate themselves with their former projects.

Guilt by association is not a good faith argument here, and at a minimum, it seems reasonable to honor individual wishes for Forum users to refrain from using their full names in affiliation with prior projects when requested (and to be careful not to do so in a way that falsely implies that the person is (or should be) ashamed of their affiliation).

After reviewing the overall situation, we think it’s important for users as well as moderators to recognize that posts about former Leverage/Paradigm staff do not happen in a vacuum. We strongly condemn the sharing of information about an individual’s prior professional or social affiliation in a way that intentionally or negligently exposes them to undue negative consequences.

If people are proud of their work at an organization but feel the need to disassociate themselves from that org publicly, it seems like something has gone wrong.

Given the overall pattern of posts from this user’s accounts across the EA Forum as well as Less Wrong from 2018-2021, it seems plausible to our team that the actions of this user may have actually been a significant contributing factor in fomenting negative sentiment towards this group of people. In light of that, making the decision to list their full names in this comment in 2019 and then editing the comment to include them again in 2021, after Cathleen’s detailed post (which includes information relevant to the comment’s hypothesis as well as a request and argument for privacy), we find it harder to defend an interpretation where there was not an intent to cause harm to the named individuals.

Further, it is our understanding that only a fraction of those named worked for Leverage or Paradigm at the time of the original post, and only ~1 to 2 of those named worked for Leverage or Paradigm at the time of the subsequent deanonymizing edit; given that, and with the assumption that the argument for both relevancy of the post on the EA Forum as well as the argument for wrongdoing relies solely on the pattern of employment at these orgs, the weighing of potential benefit/value vs. cost/harm to prior project members seems particularly clear.

Intimidation and harassment can be executed in subtle ways, and while intent can be hard to ascertain, we encourage participants on the Forum to put in extra effort to ward against their posts landing in a gray area.

We don’t think that every case of bad behavior needs to fit neatly into our listed norms (and in evaluating cases like these, we also think it makes sense to revisit our listed norms to see if we should make changes for clarity or scope)^[1], but it seems clear to us that the type of behavior exhibited by this user across their anonymous accounts is neither generous nor collaborative and it also seems likely to interfere with good discourse (not least of all by creating a hostile environment for some members of the community).

While we wish we would’ve done better, given our knowledge at the time, we don’t see this as a major failing, but we do recognize the harm that was caused and we want to emphasize that the use of anonymous accounts to harass individuals or groups is not something that we tolerate.

We have referred this case to the CEA Community Health team for further review. They will look at the totality of content from this user on this and related topics, examining patterns, severity, as well as the time period spanned by relevant posts and comments on the EA Forum as well as LW, as a way of assessing potential and actual negative impacts and intent. With the permission of relevant parties, they will also review registered complaints about the user’s behavior. With their input, we will deliberate further and decide whether there is mitigating action that the Forum moderators can and should take in this particular case.

If you have a world improvement related issue that you believe needs public attention but aren’t sure how to navigate it while minimizing unnecessary harm, we encourage you to reach out to the CEA Community Health team who can help organize your thoughts and perhaps mediate a discussion where more information can be exchanged before escalating to a public post. We recognize that in a situation where you suspect a conspiracy or are otherwise suspicious of others’ actions, it may be harder to prioritize the discussion norms of the Forum, but it is in those moments that the norms are most important to respect.

Be kind.
Stay civil, at the minimum. Don’t sneer or be snarky. In general, assume good faith. We may delete unnecessary rudeness and issue warnings or bans for it.
Substantive disagreements are fine and expected. Disagreements help us find the truth and are part of healthy communication.
Stay on topic.
No spam. This forum is for discussions about improving the world, not the promotion of services.
Be honest.
Don’t mislead or manipulate.
Communicate your uncertainty and the true reasons behind your beliefs as much as you can.
Be willing to change your mind.

^{^}
*(The Forum moderators are currently grappling with an issue that may be relevant to situations involving sensitive topics like these: it does not violate our norms to inadvertently publish false or misleading information – but in the case that a correction or material clarification is made and the OP doesn’t update their post or comment, an argument could be made that the user is either in violation of the norm of scout mindset/willingness to update their view, or (if they do update their understanding but don’t update their post) they could be in violation of knowingly/deliberately spreading misinformation. We generally have not wanted to act as the arbiters of truth, so it’s not yet clear how to best moderate a situation like this.)

77:T145f,

I run Sentinel, a team that seeks to anticipate and respond to large-scale risks. You can read our weekly minutes here. I like to spend my time acquiring deeper models of the world, and generally becoming more formidable. I'm also a fairly good forecaster: I started out on predicting on Good Judgment Open and CSET-Foretell, but now do most of my forecasting through Samotsvety, of which Scott Alexander writes:

Enter Samotsvety Forecasts. This is a team of some of the best superforecasters in the world. They won the CSET-Foretell forecasting competition by an absolutely obscene margin, “around twice as good as the next-best team in terms of the relative Brier score”. If the point of forecasting tournaments is to figure out who you can trust, the science has spoken, and the answer is “these guys”.

I used to post prolifically on the EA Forum, but nowadays, I post my research and thoughts at nunosempere.com / nunosempere.com/blog rather than on this forum, because:

I disagree with the EA Forum's moderation policy—they've banned a few disagreeable people whom I like, and I think they're generally a bit too censorious for my liking.
The Forum website has become more annoying to me over time: more cluttered and more pushy in terms of curated and pinned posts (I've partially mitigated this by writing my own minimalistic frontend)
The above two issues have made me take notice that the EA Forum is beyond my control, and it feels like a dumb move to host my research in a platform that has goals different from my own.

But a good fraction of my past research is still available here on the EA Forum. I'm particularly fond of my series on Estimating Value.

My career has been as follows:

Before Sentinel, I set up my own niche consultancy, Shapley Maximizers. This was very profitable, and I used the profits to bootstrap Sentinel. I am winding this down, but if you have need of estimation services for big decisions, you can still reach out.
I used to do research around longtermism, forecasting and quantification, as well as some programming, at the Quantified Uncertainty Research Institute (QURI). At QURI, I programmed Metaforecast.org, a search tool which aggregates predictions from many different platforms—a more up to date alternative might be adj.news. I spent some time in the Bahamas as part of the FTX EA Fellowship, and did a bunch of work for the FTX Foundation, which then went to waste when it evaporated.
I write a Forecasting Newsletter which gathered a few thousand subscribers; I previously abandoned but have recently restarted it. I used to really enjoy winning bets against people too confident in their beliefs, but I try to do this in structured prediction markets, because betting against normal people started to feel like taking candy from a baby.
Previously, I was a Future of Humanity Institute 2020 Summer Research Fellow, and then worked on a grant from the Long Term Future Fund to do "independent research on forecasting and optimal paths to improve the long-term."
Before that, I studied Maths and Philosophy, dropped out in exasperation at the inefficiency, picked up some development economics; helped implement the European Summer Program on Rationality during 2017, 2018 2019, 2020 and 2022; worked as a contractor for various forecasting and programming projects; volunteered for various Effective Altruism organizations, and carried out many independent research projects. In a past life, I also wrote a popular Spanish literature blog, and remain keenly interested in Spanish poetry.

You can share feedback anonymously with me here.

Note: You can sign up for all my posts here: <https://nunosempere.com/.newsletter/>, or subscribe to my posts' RSS here: <https://nunosempere.com/blog/index.rss>

78:T420,

To share a brief thought, the above comment gives me a bad juju because it puts a contested perspective into a forceful and authoritative voice, while being long enough that one might implicitly forget that this is a hypothetical authority talking^[1]. So it doesn't feel to me like a friendly conversational technique. I would have preferred it to be in the first person.

^{^}
Garcia Márquez has a similar but longer thing going on in The Handsomest Drowned Man In The World, where everything after "if that magnificent man had lived in the village" is a hypothetical.

79:T145f,

Enter Samotsvety Forecasts. This is a team of some of the best superforecasters in the world. They won the CSET-Foretell forecasting competition by an absolutely obscene margin, “around twice as good as the next-best team in terms of the relative Brier score”. If the point of forecasting tournaments is to figure out who you can trust, the science has spoken, and the answer is “these guys”.

I used to post prolifically on the EA Forum, but nowadays, I post my research and thoughts at nunosempere.com / nunosempere.com/blog rather than on this forum, because:

I disagree with the EA Forum's moderation policy—they've banned a few disagreeable people whom I like, and I think they're generally a bit too censorious for my liking.
The Forum website has become more annoying to me over time: more cluttered and more pushy in terms of curated and pinned posts (I've partially mitigated this by writing my own minimalistic frontend)
The above two issues have made me take notice that the EA Forum is beyond my control, and it feels like a dumb move to host my research in a platform that has goals different from my own.

But a good fraction of my past research is still available here on the EA Forum. I'm particularly fond of my series on Estimating Value.

My career has been as follows:

Before Sentinel, I set up my own niche consultancy, Shapley Maximizers. This was very profitable, and I used the profits to bootstrap Sentinel. I am winding this down, but if you have need of estimation services for big decisions, you can still reach out.
I used to do research around longtermism, forecasting and quantification, as well as some programming, at the Quantified Uncertainty Research Institute (QURI). At QURI, I programmed Metaforecast.org, a search tool which aggregates predictions from many different platforms—a more up to date alternative might be adj.news. I spent some time in the Bahamas as part of the FTX EA Fellowship, and did a bunch of work for the FTX Foundation, which then went to waste when it evaporated.
I write a Forecasting Newsletter which gathered a few thousand subscribers; I previously abandoned but have recently restarted it. I used to really enjoy winning bets against people too confident in their beliefs, but I try to do this in structured prediction markets, because betting against normal people started to feel like taking candy from a baby.
Previously, I was a Future of Humanity Institute 2020 Summer Research Fellow, and then worked on a grant from the Long Term Future Fund to do "independent research on forecasting and optimal paths to improve the long-term."
Before that, I studied Maths and Philosophy, dropped out in exasperation at the inefficiency, picked up some development economics; helped implement the European Summer Program on Rationality during 2017, 2018 2019, 2020 and 2022; worked as a contractor for various forecasting and programming projects; volunteered for various Effective Altruism organizations, and carried out many independent research projects. In a past life, I also wrote a popular Spanish literature blog, and remain keenly interested in Spanish poetry.

You can share feedback anonymously with me here.

Note: You can sign up for all my posts here: <https://nunosempere.com/.newsletter/>, or subscribe to my posts' RSS here: <https://nunosempere.com/blog/index.rss>

7a:T5d0,

In case it's helpful and you've not read them, I think that the two main pieces of context that would be helpful are Cathleen's original post and the Twitter thread of Kerry Vaughan's that Ben West is referring to.

Cathleen has also now commented above which I think clarifies how her request was meant to be taken. Here's a quote (as context, she's formatted her comment to be an idea for how CEA might have responded instead):

(At a cursory glance, it’s difficult to determine the most natural interpretation of the scope of Cathleen’s request, in order to assess the likelihood that the user was knowingly violating her wishes. We initially had a quite narrow interpretation, reading the quote out of context, but I think the situation becomes clearer if you take the time to read her entire post or the section that the quote was pulled from, entitled "We want to move forward with our lives (and not be cancelled)", which includes a direct reference to LinkedIn/her intent to keep her work history private.)

7b:T777,

Reversing start up advice
In the spirit of reversing advice you read, some places where I would give the opposite advice of this thread:

Be less ambitious
I don't have a huge sample size here, but the founders I've spoken to since the "EA has a lot of money so you should be ambitious" era started often seem to be ambitious in unhelpful ways. Specifically: I think they often interpret this advice to mean something like "think about how you could hire as many people as possible" and then they waste a bunch of resources on some grandiose vision without having validated that a small-scale version of their solution works.

Founders who instead work by themselves or with one or two people to try to really deeply understand some need and make a product that solves that need seem way more successful to me.^[1]

Think about failure
The "infinite beta" mentality seems quite important for founders to have. "I have a hypothesis, I will test it, if that fails I will pivot in this way" seems like a good frame, and I think it's endorsed by standard start up advice (e.g. lean startup).

^{^}
Of course, it's perfectly coherent to be ambitious about finding a really good value proposition. It's just that I worry that "be ambitious" primes people to be ambitious in unhelpful ways.

7c:T677,

I have recently been wondering what my expected earnings would be if I started another company. I looked back at the old 80 K blog post arguing that there is some skill component to entrepreneurship, and noticed that, while serial entrepreneurs do have a significantly higher chance of a successful exit on their second venture, they raise their first rounds at substantially lower valuations. (Table 4 here.)

It feels so obvious to me that someone who's started a successful company in the past will be more likely to start one in the future, and I continue to be baffled why the data don't show this.^[1]

I have heard some VCs say that they don't fund serial entrepreneurs because humans only have enough energy to start one company; I always thought this was kind of dumb, but maybe there is some truth to it.

^{^}
Although the data don't not show this either. Companies founded by second time entrepreneurs might be less ambitious, raise money earlier, or have some other difference which is consistent with second time entrepreneurs being more successful

7d:T453,

I'm a student of moral science at the university of Ghent. I also started and ran EA Ghent from 2020 to 2024, at which point I quit in protest over the Manifest scandal (and the reactionary trend it highlighted). I now no longer consider myself an EA (but I'm still part of GWWC and EAA, and if the rationalists split off I'll join again).

If you're interested in philosophy and mechanism design, consider checking out my blog.

I co-started Effectief Geven (Belgian effective giving org), am a volunteer researcher at SatisfIA (AI-safety org) and a volunteer writer at GAIA (Animal welfare org).

Possible conflict of interests: I have never received money from EA, but could plausibly be biased in favor of the organizations I volunteer for.

7e:T46d,

Note: I went through Bob's comments and think it likely they were brigaded to some extent. I didn't think they were in general excellent, but they certainly were not negative-karma comments. I strong-upvoted the ones that were below zero, which was about three or four.

I think it is valid to use the strong upvote as a means of countering brigades, at least where a moderator has confirmed there is reason to believe brigading is active on a topic. My position is limited to comments below zero, because the harmful effects of brigades suppressing good-faith comments from visibility and affirmatively penalizing good-faith users are particularly acute. Although there are mod-level solutions, Ben's comments suggest they may have some downsides and require time, so I feel a community corrective that doesn't require moderators to pull away from more important tasks has value.

I also think it is important for me to be transparent about what I did and accept the community's judgment. If the community feels that is an improper reason to strong upvote, I will revert my votes.

Edit: is to are

7f:T754,

Plant-based burgers now taste better than beef

The food sector has witnessed a surge in the production of plant-based meat alternatives that aim to mimic various attributes of traditional animal products; however, overall sensory appreciation remains low. This study employed open-ended questions, preference ranking, and an identification question to analyze sensory drivers and barriers to liking four burger patties, i.e., two plant-based (one referred to as pea protein burger and one referred to as animal-like protein burger), one hybrid meat-mushroom (75% meat and 25% mushrooms), and one 100% beef burger. Untrained participants (n=175) were randomly assigned to blind or informed conditions in a between-subject study. The main objective was to evaluate the impact of providing information about the animal/plant-based protein source/type, and to obtain product descriptors and liking/disliking levels from consumers. Results from the ranking tests for blind and informed treatments showed that the animal-like protein [Impossible] was the most preferred product, followed by the 100% beef burger. Moreover, in the blind condition, there was no significant difference in preferences between the beef burger and the hybrid and pea protein burgers. In the blind tasting, people preferred the pea protein burger over the hybrid one, contrary to the results of the informed tasting, which implies the existence of affecting factors other than pure hedonistic enjoyment. In the identification question, although consumers correctly identified the beef burger under the blind condition, they still preferred the animal-like burger.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0963996923003587

80:T14ba,

Thanks for the comment and the followup comments by you and Michael, Ben. First, it's really cool that Impossible was preferred to beef burgers in a blind test! Even if the test is not completely fair! Impossible has been around for a while, and obviously they would've been pretty excited to do a blind taste test earlier if they thought they could win, which is evidence that the product has improved somewhat over the years.

I want to quickly add an interesting tidbit I learned from food science practitioners^[1] a while back:

Blind taste tests are not necessarily representative of "real" consumer food preferences.

By that, I mean I think most laymen who think about blind taste tests believe that there's a Platonic taste attribute that's captured well by blind taste tests (or captured except for some variance). So if Alice prefers A to B in a blind taste test, this means that Alice in some sense should like A more than B. And if she buys (at the same price) B instead of A at the supermarket, that means either she was tricked by good marketing, or she has idiosyncratic non-taste preferences that makes her prefer B to A (eg positive associations with eating B with family or something).

I think this is false. Blind taste tests are just pretty artificial, and they do not necessarily reflect real world conditions where people eat food. This difference is large enough to sometimes systematically bias results (hence the worry about differentially salted Impossible burgers and beef burgers).

People who regularly design taste tests usually know that there are easy ways that they can manipulate taste tests so people will prefer more X in a taste test, in ways that do not reflect more people wanting to buy more X in the real world. For example, I believe adding sugar regularly makes products more "tasty" in the sense of being more highly rated in a taste test. However, it is not in fact the case that adding high amounts of sugar automatically makes a product more commonly bought. This is generally understood as people in fact having genuinely different food preferences in taste test conditions than consumer real world decisions.

Concrete example: Pepsi consistently performs better than Coca-Cola in blind taste tests. Yet most consumers consistently buy more Coke than Pepsi. Many people (including many marketers, like the writers of the hyperlinks above) believe that this is strong evidence that Coke just has really good brand/marketing, and is able to sell an inferior product well to the masses.

Personally, I'm not so sure. My current best guess is that this discrepancy is best explained by consumer's genuine drink preferences being different in blind taste tests from real-world use cases. As a concrete operationalization, if people make generic knock-offs of Pepsi and Coke with alternative branding, I would expect faux Pepsi (that taste just like Pepsi) to perform better in blind tastes than faux Coke (that tastes just like Coke), but for more people to buy faux Coke anyway.

For Impossible specifically, I remember doing a blind taste test in 2016 between Impossible beef and regular beef, and thinking that personally I liked ^[2]the Impossible burger more. But I also remember distinctly that the Impossible burger had a much stronger umami taste, which naively seems to me like exactly the type of thing that more taste testers will prefer in blind test conditions than real-world conditions.

This is a pretty long-winded comment, but I hope other people finds this interesting!

^{^}
This is lore, so it might well be false. I heard this from practitioners who sounded pretty confident, and it made logical sense to me, but this is different from the claims being actually empirically correct. Before writing this comment, I was hoping to find an academic source on this topic I can quickly summarize, but I was unable to find it quickly. So unfortunately my reasoning transparency here is basically on the level of "trust me bro :/"
^{^}
To be clear I think it's unlikely for this conclusion to be shared by most taste testers, for the aforementioned reason that if Impossible believed this, they would've done public taste tests way before 2023.

81:Tb22,

@lukeprog's investigation into Cryonics and Molecular nanotechnology seems like it may have relevant lessons for the nascent attempts to build a mass movement around AI safety:

First, early advocates of cryonics and MNT focused on writings and media aimed at a broad popular audience, before they did much technical, scientific work. These advocates successfully garnered substantial media attention, and this seems to have irritated the most relevant established scientific communities (cryobiology and chemistry, respectively), both because many of the established scientists felt that something with no compelling scientific backing was getting more attention than their own “real” work, and because some of them (inaccurately) suspected that media attention for cryonics and MNT had translated into substantial (but unwarranted) funding for both fields.
Second, early advocates of cryonics and MNT spoke and wrote in a way that was critical and dismissive toward the most relevant mainstream scientific fields, and this contributed further to tensions between advocates of cryonics and MNT and the established scientific communities from which they could have most naturally recruited scientific talent and research funding.
Third, and perhaps largely as a result of these first two issues, these “neighboring” established scientific communities (of cryobiologists and chemists) engaged in substantial “boundary work” to keep advocates of cryonics and MNT excluded. For example, in the case of cryonics: according to an historical account by a cryonicist26 (who may of course be biased), established cryobiologists organized to repeatedly label cryonicists as frauds until cryonicists threatened a lawsuit; they passed over cryonics-associated cryobiologists for promotions within the professional societies, or asked them to resign from those societies, and they also blocked cryonicists from obtaining new society memberships via amendments to the bylaws; they threatened to boycott the only supplier of storage vessels suitable for cryonics, forcing cryonicists to build their own storage vessels; they wrote a letter to the California Board of Funeral Directors and Embalmers urging them to investigate cryonicists and shut them down; and so on.

82:T9ab,

Sam Bankman-Fried's trial is scheduled to start October 3, 2023, and Michael Lewis’s book about FTX comes out the same day. My hope and expectation is that neither will be focused on EA,^[1] but several people have recently asked me about if they should prepare anything, so I wanted to quickly record my thoughts.

The Forum feels like it’s in a better place to me than when FTX declared bankruptcy: the moderation team at the time was Lizka, Lorenzo, and myself, but it is now six people, and they’ve put in a number of processes to make it easier to deal with a sudden growth in the number of heated discussions. We have also made a number of design changes, notably to the community section.

CEA has also improved our communications and legal processes so we can be more responsive to news, if we need to (though some of the constraints mentioned here are still applicable).

Nonetheless, I think there’s a decent chance that viewing the Forum, Twitter, or news media could become stressful for some people, and you may want to preemptively create a plan for engaging with that in a healthy way.

^{^}
This market is thinly traded but is currently predicting that Lewis’s book will not explicitly assert that Sam misused customer funds because of “ends justify the means” reasoning

83:Tdd5,

My hope and expectation is that neither will be focused on EA

I'd be surprised [p<0.1] if EA was not a significant focus of the Michael Lewis book – but agree that it's unlikely to be the major topic. Many leaders at FTX and Alameda Research are closely linked to EA. SBF often, and publically, said that effective altruism was a big reason for his actions. His connection to EA is interesting both for understanding his motivation and as a story-telling element. There are Manifold prediction markets on whether the book would mention 80'000h (74%), Open Philanthropy (74%), and Give Well (80%), but these markets aren't traded a lot and are not very informative.^[1]

This video titled The Fake Genius: A $30 BILLION Fraud (2.8 million views, posted 3 weeks ago) might give a glimpse of how EA could be handled. The video touches on EA but isn't centred on it. It discusses the role EAs played in motivating SBF to do earning to give, and in starting Alameda Research and FTX. It also points out that, after the fallout at Alameda Research, 'higher-ups' at CEA were warned about SBF but supposedly ignored the warnings. Overall, the video is mainly interested in the mechanisms of how the suspected fraud happened, where EA is only one piece of the puzzle. One can equally get a sense of "EA led SBF to do fraud" as "SBF used EA as a front to do fraud".

ETA:
The book description^[2] "mentions "philanthropy", makes it clear that it's mainly about SBF and not FTX as a firm, and describes the book as partly a psychological portrait.

^{^}
I also created a similar market for CEA, but with 2 mentions as the resolving criteria. One mention is very likely as SBF worked briefly for them.
^{^}
"In Going Infinite Lewis sets out to answer this question, taking readers into the mind of Bankman-Fried, whose rise and fall offers an education in high-frequency trading, cryptocurrencies, philanthropy, bankruptcy, and the justice system. Both psychological portrait and financial roller-coaster ride, Going Infinite is Michael Lewis at the top of his game, tracing the mind-bending trajectory of a character who never liked the rules and was allowed to live by his own—until it all came undone."

84:T1696,

Thoughts on the OpenAI Board Decisions

A couple months ago I remarked that Sam Bankman-Fried's trial was scheduled to start in October, and people should prepare for EA to be in the headlines. It turned out that his trial did not actually generate much press for EA, but a month later EA is again making news as a result of recent Open AI board decisions.

A couple quick points:

It is often the case that people's behavior is much more reasonable than what is presented in the media. It is also sometimes the case that the reality is even stupider than what is presented. We currently don't know what actually happened, and should hold multiple hypotheses simultaneously.^[1]
It's very hard to predict the outcome of media stories. Here are a few takes I've heard; we should consider that any of these could become the dominant narrative.
1. Vinod Khosla (The Information): “OpenAI’s board members’ religion of ‘effective altruism’ and its misapplication could have set back the world’s path to the tremendous benefits of artificial intelligence”
2. John Thornhill (Financial Times): One entrepreneur who is close to OpenAI says the board was “incredibly principled and brave” to confront Altman, even if it failed to explain its actions in public. “The board is rightly being attacked for incompetence,” the entrepreneur told me. “But if the new board is composed of normal tech people, then I doubt they’ll take safety issues seriously.”
3. The Economist: “The chief lesson is the folly of policing technologies using corporate structures … Fortunately for humanity, there are bodies that have a much more convincing claim to represent its interests: elected governments”
The previous point notwithstanding, people's attention spans are extremely short, and the median outcome of a news story is ~nothing. I've commented before that FTX's collapse had little effect on the average person’s perception of EA, and we might expect a similar thing to happen here.^[2]
Animal welfare has historically been unique amongst EA causes in having a dedicated lobby who is fighting against it. While we don't yet have a HumaneWatch for AI Safety, we should be aware that people have strong interests in how AI develops, and this means that stories about AI will be treated differently from those about, say, malaria.
It can be frustrating to feel that a group you are part of is being judged by the actions of a couple people you’ve never met nor have any strong feelings about. The flipside of this though is that we get to celebrate the victories of people we’ve never met. Here are a few things posted in the last week that I thought were cool:
1. The Against Malaria Foundation is in the middle of a nine-month bed net distribution which is expected to prevent 20 million cases of malaria, and about 40,000 deaths. (Rob Mather)
2. The Shrimp Welfare Project signed an agreement to prevent 125 million shrimps per year from having their eyes cut off and other painful farming practices. (Ula Zarosa)
3. The Belgian Senate voted to add animal welfare to their Constitution. (Bob Jacobs)
4. Scott Alexander’s recent post also has a nice summary of victories.

^{^}
A collection of prediction markets about this event can be found here.
^{^}
Note that the data collected here does not exclude the possibility that perception of EA was affected in some subcommunities, and it might be the case that some subcommunities (e.g. OpenAI staff) do have a changed opinion, even if the average person’s opinion is unchanged

85:Tb06,

Sure, here are the top hits for "Effective Altruism OpenAI" (I did no cherry-picking, this was the first search term that I came up with, and I am just going top to bottom). Each one mentions FTX in a way that pretty clearly matters for the overall article:

Bloomberg: "What is Effective Altruism? What does it mean for AI?"
- "AI safety was embraced as an important cause by big-name Silicon Valley figures who believe in effective altruism, including Peter Thiel, Elon Musk and Sam Bankman-Fried, the founder of crypto exchange FTX, who was convicted in early November of a massive fraud."
Reddit "I think this was an Effective Altruism (EA) takeover by the OpenAI board"
- Top comment: " I only learned about EA during the FTX debacle. And was unaware until recently of its focus on AI. Since been reading and catching up …"
WSJ: "How a Fervent Belief Split Silicon Valley—and Fueled the Blowup at OpenAI"
- "Coming just weeks after effective altruism’s most prominent backer, Sam Bankman-Fried, was convicted of fraud, the OpenAI meltdown delivered another blow to the movement, which believes that carefully crafted artificial-intelligence systems, imbued with the correct human values, will yield a Golden Age—and failure to do so could have apocalyptic consequences."
Wired: "Effective Altruism Is Pushing a Dangerous Brand of ‘AI Safety’"
- "EA is currently being scrutinized due to its association with Sam Bankman-Fried’s crypto scandal, but less has been written about how the ideology is now driving the research agenda in the field of artificial intelligence (AI), creating a race to proliferate harmful systems, ironically in the name of “AI safety.”
Semafor: "The AI industry turns against its favorite philosophy"
- "The first was caused by the downfall of convicted crypto fraudster Sam Bankman-Fried, who was once among the leading figures of EA, an ideology that emerged in the elite corridors of Silicon Valley and Oxford University in the 2010s offering an alternative, utilitarian-infused approach to charitable giving."

86:T936,

I actually did that earlier, then realized I should clarify what you were trying to claim. I will copy the results in below, but even though they support the view that FTX was not a huge deal I want to disclaim that this methodology doesn't seem like it actually gets at the important thing.

But anyway, my original comment text:

As a convenience sample I searched twitter for "effective altruism". The first reference to FTX doesn't come until tweet 36, which is a link to this. Honestly it seems mostly like a standard anti-utilitarianism complaint; it feels like FTX isn't actually the crux.

In contrast, I see 3 e/acc-type criticisms before that, two "I like EA but this AI stuff is too weird" things (including one retweeted by Yann LeCun??), two "EA is tech-bro/not diverse" complaints and one thing about Whytham Abbey.

And this (survey discussed/criticized here):

87:T1215,

I just tried to reproduce the Twitter datapoint. Here is the first tweet when I sort by most recent:

Most tweets are negative, mostly referring to the OpenAI thing. Among the top 10 I see three references to FTX. This continues to be quite remarkable, especially given that it's been more than a year, and these tweets are quite short.

I don't know what search you did to find a different pattern. Maybe it was just random chance that I got many more than you did.

88:T475,

It indeed strikes me as a quite trivial philosophical assumption the denial of which would I think seem absurd to almost anyone considering it

On the contrary, approximately everyone denies this! Approximately ~0% of Americans think that humans with more neurons than other humans have more moral value, for example.^[1]

^{^}
Citation needed, but I would be pretty surprised if this were false. Would love to hear contrary evidence though!

89:T727,

First in-ovo sexing in the US

Egg Innovations announced that they are "on track to adopt the technology in early 2025." Approximately 300 million male chicks are ground up alive in the US each year (since only female chicks are valuable) and in-ovo sexing would prevent this.

UEP originally promised to eliminate male chick culling by 2020; needless to say, they didn't keep that commitment. But better late than never!

Congrats to everyone working on this, including @Robert - Innovate Animal Ag, who founded an organization devoted to pushing this technology.^[1]

^{^}
Egg Innovations says they can't disclose details about who they are working with for NDA reasons; if anyone has more information about who deserves credit for this, please comment!

8a:T5e7,

Call me a hater, and believe me, I am, but maybe someone who went to university at 16 and clearly spent most of their time immersed in books is not the most socially developed.

Maybe after they are implicated in a huge scandal that destroyed our movement's reputation we should gently nudge them to not go on popular podcasts and talk fantastically and almost giddily about how world war 3 is just around the corner. Especially when they are working in a financial capacity in which they would benefit from said war.

Many of the people we have let be in charge of our movement and speak on behalf of it don't know the first thing about optics or leadership or politics. I don't think Elizier Yudowsky could win a middle school class president race with a million dollars.

I know your point was specifically tailored toward optics and thinking carefully about what we say when we have a large platform, but I think looking back and forward bad optics and a lack of real politik messaging are pretty obvious failure modes of a movement filled with chronically online young males who worship intelligence and research output above all else. I'm not trying to sh*t on Leopold and I don't claim I was out here beating a drum about the risks of these specific papers but yea I do think this is one symptom of a larger problem. I can barely think of anyone high up (publicly) in this movement who has risen via organizing.

8b:T588,

I don't think I was claiming they have the exact same failure modes - do you want to point out where I did that? Rather they both have failure modes that I would expect to happen as a result of selecting them to be talking heads on the basis of wits and research output. Also I feel like you are implying Leopold is evil or something like that and I don't agree but maybe I'm misinterpretting.

He seems like a smooth operator in some ways and certainly is quite different than Elizier. That being said I showed my dad (who has become an oddly good litmus test for a lot of this stuff for me as someone who is somewhat sympathethic to our movement but also a pretty normal 60 year old man in a completely different headspace) the Dwarkesh episode and he thought Leopold was very, very, very weird (and not because of his ideas). He kind of reminds me of Peter Thiel. I'll completely admit I wasn't especially clear in my points and that mostly reflects my own lack of clarity on the exact point I was trying to getting across.

I think I take back like 20% of what I said (basically to the extent I was making a very direct stab at what exactly that failure mode is) but mostly still stand by the original comment, which again I see as being approximately ~ "Selecting people to be the public figureheads of our movement on the basis wits and research output is likely to be bad for us".

8c:T1043,

I'm not sure to what extent the Situational Awareness Memo or Leopold himself are representatives of 'EA'

In the pro-side:

Leopold thinks AGI is coming soon, will be a big deal, and that solving the alignment problem is one of the world's most important priorities
He used to work at GPI & FTX, and formerly identified with EA
He (~~probably~~ almost certainly) personally knows lots of EA people in the Bay

On the con-side:

EA isn't just AI Safety (yet), so having short timelines/high importance on AI shouldn't be sufficient to make someone an EA?^[1]
EA shouldn't also just refer to a specific subset of the Bay Culture (please), or at least we need some more labels to distinguish different parts of it in that case
Many EAs have disagreed with various parts of the memo, e.g. Gideon's well received post here
Since his EA institutional history he moved to OpenAI (mixed)^[2] and now runs an AGI investment firm.
By self-identification, I'm not sure I've seen Leopold identify as an EA at all recently.

This again comes down to the nebulousness of what 'being an EA' means.^[3] I have no doubts at all that, given what Leopold thinks is the way to have the most impact he'll be very effective at achieving that.

Further, on your point, I think there's a reason to suspect that something like situational awareness went viral in a way that, say, Rethink Priorities Moral Weight project didn't - the promise many people see in powerful AI is power itself, and that's always going to be interesting for people to follow, so I'm not sure that situational awareness becoming influential makes it more likely that other 'EA' ideas will

^{^}
Plenty of e/accs have these two beliefs as well, they just expect alignment by default, for instance
^{^}
I view OpenAI as tending implicitly/explicitly anti-EA, though I don't think there was an explicit 'purge', I think the culture/vision of the company was changed such that card-carrying EAs didn't want to work there any more
^{^}
The 3 big defintions I have (self-identification, beliefs, actions) could all easily point in different directions for Leopold

8d:T6c8,

In most cases this is a rumors based thing, but I have heard that a substantial chunk of the OP-adjacent EA-policy space has been quite hawkish for many years, and at least the things I have heard is that a bunch of key leaders "basically agreed with the China part of situational awareness".

Again, people should really take this with a double-dose of salt, I am personally at like 50/50 of this being true, and I would love people like lukeprog or Holden or Jason Matheny or others high up at RAND to clarify their positions here. I am not attached to what I believe, but I have heard these rumors from sources that didn't seem crazy (but also various things could have been lost in a game of telephone, and being very concerned about China doesn't result in endorsing a "Manhattan project to AGI", though the rumors that I have heard did sound like they would endorse that)

Less rumor-based, I also know that Dario has historically been very hawkish, and "needing to beat China" was one of the top justifications historically given for why Anthropic does capability research. I have heard this from many people, so feel more comfortable saying it with fewer disclaimers, but am still only like 80% on it being true.

Overall, my current guess is that indeed, a large-ish fraction of the EA policy people would have pushed for things like this, and at least didn't seem like they would push back on it that much. My guess is "we" are at least somewhat responsible for this, and there is much less of a consensus against a U.S. china arms race in US governance among EAs than one might think, and so the above is not much evidence that there was no listening or only very selective listening to EAs.

8e:T8df,

Slightly independent to the point Habryka is making, which may well also be true, my anecdotal impression is that the online EA community / EAs I know IRL were much bigger on 'we need to beat China' arguments 2-4 years ago. If so, simple lag can also be part of the story here. In particular I think it was the mainstream position just before ChatGPT was released, and partly as a result I doubt an 'overwhelming majority of EAs involved in AI safety' disagree with it even now.

Example from August 2022:

https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/why-not-slow-ai-progress

So maybe (the argument goes) we should take a cue from the environmental activists, and be hostile towards AI companies...
This is the most common question I get on AI safety posts: why isn’t the rationalist / EA / AI safety movement doing this more? It’s a great question, and it’s one that the movement asks itself a lot...
Still, most people aren’t doing this. Why not?

Later, talking about why attempting a regulatory approach to avoiding a race is futile:

The biggest problem is China. US regulations don’t affect China. China says that AI leadership is a cornerstone of their national security - both as a massive boon to their surveillance state, and because it would boost their national pride if they could beat America in something so cutting-edge.
So the real question is: which would we prefer? OpenAI gets superintelligence in 2040? Or Facebook gets superintelligence in 2044? Or China gets superintelligence in 2048?
Might we be able to strike an agreement with China on AI, much as countries have previously made arms control or climate change agreements? This is . . . not technically prevented by the laws of physics, but it sounds really hard. When I bring this challenge up with AI policy people, they ask “Harder than the technical AI alignment problem?” Okay, fine, you win this one.

I feel like a generic non-EA policy person reading that post could well end up where the congressional commission landed? It's right there in the section that most explicitly talks about policy.

8f:T93e,

That sounds plausible. I do think of ACX as much more 'accelerationist' than the doomer circles, for lack of a better term. Here's a more recent post from October 2023 informing that impression, below probably does a better job than I can do of adding nuance to Scott's position.

https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/pause-for-thought-the-ai-pause-debate

Second, if we never get AI, I expect the future to be short and grim. Most likely we kill ourselves with synthetic biology. If not, some combination of technological and economic stagnation, rising totalitarianism + illiberalism + mobocracy, fertility collapse and dysgenics will impoverish the world and accelerate its decaying institutional quality. I don’t spend much time worrying about any of these, because I think they’ll take a few generations to reach crisis level, and I expect technology to flip the gameboard well before then. But if we ban all gameboard-flipping technologies (the only other one I know is genetic enhancement, which is even more bannable), then we do end up with bioweapon catastrophe or social collapse. I’ve said before I think there’s a ~20% chance of AI destroying the world. But if we don’t get AI, I think there’s a 50%+ chance in the next 100 years we end up dead or careening towards Venezuela. That doesn’t mean I have to support AI accelerationism because 20% is smaller than 50%. Short, carefully-tailored pauses could improve the chance of AI going well by a lot, without increasing the risk of social collapse too much. But it’s something on my mind.

90:T29d5,

A somewhat relevant article that I discovered while researching this: Longtermists Are Pushing a New Cold War With China - Jacobin

The Biden administration’s decision, in October of last year, to impose drastic export controls on semiconductors, stands as one of its most substantial policy changes so far. As Jacobin‘s Branko Marcetic wrote at the time, the controls were likely the first shot in a new economic Cold War between the United States and China, in which both superpowers (not to mention the rest of the world) will feel the hurt for years or decades, if not permanently.
[...]
The idea behind the policy, however, did not emerge from the ether. Three years before the current administration issued the rule, Congress was already receiving extensive testimony in favor of something much like it. The lengthy 2019 report from the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence suggests unambiguously that the “United States should commit to a strategy to stay at least two generations ahead of China in state-of-the-art microelectronics” and
The commission report makes repeated references to the risks posed by AI development in “authoritarian” regimes like China’s, predicting dire consequences as compared with similar research and development carried out under the auspices of liberal democracy. (Its hand-wringing in particular about AI-powered, authoritarian Chinese surveillance is ironic, as it also ominously exhorts, “The [US] Intelligence Community (IC) should adopt and integrate AI-enabled capabilities across all aspects of its work, from collection to analysis.”)
These emphases on the dangers of morally misinformed AI are no accident. The commission head was Eric Schmidt, tech billionaire and contributor to Future Forward, whose philanthropic venture Schmidt Futures has both deep ties with the longtermist community and a record of shady influence over the White House on science policy. Schmidt himself has voiced measured concern about AI safety, albeit tinged with optimism, opining that “doomsday scenarios” of AI run amok deserve “thoughtful consideration.” He has also coauthored a book on the future risks of AI, with no lesser an expert on morally unchecked threats to human life than notorious war criminal Henry Kissinger.
Also of note is commission member Jason Matheny, CEO of the RAND Corporation. Matheny is an alum of the longtermist Future of Humanity Institute (FHI) at the University of Oxford, who has claimed existential risk and machine intelligence are more dangerous than any historical pandemics and “a neglected topic in both the scientific and governmental communities, but it’s hard to think of a topic more important than human survival.” This commission report was not his last testimony to Congress on the subject, either: in September 2020, he would individually speak before the House Budget Committee urging “multilateral export controls on the semiconductor manufacturing equipment needed to produce advanced chips,” the better to preserve American dominance in AI.
Congressional testimony and his position at the RAND Corporation, moreover, were not Matheny’s only channels for influencing US policy on the matter. In 2021 and 2022, he served in the White House’s Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) as deputy assistant to the president for technology and national security and as deputy director for national security (the head of the OSTP national security division). As a senior figure in the Office — to which Biden has granted “unprecedented access and power” — advice on policies like the October export controls would have fallen squarely within his professional mandate.
The most significant restrictions advocates (aside from Matheny) to emerge from CSET, however, have been Saif Khan and Kevin Wolf. The former is an alum from the Center and, since April 2021, the director for technology and national security at the White House National Security Council. The latter has been a senior fellow at CSET since February 2022 and has a long history of service in and connections with US export policy. He served as assistant secretary of commerce for export administration from 2010–17 (among other work in the field, both private and public), and his extensive familiarity with the US export regulation system would be valuable to anyone aspiring to influence policy on the subject. Both would, before and after October, champion the semiconductor controls.
At CSET, Khan published repeatedly on the topic, time and again calling for the United States to implement semiconductor export controls to curb Chinese progress on AI. In March 2021, he testified before the Senate, arguing that the United States must impose such controls “to ensure that democracies lead in advanced chips and that they are used for good.” (Paradoxically, in the same breath the address calls on the United States to both “identify opportunities to collaborate with competitors, including China, to build confidence and avoid races to the bottom” and to “tightly control exports of American technology to human rights abusers,” such as… China.)
Among Khan’s coauthors was aforementioned former congressional hopeful and longtermist Carrick Flynn, previously assistant director of the Center for the Governance of AI at FHI. Flynn himself individually authored a CSET issue brief, “Recommendations on Export Controls for Artificial Intelligence,” in February 2020. The brief, unsurprisingly, argues for tightened semiconductor export regulation much like Khan and Matheny.
This February, Wolf too provided a congressional address on “Advancing National Security and Foreign Policy Through Sanctions, Export Controls, and Other Economic Tools,” praising the October controls and urging further policy in the same vein. In it, he claims knowledge of the specific motivations of the controls’ writers:
BIS did not rely on ECRA’s emerging and foundational technology provisions when publishing this rule so that it would not need to seek public comments before publishing it.
These motivations also clearly included exactly the sorts of AI concerns Matheny, Khan, Flynn, and other longtermists had long raised in this connection. In its background summary, the text of one rule explicitly links the controls with hopes of retarding China’s AI development. Using language that could easily have been ripped from a CSET paper on the topic, the summary warns that “‘supercomputers’ are being used by the PRC to improve calculations in weapons design and testing including for WMD, such as nuclear weapons, hypersonics and other advanced missile systems, and to analyze battlefield effects,” as well as bolster citizen surveillance.
[...]
Longtermists, in short, have since at least 2019 exerted a strong influence over what would become the Biden White House’s October 2022 semiconductor export rules. If the policy is not itself the direct product of institutional longtermists, it at the very least bears the stamp of their enthusiastic approval and close monitoring.
Just as it would be a mistake to restrict interest in longtermism’s political ambitions exclusively to election campaigns, it would be shortsighted to treat its work on semiconductor infrastructure as a one-off incident. Khan and Matheny, among others, remain in positions of considerable influence, and have demonstrated a commitment to bringing longtermist concerns to bear on matters of high policy. The policy sophistication, political reach, and fresh-faced enthusiasm on display in its semiconductor export maneuvering should earn the AI doomsday lobby its fair share of critical attention in the years to come.

The article seems quite biased to me, but I do think some of the basics here make sense and match with things I have heard (but also, some of it seems wrong).

91:T50a,

I have work experience in HR and Operations. I read a lot, I enjoy taking online courses, and I do some yoga and some rock climbing. I enjoy learning languages, and I think that I tend to have a fairly international/cross-cultural focus or awareness in my life. I was born and raised in a monolingual household in the US, but I've lived most of my adult life outside the US, with about ten years in China, two years in Spain, and less than a year in Brazil.

As far as EA is concerned, I'm fairly cause agnostic/cause neutral. I think that I am a little bit more influenced by virtue ethics and stoicism than the average EA, and I also occasionally find myself thinking about inclusion, diversity, and accessibility in EA. Some parts of the EA community that I've observed in-person seem not very welcoming to outsides, or somewhat gatekept. I tend to care quite a bit about how exclusionary or welcoming communities are.

I was told by a friend in EA that I should brag about how many books I read because it is impressive, but I feel uncomfortable being boastful, so here is my clunky attempt to brag about that.

Unless explicitly stated otherwise, opinions are my own, not my employer's.

92:T427,

Kieran Greig is the President at Rethink Priorities. He works with the Leadership Team to advise on Rethink Priorities’ strategy and execution, at all levels. Prior to that, he was the Director of Research for Farmed Animal Funders, a group of large donors who each give over $250,000 annually to end factory farming. He previously worked as a researcher at Animal Charity Evaluators, and prior to that was a co-founder of Charity Entrepreneurship and Charity Science Health. He has written about topics like improving the welfare of farmed fish and supporting plant-based alternatives to animal products. He has a B. Sc. from Monash University and a Masters from La Trobe University.

93:T8b9,

The AI Eval Singularity is Near

AI capabilities seem to be doubling every 4-7 months
Humanity's ability to measure capabilities is growing much more slowly
This implies an "eval singularity": a point at which capabilities grow faster than our ability to measure them
It seems like the singularity is ~here in cybersecurity, CBRN, and AI R&D (supporting quotes below)
It's possible that this is temporary, but the people involved seem pretty worried

Appendix - quotes on eval saturation

Opus 4.6

"For AI R&D capabilities, we found that Claude Opus 4.6 has saturated most of our
automated evaluations, meaning they no longer provide useful evidence for ruling out ASL-4 level autonomy. We report them for completeness, and we will likely discontinue them going forward. Our determination rests primarily on an internal survey of Anthropic staff, in which 0 of 16 participants believed the model could be made into a drop-in replacement for an entry-level researcher with scaffolding and tooling improvements within three months."
"For ASL-4 evaluations [of CBRN], our automated benchmarks are now largely saturated and no longer provide meaningful signal for rule-out (though as stated above, this is not indicative of harm; it simply means we can no longer rule out certain capabilities that may be pre-requisities to a model having ASL-4 capabilities)."
It also saturated ~100% of the cyber evaluations

Codex-5.3

"We are treating this model as High [for cybersecurity], even though we cannot be certain that it actually has these capabilities, because it meets the requirements of each of our canary thresholds and we therefore cannot rule out the possibility that it is in fact Cyber High."

94:T587,

Related, from an OAI researcher.

49:["$","$L6a",null,{"comments":[{"_id":"8vfsnmSJb2nkqs2Ed","postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.510Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2021-10-17T23:11:17.488Z","score":0.002454649191349745,"baseScore":12,"voteCount":11,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

An EA Limerick

(Lacey told me this was not good enough to actually submit to the writing contest, so publishing it as a short form.)

An AI sat boxed in a room
Said Eliezer: \"This surely spells doom!
With self-improvement recursive,
And methods subversive
It will just simply go 'foom'.\"

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"GX3XpEgqpGyHGKiGS","postedAt":"2021-10-17T23:11:17.170Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2021-10-17T23:11:17.173Z","score":0.000016050529666244984,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"8vfsnmSJb2nkqs2Ed","topLevelCommentId":"8vfsnmSJb2nkqs2Ed","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"qfcuaXKZBrEb4AGvE","slug":"e-vasquez","displayName":"E Vasquez ","username":"E Vasquez ","createdAt":"2021-10-14T00:49:55.671Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":4,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":0,"commentCount":5,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Nice!

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","postedAt":"2022-03-07T16:37:45.504Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-03-27T00:12:40.548Z","score":0.012607413344085217,"baseScore":61,"voteCount":20,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":7,"directChildrenCount":3,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Thanks! I'm not sure I fully understand your comment – are you implying that the skills you mention are easier to learn in a startup?

Unsurprisingly, I disagree with that view :)

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"sNt5xAdahztyDLwRJ","postedAt":"2022-03-08T13:37:29.259Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-03-09T03:56:15.541Z","score":0.0021499237045645714,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"a49457BdbBmYARxZy","topLevelCommentId":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Working for/with people who are good at those skills seems like a pretty good bet to me.

E.g. \"knowing how to attract people to work with you\" – if person A has a manager who was really good at attracting people to work with them, and their manager is interested in mentoring, and person B is just learning how to attract people to work with them from scratch at their own startup, I would give very good odds that person A will learn faster.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"wdHwiiapntkckMSKf","postedAt":"2022-03-08T20:59:35.649Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-03-09T03:56:15.541Z","score":0.0013585040578618646,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"WEyAkjHfqS2etLDpT","topLevelCommentId":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Yeah definitely. I don't want to claim that learning is impossible at a startup – clearly it's possible – just that, all else equal, learning usually happens faster at existing companies.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"bivWeeWCovssSTZcR","postedAt":"2022-03-08T21:47:41.056Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-03-08T21:47:41.058Z","score":0.0005596904084086418,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"sNt5xAdahztyDLwRJ","topLevelCommentId":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"77rTsDyqv9NGszfxx","slug":"charles-he","displayName":"Charles He","username":"Charles He","createdAt":"2021-01-25T00:23:08.899Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":2586,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":2,"commentCount":948,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can give me anonymous feedback here: https://forms.gle/q65w9Nauaw5e7t2Z9

If person A has a manager who was really good at attracting people to work with them, and their manager is interested in mentoring

Can you give some advice about the topic of attracting good people to work with you, or have any writeups you like?

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"EnmZgyWFKNPpmSjym","postedAt":"2022-03-08T23:47:35.050Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-03-08T23:47:35.054Z","score":0.00039999998989515007,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","topLevelCommentId":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"tQDdLhT7Tvv26kJJG","slug":"hibukki","displayName":"Yonatan Cale","username":"hibukki","createdAt":"2021-02-27T15:36:36.792Z","profileImageId":"Profile/jclnhg2rnr048n5qcguk","karma":4867,"jobTitle":"","organization":"Effective Developers","postCount":27,"commentCount":927,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"$6c"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

It depends what you want to learn

As you said.

Founding a startup is a great way to learn how to found a startup.
Working as a backend engineer in some company is a great way to learn how to be a backend engineer in some company.

(I don't see why to break it up more than that)

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"rGoeHwnTGJqCwhTSk","postedAt":"2022-03-26T22:35:01.908Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-03-26T22:35:01.912Z","score":0.001461546984501183,"baseScore":7,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{"agree":2},"parentCommentId":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","topLevelCommentId":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"rm6LxnWsJZW29yJfs","slug":"imben","displayName":"Clifford","username":"imben","createdAt":"2014-09-10T00:06:09.078Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":1334,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":12,"commentCount":77,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

I think I agree with this. Two things that might make starting a startup a better learning opportunity than your alternative, in spite of it being a worse learning environment:

You are undervalued by the job market (so you can get more opportunities to do cool things by starting your own thing)
You work harder in your startup because you care about it more (so you get more productive hours of learning)

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"cNgbKCTWnrhHtYb6F","postedAt":"2022-03-27T00:12:39.993Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-03-27T00:12:39.996Z","score":0.0004079999926034361,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","topLevelCommentId":"3yFDLgMBJdaWtdXcG","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"ji2xNTJPhLx2c4pmb","slug":"dave-cortright","displayName":"Dave Cortright 🔸","username":"DaveC","createdAt":"2018-12-16T01:10:18.782Z","profileImageId":"Profile/njh5mk95cydhtv4dxsff","karma":833,"jobTitle":"Professional Coach","organization":null,"postCount":23,"commentCount":155,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I have been a serious philanthropist since 2004 and part of the EA community since 2017. I am audaciously optimistic we can ameliorating the global mental health crisis. I used my coaching and facilitatation skills to help grow EA capacity. I support environmental and animal welfare organizations. I am on the advisory council of Vegan Outreach and the Santa Clara County Behavioral Health Board.

I am a certified professional coach, with additional experience in crisis counseling and peer mentoring. I shifted to mental health and well-being after 25 years as a designer, manager, and director at Silicon Valley tech companies. I am passionate about helping others, and by guiding them to find their true calling, I amplify my impact on improving the world.

It depends on what you want to learn. At a startup, people will often get a lot more breadth of scope than they would otherwise in an established company. Yes, you might not have in-house mentors or seasoned pros to learn from, but these days motivated people can fill in the holes outside the org.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"5zq4YZz4DHNKrLAQP","postedAt":"2022-06-18T16:08:29.182Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-10T09:46:44.946Z","score":0.005046237725764513,"baseScore":23,"voteCount":11,"extendedScore":{"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":4,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

You can give me anonymous feedback here: https://forms.gle/q65w9Nauaw5e7t2Z9

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Thanks for the push back! I agree that 80k cares more about the use of their listener's time than most podcasters, although this is a low bar.

80k is operating under a lot of constraints, and I'm honestly not sure if they are actually doing anything incorrectly here. Notably, the fancy people who they get on the podcast probably aren't willing to devote many hours to rephrasing things in the most concise way possible, which really constrains their options.

I do still feel like there is a missing mood though.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"Q5gnB4gfFECodH7qw","postedAt":"2022-09-02T03:25:43.701Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-07T12:26:17.285Z","score":0.0016684317961335182,"baseScore":7,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Person-affecting longtermism

This post points out that brain preservation (cryonics) is potentially quite cheap on a $/QALY basis because people who are reanimated will potentially live for a very long time with very high quality of life.

It seems reasonable to assume that reanimated people would funge against future persons, so I'm not sure if this is persuasive for those who don't adopt person affecting views, but for those who do, it's plausibly very cost-effective.

This is interesting because I don't hear much about person affecting longtermist causes.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"Nwp99KjtEu929FcYt","postedAt":"2022-09-16T23:45:40.723Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-10-24T16:21:10.809Z","score":0.0037061478942632675,"baseScore":16,"voteCount":9,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Democratizing risk post update
Earlier this week, a post was published criticizing democratizing risk. This post was deleted by the (anonymous) author. The forum moderation team did not ask them to delete it, nor are we aware of their reasons for doing so.
We are investigating some likely Forum policy violations, however, and will clarify the situation as soon as possible.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"94HakSn6PAoejvgZt","postedAt":"2022-10-24T16:21:10.552Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-10-24T16:21:10.555Z","score":0.00051499018445611,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"Nwp99KjtEu929FcYt","topLevelCommentId":"Nwp99KjtEu929FcYt","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"SuPnfB9qqKWsucNzm","slug":"lizka","displayName":"Lizka","username":"Lizka","createdAt":"2019-11-06T06:22:18.538Z","profileImageId":"Profile/llwmfw62hcsq2vuk1n7g","karma":18075,"jobTitle":"Researcher","organization":"Forethought","postCount":154,"commentCount":580,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"$6f"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

See the updates here.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","postedAt":"2022-10-28T17:13:08.479Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-03T18:02:06.971Z","score":0.012937071733176708,"baseScore":55,"voteCount":24,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":16,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":true,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$70","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"zqKee2TsmtZWhDfJW","postedAt":"2022-10-29T00:45:59.812Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-03T18:02:06.971Z","score":-0.0024649505503475666,"baseScore":-10,"voteCount":13,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":11,"directChildrenCount":5,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":null,"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$71","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"TA3vWScTaD3L7wvC3","postedAt":"2022-10-29T01:03:18.718Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-10-31T23:27:41.321Z","score":0.013788001611828804,"baseScore":59,"voteCount":19,"extendedScore":{"agreement":0,"approvalVoteCount":19,"agreementVoteCount":0},"parentCommentId":"zqKee2TsmtZWhDfJW","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Head of Lightcone Infrastructure. Wrote the forum software that the EA Forum is based on. I've historically been one of the most active and highest karma commenters on the forum. I no longer post or comment here, and recommend the same to others.

My best guess is EA at large is causing large harm for the world, and there is no leadership or accountability in-place to fix it. Many of the principles are important, but I don't think this specific community embodies these principles very much and often actively sabotages them.

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

I work at SAIF. We work on China–West coordination on frontier AI safety. Among other things we run IDAIS (International Dialogues on AI Safety), which convenes leading senior AI scientists from China and the West on frontier risks.

I am also a board member for EA Germany.

Prior to my role at SAIF, I worked at the Centre for Effective Altruism as a project manager, and at Effective Ventures as the Head of Property and Head of Staff Support.

I studied Philosophy and Economics in Bayreuth, Germany and was one of the core organisers of the EA group in Bayreuth for about 4 years. I love bouldering, sewing, lino printing, beach Volleyball, and vegan cooking.

Kerry, what are you getting at? What do you think was the harm or the intended harm of Ryan's posts?

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"crhJjLqBRv24pxY4Z","postedAt":"2022-10-31T23:27:41.109Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-10-31T23:27:41.111Z","score":0.0024766267742961645,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"TA3vWScTaD3L7wvC3","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":null,"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$74","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"MhEAMmMpMxhXKsgis","postedAt":"2022-10-31T23:29:56.499Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-01T21:39:08.473Z","score":0.0013936215545982122,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"zqKee2TsmtZWhDfJW","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":null,"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$75","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"z5qdTrduLxP6BovgH","postedAt":"2022-10-31T23:34:06.823Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-10-31T23:34:06.826Z","score":0.000045790297008352354,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"EQw4jq8vvvEJqkCi5","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":null,"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

I disagree with that interpretation especially given the context of Cathleen’s post. It includes lengthy discussions of poor and bizarre behavior by members of the EA community toward Leverage/Paradigm staff.

I think reading Cathleen’s post and then re-adding her name is either an intentional violation of her wishes or, at a minimum, shows a reckless disregard for her request for privacy.

In any case, I don’t think this issue is central. The original comment already was doxing given the context, which includes the “question” to which it was a reply, the poster’s overall pattern of behavior, and the history of very poor behavior towards Leverage/Paradigm staff by members of the EA community. The poster’s behavior after reading Cathleen’s request for privacy simply makes their intention clearer.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"jq8gMh9ux9rfjqv4m","postedAt":"2022-11-01T04:43:21.142Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-01T23:31:56.947Z","score":-0.0009605258237570524,"baseScore":-4,"voteCount":12,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"N5N56n8aMfPjLGc3f","slug":"cathleen","displayName":"Cathleen","username":"Cathleen","createdAt":"2022-09-21T00:32:30.630Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":-4,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":0,"commentCount":1,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$76","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"2Mo2QdXxLzTEixJsE","postedAt":"2022-11-01T09:52:52.131Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-01T16:57:09.671Z","score":0.00525640556588769,"baseScore":22,"voteCount":11,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"jq8gMh9ux9rfjqv4m","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"YRCdk7cvPT6pyiph9","slug":"nunosempere","displayName":"NunoSempere","username":"NunoSempere","createdAt":"2018-11-15T15:52:18.347Z","profileImageId":"Profile/k878ddoduabhtngbawob","karma":13985,"jobTitle":"Director, Head of Foresight","organization":"Sentinel","postCount":107,"commentCount":1294,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"$77"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$78","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"A669vmHLDLsvFcaXa","postedAt":"2022-11-01T10:37:33.063Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-01T21:39:08.473Z","score":0.0013947455445304513,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":6,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"MhEAMmMpMxhXKsgis","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"YRCdk7cvPT6pyiph9","slug":"nunosempere","displayName":"NunoSempere","username":"NunoSempere","createdAt":"2018-11-15T15:52:18.347Z","profileImageId":"Profile/k878ddoduabhtngbawob","karma":13985,"jobTitle":"Director, Head of Foresight","organization":"Sentinel","postCount":107,"commentCount":1294,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"$79"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Note that the two anonymous accounts are spaced a year apart; seems likely that Ryan lost the password to the 1st.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"bJoGDBBMPKdmPyahw","postedAt":"2022-11-01T16:57:09.475Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-01T16:57:09.477Z","score":0.002053564880043268,"baseScore":8,"voteCount":6,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"2Mo2QdXxLzTEixJsE","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

(fwiw I didn't mind the format and felt like this was Cathleen engaging in good faith.)

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"W3Y4tTXdWrbyaSAfk","postedAt":"2022-11-01T21:39:08.253Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-01T21:39:08.256Z","score":0.0005219383165240288,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":6,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"A669vmHLDLsvFcaXa","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":null,"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

The obvious thing to do in that case is to disclose this in a comment somewhere.

Also, this defense doesn't work for his efforts to promote his own anonymous posts from his public account.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"n6QGqSmosJhEJrxrX","postedAt":"2022-11-01T23:31:56.606Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-01T23:31:56.613Z","score":0.0009615102899260819,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"jq8gMh9ux9rfjqv4m","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"xxFSXjSkg28rGAkNi","slug":"larissavaughanrowe","displayName":"LarissaVaughanRowe","username":"LarissaHeskethRowe","createdAt":"2017-02-28T18:05:17.207Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":199,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":3,"commentCount":29,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

I would have so much respect for CEA if they had responded like this.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"CmqMmyaKCGykjKkAC","postedAt":"2022-11-01T23:41:17.455Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-01T23:41:17.457Z","score":-0.003546691732481122,"baseScore":-15,"voteCount":7,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"EQw4jq8vvvEJqkCi5","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"xxFSXjSkg28rGAkNi","slug":"larissavaughanrowe","displayName":"LarissaVaughanRowe","username":"LarissaHeskethRowe","createdAt":"2017-02-28T18:05:17.207Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":199,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":3,"commentCount":29,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$7a","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"YxWjWmMcrkFCbpeG7","postedAt":"2022-11-02T15:27:01.725Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-03T18:02:06.971Z","score":0.004630246665328741,"baseScore":19,"voteCount":10,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"zqKee2TsmtZWhDfJW","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":true,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

At this point, the moderators are trying to focus on any practical steps we should take. Given that the names in question are encoded, and no one currently listed in the comment has reached out to us, we do not plan to take further action. Anyone who feels that private or incorrect information about themselves is posted on the Forum is always free to contact us.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"MzeeLKvTxPPkZf7Ww","postedAt":"2022-11-03T18:02:06.749Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-03T18:02:06.751Z","score":0.0009658258641138673,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"YxWjWmMcrkFCbpeG7","topLevelCommentId":"iBLwGaKFrYxmPPFfQ","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":null,"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Hi Ben,

Could you explain what's not practical about these simple steps that you could take:

1) Create an EA Forum policy against sockpuppeting, and apply it retroactively to this case. This might naturally result in deleting the offending posts or adding a notification indicating they are sockpuppets.

2) Remove the encoded names and replace them with numbers per the edit your team made originally.

3) Change the word \"doxing\" to \"deanonymizing\" in the following sentence from the Guide to Norms (since the behavior you intend to prohibit is not doxing):

Doxing — or revealing someone's real name if they are anonymous on the Forum or elsewhere on the internet — is prohibited

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"58kKwv8e2x4mTmKCj","postedAt":"2022-11-06T19:32:24.697Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-11-09T16:25:49.112Z","score":0.005940692033618689,"baseScore":25,"voteCount":9,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Two days after posting, SBF, who the thread lists as the prototypical example of someone who would never make a plan B, seems to have executed quite the plan B.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"N8axjJsaCYHdEMtDz","postedAt":"2022-12-15T21:16:17.265Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2022-12-16T07:29:16.216Z","score":0.0017460535746067762,"baseScore":7,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Software Developer at Giving What We Can, trying to make giving significantly and effectively a social norm.

Wild guesses as someone that knows very little about this:

I wonder if it's because people have sublinear returns on wealth, so their second company would be more mission driven and less optimized for making money. Also, there might be some selection bias in who needs to raise money vs being self funded.

But if I had to bet I would say that it's mostly noise, and there's not enough data to have a strong prior.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","postedAt":"2023-01-15T18:25:43.827Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-17T15:55:16.417Z","score":0.01319920178502798,"baseScore":54,"voteCount":17,"extendedScore":{"agreement":0,"approvalVoteCount":17,"agreementVoteCount":0},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":16,"directChildrenCount":3,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":true,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Possible Vote Brigading

We have received an influx of people creating accounts to cast votes and comments over the past week, and we are aware that people who feel strongly about human biodiversity sometimes vote brigade on sites where the topic is being discussed. Please be aware that voting and discussion about some topics may not be representative of the normal EA Forum user base.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"DJSBoeHzofQxAdi6m","postedAt":"2023-01-15T20:31:08.898Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-17T15:55:16.417Z","score":0.011317456141114235,"baseScore":46,"voteCount":18,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":11,"directChildrenCount":3,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

Huh, seems like you should just revert those votes, or turn off voting for new accounts. Seems better than just having people be confused about vote totals.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"HvfcBDijNxef7FuvA","postedAt":"2023-01-15T20:50:37.495Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-15T20:50:37.498Z","score":0.0011093395296484232,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"XSRqHpYegqbrEyWu5","slug":"pseudonym-1","displayName":"pseudonym","username":"pseudonym","createdAt":"2022-10-05T20:02:13.089Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":2153,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":4,"commentCount":192,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Feel free to DM me anything you want to share but don't want to or can't under your own account(s), and I can share them on your behalf if I think it's adding value to the discourse/community.

The corollary is that views shared on this account don't necessarily reflect my own personal views, though they will usually be worded to sound like they are.

Do the moderators think the effect of vote brigading reflect support from people who are pro-HBD or anti-HBD?

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"jrJfFYHsDNQGFLdgH","postedAt":"2023-01-16T02:15:39.879Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T19:00:22.939Z","score":0.00580423092469573,"baseScore":23,"voteCount":10,"extendedScore":{"agreement":0,"approvalVoteCount":10,"agreementVoteCount":0},"parentCommentId":"DJSBoeHzofQxAdi6m","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":3,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"qBHaRchuhX3GLvZyg","slug":"jason-1","displayName":"Jason","username":"Jason","createdAt":"2022-11-09T23:16:18.229Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":19441,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":3,"commentCount":2340,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I am an attorney in a public-sector position not associated with EA, although I cannot provide legal advice to anyone. My involvement with EA so far has been mostly limited so far to writing checks to GiveWell and other effective charities in the Global Health space, as well as some independent reading. I have occasionally read the forum and was looking for ideas for year-end giving when the whole FTX business exploded . . .

And maybe add a visible \"new account\" flag -- I understand not wanting to cut off existing users creating throwaways, but some people are using screenshots of forum comments as evidence of what EAs in general think.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"wcRcwbKPfFFmfFtkw","postedAt":"2023-01-16T02:16:20.873Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-17T15:55:16.417Z","score":0.002356518292799592,"baseScore":9,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"DJSBoeHzofQxAdi6m","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":5,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Yeah, I think we should probably go through and remove people who are obviously brigading (eg tons of votes in one hour and no other activity), but I'm hesitant to do too much more retroactively. I think it's possible that next time we have a discussion that has a passionate audience outside of EA we should restrict signups more, but that obviously has costs.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"yyQHaKTscjbi9EyGm","postedAt":"2023-01-16T03:03:04.621Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T19:17:01.970Z","score":0.001612424966879189,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"wcRcwbKPfFFmfFtkw","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

When you purge user accounts you automatically revoke their votes. I wouldn't be very hesitant to do that.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"kWw83imgpYpWWYBzF","postedAt":"2023-01-16T16:40:02.638Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T19:17:01.970Z","score":0.0016151649178937078,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"yyQHaKTscjbi9EyGm","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

How do you differentiate someone who is sincerely engaging and happens to have just created an account now from someone who just wants their viewpoint to seem more popular and isn't interested in truth seeking?

Or are you saying we should just purge accounts that are clearly in the latter category, and accept that there will be some which are actually in the latter category but we can't distinguish from the former?

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"F9WuCaxnpEYvscwc5","postedAt":"2023-01-16T17:37:40.469Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T19:01:10.628Z","score":0.00161520775873214,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":{"agreement":0,"approvalVoteCount":5,"agreementVoteCount":0},"parentCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"8WBD8X9dcMvkGiN5G","slug":"larks","displayName":"Larks","username":"Larks","createdAt":"2014-09-20T20:07:58.285Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":16912,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":28,"commentCount":1662,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Could you set a minimum karma threshold (or account age or something) for your votes to count? I would expect even a low threshold like 10 would solve much of the problem.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"f49bdBYxe3yEoYHuB","postedAt":"2023-01-16T17:38:29.668Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T17:38:29.670Z","score":0.003848102642223239,"baseScore":15,"voteCount":6,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":true,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Closing comments on posts
If you are the author of a post tagged \"personal blog\" (which notably includes all new Bostrom-related posts) and you would like to prevent new comments on your post, please email forum@centerforeffectivealtruism.org and we can disable them.

We know that some posters find the prospect of dealing with commenters so aversive that they choose not to post at all; this seems worse to us than posting with comments turned off.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"62jnHo7baJo3dvKZk","postedAt":"2023-01-16T17:38:54.434Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T17:38:54.437Z","score":0.0013613509945571423,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"jrJfFYHsDNQGFLdgH","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"8WBD8X9dcMvkGiN5G","slug":"larks","displayName":"Larks","username":"Larks","createdAt":"2014-09-20T20:07:58.285Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":16912,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":28,"commentCount":1662,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Arguably also beneficially if you thought that we should typically make an extra effort to be tolerant of 'obvious' questions from new users.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"Skcz2Pe7AfbGDaj36","postedAt":"2023-01-16T17:42:11.245Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T17:42:11.250Z","score":0.0006036552367731929,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"jrJfFYHsDNQGFLdgH","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Thanks! Yeah, this is something we've considered, usually in the context of trying to make the Forum more welcoming to newcomers, but this is another reason to prioritize that feature.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"H57GCYeac7phGTKSd","postedAt":"2023-01-16T17:43:27.850Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T19:01:10.628Z","score":0.006265534088015556,"baseScore":25,"voteCount":10,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":0,"agreement":2,"approvalVoteCount":10,"agreementVoteCount":1},"parentCommentId":"F9WuCaxnpEYvscwc5","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Yeah, interesting. I think we have a lot of lurkers who never get any karma and I don't want to entirely exclude them, but maybe some combo like \"10 karma or your account has to be at least one week old\" would be good.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"F9PfaoLLdkdbaw5ph","postedAt":"2023-01-16T19:00:22.716Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T19:00:22.719Z","score":0.00006770820618839934,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"jrJfFYHsDNQGFLdgH","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"LwDSW3qxheugptwRg","slug":"peter_wildeford","displayName":"Peter Wildeford","username":"Peter_Hurford","createdAt":"2014-08-21T01:29:43.927Z","profileImageId":"Profile/rstuqscgzpzx9vnybs5p","karma":20340,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":82,"commentCount":1803,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

I agree.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"7FkH5hEuFgr8nDe8P","postedAt":"2023-01-16T19:00:39.602Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T19:00:39.605Z","score":0.001361402915790677,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"DJSBoeHzofQxAdi6m","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"LwDSW3qxheugptwRg","slug":"peter_wildeford","displayName":"Peter Wildeford","username":"Peter_Hurford","createdAt":"2014-08-21T01:29:43.927Z","profileImageId":"Profile/rstuqscgzpzx9vnybs5p","karma":20340,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":82,"commentCount":1803,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

I agree.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"xENSxN4CpBEdvLYcd","postedAt":"2023-01-16T19:01:10.416Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T19:01:10.419Z","score":0.001111573539674282,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"H57GCYeac7phGTKSd","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"LwDSW3qxheugptwRg","slug":"peter_wildeford","displayName":"Peter Wildeford","username":"Peter_Hurford","createdAt":"2014-08-21T01:29:43.927Z","profileImageId":"Profile/rstuqscgzpzx9vnybs5p","karma":20340,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":82,"commentCount":1803,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Yeah I think that would be a really smart way to implement it.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"LRxtKmbnPTCAwz3js","postedAt":"2023-01-16T19:17:01.726Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-16T19:17:01.729Z","score":0.0013614132767543197,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"kWw83imgpYpWWYBzF","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

I think being like \"sorry, we've reverted votes from recently signed-up accounts because we can't distinguish them\" seems fine. Also, in my experience abusive voting patterns are usually very obvious, where people show up and only vote on one specific comment or post, or on content of one specific user, or vote so fast that it seems impossible for them to have read the content they are voting on.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"8gmkSFgsifw7uaqks","postedAt":"2023-01-17T11:14:52.653Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-17T15:55:16.417Z","score":0,"baseScore":0,"voteCount":7,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"wcRcwbKPfFFmfFtkw","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"86kbCNY523Arv4h6k","slug":"bob-jacobs-inactive","displayName":"Bob Jacobs [inactive]","username":"bmjacobs@telenet.be","createdAt":"2019-12-25T21:37:29.973Z","profileImageId":"Profile/w5vjftvndjb0tsxvugwg","karma":1802,"jobTitle":"Co-founder","organization":"Effectief Geven","postCount":23,"commentCount":146,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"$7d"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

How about: getting a lot of downvotes from new accounts doesn't decrease your voting-power and doesn't mean your comments won't show up on the frontpage?
Half a dozen of my latest comments have responded to HBDers. Since they get a notification it doesn't surprise me that those comments get immediate downvotes which hides them from the frontpage and subsequently means that they can easily decrease my voting-power on this forum (it went from 5 karma for a strong upvote to now 4 karma for a strong upvote).
Giving brigaders the power to hide things from the frontpage and decide which people have more voting-power on this forum seems undesirable.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"2wempkwyQycn3X6Pe","postedAt":"2023-01-17T15:55:15.745Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-01-17T15:55:15.747Z","score":0.0026159596163779497,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":null,"parentCommentId":"8gmkSFgsifw7uaqks","topLevelCommentId":"dobbatRseJHL8KXER","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"qBHaRchuhX3GLvZyg","slug":"jason-1","displayName":"Jason","username":"Jason","createdAt":"2022-11-09T23:16:18.229Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":19441,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":3,"commentCount":2340,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

We are banning stone and their alternate account for one month for messaging users and accusing others of being sock puppets, even after the moderation team asked them to stop. If you believe that someone has violated Forum norms such as creating sockpuppet accounts, please contact the moderators.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"Jn58DHFkbGWA5GpuA","postedAt":"2023-05-03T18:54:12.200Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-05-07T09:47:02.397Z","score":0.009557895362377167,"baseScore":37,"voteCount":19,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Animal welfare is a core focus area within effective altruism. It focuses on ways to improve the wellbeing of nonhuman animals, primarily..."}]},{"_id":"iFmCjJLadjw5SbyzD","postedAt":"2023-05-03T20:00:54.392Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-05-03T21:47:04.129Z","score":0.003161731641739607,"baseScore":12,"voteCount":7,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"Jn58DHFkbGWA5GpuA","topLevelCommentId":"Jn58DHFkbGWA5GpuA","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"koiapr98ETwouMpRf","slug":"michael-st-jules","displayName":"Michael St Jules 🔸","username":"MichaelStJules","createdAt":"2016-05-21T16:33:33.630Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":13104,"jobTitle":"Animal welfare grantmaking and advising","organization":null,"postCount":53,"commentCount":2694,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Philosophy, global priorities and animal welfare research. My current specific interests include: philosophy of mind, moral weights, person-affecting views, preference-based views and subjectivism, moral uncertainty, decision theory, deep uncertainty/cluelessness and backfire risks, s-risks, and indirect effects on wild animals.

I've also done economic modelling for some animal welfare issues.

Want to leave anonymous feedback for me, positive, constructive or negative? https://www.admonymous.co/michael-st-jules

Interesting! Some thoughts:

I wonder if the preparation was \"fair\", and I'd like see replications with different beef burgers. Maybe they picked a bad beef burger?
Who were the participants? E.g. students at a university, and so more liberal-leaning and already accepting of plant-based substitutes?
Could participants reliably distinguish the beef burger and the animal-like plant-based burger in the blind condition?

(I couldn't get access to the paper.)

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"wKbMWscMhbmPwEpvs","postedAt":"2023-05-03T21:47:03.912Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-05-03T21:47:03.915Z","score":0.0028579372446984053,"baseScore":11,"voteCount":6,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":0,"agreement":2,"approvalVoteCount":6,"agreementVoteCount":1},"parentCommentId":"iFmCjJLadjw5SbyzD","topLevelCommentId":"Jn58DHFkbGWA5GpuA","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

This Twitter thread points out that the beef burger was less heavily salted.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"smBaernENGigmTbRn","postedAt":"2023-05-07T09:47:02.159Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-05-07T09:47:02.161Z","score":0.001496203476563096,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agreement":0,"approvalVoteCount":3,"agreementVoteCount":0},"parentCommentId":"Jn58DHFkbGWA5GpuA","topLevelCommentId":"Jn58DHFkbGWA5GpuA","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"33FdNS7CjcfkFdsKE","slug":"linch","displayName":"Linch","username":"Linch","createdAt":"2015-12-21T21:21:36.402Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":28504,"jobTitle":null,"organization":"Forethought","postCount":83,"commentCount":3014,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$80","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"4NbqLbecNQhPEcvwR","postedAt":"2023-05-11T03:11:36.611Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-05-11T03:11:36.613Z","score":0.0023996420204639435,"baseScore":9,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

I run the Studio team 80,000 Hours, which produces the 80,000 Hours podcast. Previously I worked at the Global Priorities Institute, ran Giving What We Can and was a Fund Manager at the Effective Altruism Infrastructure Fund.

Comments here are my own views only, not my present or past employers', unless otherwise specified.

Thank you for the prompt.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"YzFz5kELSmjqxDJfF","postedAt":"2023-09-26T06:04:43.991Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-28T20:48:47.366Z","score":0.007188329007476568,"baseScore":25,"voteCount":17,"extendedScore":{"agree":13,"disagree":2,"agreement":13,"approvalVoteCount":17,"agreementVoteCount":15},"parentCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":8,"directChildrenCount":3,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"shgRF2QBhtYAWPv3H","slug":"tobiash","displayName":"Tobias Häberli","username":"TobiasH","createdAt":"2018-12-28T10:29:38.423Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":2237,"jobTitle":null,"organization":"Pivotal Research","postCount":21,"commentCount":175,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$83","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"t4Ztah87puchefKjc","postedAt":"2023-09-26T13:51:38.832Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-28T20:48:47.366Z","score":0.0033582241740077734,"baseScore":11,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{"agree":2,"disagree":2},"parentCommentId":"YzFz5kELSmjqxDJfF","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":5,"directChildrenCount":3,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"srRkgcZBH8jrz8bXB","slug":"sean_o_h","displayName":"Sean_o_h","username":"Sean_o_h","createdAt":"2014-12-24T11:34:52.194Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":3933,"jobTitle":"Research Programme Director","organization":"University of Cambridge","postCount":6,"commentCount":221,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I direct the AI:Futures and Responsibility Programme (https://www.ai-far.org/) at the University of Cambridge, which works on AI strategy, safety and governance. I also work on global catastrophic risks with the Centre for the Study of Existential Risk and AI strategy/policy with the Centre for the Future of Intelligence.

Yeah, unfortunately I suspect that \"he claimed to be an altruist doing good! As part of this weird framework/community!\" is going to be substantial part of what makes this an interesting story for writers/media, and what makes it more interesting than \"he was doing criminal things in crypto\" (which I suspect is just not that interesting on its own at this point, even at such a large scale).

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"PcMutF6LE7iWXyavQ","postedAt":"2023-09-26T15:35:35.859Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-26T15:35:35.863Z","score":0.0015692560700699687,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agreement":0,"approvalVoteCount":3,"agreementVoteCount":0},"parentCommentId":"YzFz5kELSmjqxDJfF","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Yeah, \"touches on EA but isn't centred on it\" is my modal prediction for how major stories will go. I expect that more minor stories (e.g. the daily \"here's what happened on day n of the trial\" story) will usually not mention EA. But obviously it's hard to predict these things with much confidence.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"RjfRRu7hfogkzZrz8","postedAt":"2023-09-26T20:01:35.230Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-27T16:45:42.460Z","score":0.0008704814244993031,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{"agree":2,"disagree":4},"parentCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"t82GrL36caqfrWSZ8","slug":"quinn","displayName":"quinn","username":"quinn","createdAt":"2020-12-13T23:58:06.540Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":2216,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":18,"commentCount":327,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

(I forgot to tell JP and Lizka in at EAG in NY a few weeks ago, but now's as good a time as any):

Can my profile karma total be two numbers, one for community and one for other stuff? I don't want a reader to think my actual work is valuable to people in proportion to my EA Forum karma, as far as I can tell I think 3-5x my karma is community sourced compared to my object-level posts. People should look at my profile as \"this guy procrastinates through PVP on social media like everyone else, he should work harder on things that matter\".

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"kLeQLmxTMNdvws4pa","postedAt":"2023-09-26T20:03:15.037Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-26T20:03:15.050Z","score":0.001568232080899179,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":2,"disagree":0,"agreement":3,"approvalVoteCount":3,"agreementVoteCount":2},"parentCommentId":"t4Ztah87puchefKjc","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"t82GrL36caqfrWSZ8","slug":"quinn","displayName":"quinn","username":"quinn","createdAt":"2020-12-13T23:58:06.540Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":2216,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":18,"commentCount":327,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Michael Lewis wouldn't do it as a gotcha/sneer, but this is a reason I'll be upset if Adam McKay ends up with the movie.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"bezMmv5QPw34YjEDQ","postedAt":"2023-09-26T21:17:47.131Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-27T16:45:42.460Z","score":0.0022724352311342955,"baseScore":7,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":1,"agreement":0,"approvalVoteCount":2,"agreementVoteCount":2},"parentCommentId":"RjfRRu7hfogkzZrz8","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Yeah, I kind of agree that we should do something here; maybe the two-dimensional thing you mentioned, or maybe community karma should count less/not at all.

Could you add a comment here?

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"yefNA6T2iGekasjwf","postedAt":"2023-09-27T10:18:21.025Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-27T16:45:42.460Z","score":0.001992950914427638,"baseScore":7,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{"agree":4,"disagree":1,"agreement":2,"approvalVoteCount":4,"agreementVoteCount":5},"parentCommentId":"bezMmv5QPw34YjEDQ","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"4wxZHKkytzf5CZvxK","slug":"t_w","displayName":"T_W","username":"tswizzle96","createdAt":"2022-09-23T15:20:22.549Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":1330,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":23,"commentCount":179,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I hope you've smiled today :)

Discovering EA has been one of the best things to happen to me in my life. I think I likely share something really important with all the people that consider themselves under this umbrella. EA can be a question, sure, but I hope more than that that EA can be a community, one that really works towards making the world a little better than it was. Please feel free to message if I can ever be of help.

Could see a number of potentially good solutions here, but think the \"not at all\" is possibly not the greatest idea. Creating a separate community karma could lead to a sort of system of social clout that may not be desirable, but I also think having no way to signal who has and has not in the past been a major contributor to the community as a topic would be more of a failure mode because I often use it to get a deeper sense of how to think about the claims in a given comment/post.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"kbgBQS5q6harhRJPn","postedAt":"2023-09-27T13:54:17.142Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-27T15:28:35.059Z","score":0.0033634421415627003,"baseScore":11,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":0,"agreement":2,"approvalVoteCount":4,"agreementVoteCount":1},"parentCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"8WBD8X9dcMvkGiN5G","slug":"larks","displayName":"Larks","username":"Larks","createdAt":"2014-09-20T20:07:58.285Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":16912,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":28,"commentCount":1662,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

If I understand this correctly, maybe not in the trial itself:

Accordingly, the defendant is precluded from referring to any alleged prior good acts by the defendant, including any charity or philanthropy, as indicative of his character or his guilt or innocence.

I guess technically the prosecution could still bring it up.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"LsR6zwGsNnAeFWnbT","postedAt":"2023-09-27T14:40:02.556Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-27T16:59:41.398Z","score":0.007024062797427177,"baseScore":24,"voteCount":12,"extendedScore":{"agree":6,"disagree":0,"agreement":20,"approvalVoteCount":12,"agreementVoteCount":6},"parentCommentId":"t4Ztah87puchefKjc","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"xn3DTnCvwddKTX9Sm","slug":"davidnash","displayName":"DavidNash","username":"DavidNash","createdAt":"2014-12-19T12:45:07.177Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":5407,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":86,"commentCount":340,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Newsletter - Global Development & EA

The Panorama episode briefly mentioned EA. Peter Singer spoke for a couple of minutes and EA was mainly viewed as charity that would be missing out on money. There seemed to be a lot more interest on the internal discussions within FTX, crypto drama, the politicians, celebrities etc.

Maybe Panorama is an outlier but potentially EA is not that interesting to most people or seemingly too complicated to explain if you only have an hour.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"NoaNax9PNLBbKNcxr","postedAt":"2023-09-27T15:08:58.931Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-27T15:08:58.944Z","score":0.0006496715941466391,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":0,"agreement":1,"approvalVoteCount":1,"agreementVoteCount":1},"parentCommentId":"LsR6zwGsNnAeFWnbT","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"srRkgcZBH8jrz8bXB","slug":"sean_o_h","displayName":"Sean_o_h","username":"Sean_o_h","createdAt":"2014-12-24T11:34:52.194Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":3933,"jobTitle":"Research Programme Director","organization":"University of Cambridge","postCount":6,"commentCount":221,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Good to know, thank you.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"nG87DuCQ9Rmhec4uM","postedAt":"2023-09-27T15:28:34.579Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-27T15:28:34.584Z","score":0.0015870961360633373,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agreement":0,"approvalVoteCount":3,"agreementVoteCount":0},"parentCommentId":"kbgBQS5q6harhRJPn","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

I hadn't realized that, thanks for sharing

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"EdkAFzdrp83jPv5R2","postedAt":"2023-09-27T16:45:41.994Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-27T16:45:42.000Z","score":0.0008716629818081856,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"agreement":0,"approvalVoteCount":2,"agreementVoteCount":0},"parentCommentId":"yefNA6T2iGekasjwf","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"t82GrL36caqfrWSZ8","slug":"quinn","displayName":"quinn","username":"quinn","createdAt":"2020-12-13T23:58:06.540Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":2216,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":18,"commentCount":327,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

There would be some UX ways to make community clout feel lower status than the other clout, I agree with you that having community clout means more investment / should be preferred over a new account which for all you know is a driveby dunk/sneer after wandering in on twitter.

I'll cc this to my feature request in the proper thread.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"DYnF7KotmKQGKpGG8","postedAt":"2023-09-27T16:59:40.660Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-27T16:59:40.665Z","score":0.0036954216193407774,"baseScore":12,"voteCount":7,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"LsR6zwGsNnAeFWnbT","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"RCd6bMJxLwK29NWFH","slug":"nathan","displayName":"Nathan Young","username":"nathan","createdAt":"2019-05-03T06:27:48.177Z","profileImageId":"Profile/nnysonhnlmvidf7kt1ov","karma":17820,"jobTitle":"Project manager/Director","organization":"Frostwork (web app agency)","postCount":146,"commentCount":2650,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Builds web apps (eg viewpoints.xyz) and makes forecasts. Currently I have spare capacity.

Yeah I was interviewed for a podcast by a canadian station on this topic (cos a canadian hedge fund was very involved). iirc they had 6 episodes but dropped the EA angle because it was too complex.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"zAsttQoaGxhoGenW3","postedAt":"2023-09-28T20:47:36.173Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-28T20:47:36.183Z","score":0.0029337138403207064,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"YzFz5kELSmjqxDJfF","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"4wxZHKkytzf5CZvxK","slug":"t_w","displayName":"T_W","username":"tswizzle96","createdAt":"2022-09-23T15:20:22.549Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":1330,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":23,"commentCount":179,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I hope you've smiled today :)

Update: the court ruled SBF can't make reference to his philanthropy

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"Jf3wBDS8isvEXKF3L","postedAt":"2023-09-28T20:48:46.966Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-09-28T20:48:46.968Z","score":0.0029337157029658556,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":2,"disagree":0,"agreement":8,"approvalVoteCount":3,"agreementVoteCount":2},"parentCommentId":"t4Ztah87puchefKjc","topLevelCommentId":"7WDTqoSfCRbuNvLGK","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"TRZewkduE3rfchqxx","slug":"joshcmorrison","displayName":"joshcmorrison","username":"joshcmorrison","createdAt":"2014-11-15T22:33:33.526Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":1860,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":12,"commentCount":78,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Agree with this and also with the point below that the EA angle is kind of too complicated to be super compelling for a broad audience. I thought this New Yorker piece's discussion (which involved EA a decent amount in a way I thought was quite fair -- https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/10/02/inside-sam-bankman-frieds-family-bubble) might give a sense of magnitude (though the NYer audience is going to be more interested in these sort of nuances than most.

The other factors I think are: 1. to what extent there are vivid new tidbits or revelations in Lewis's book that relate to EA and 2. the drama around Caroline Ellison and other witnesses at trial and the extent to which that is connected to EA; my guess is the drama around the cooperating witnesses will seem very interesting on a human level, though I don't necessarily think that will point towards the effective altruism community specifically.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","postedAt":"2023-11-29T17:51:37.135Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:54.106Z","score":0.014800933189690113,"baseScore":49,"voteCount":24,"extendedScore":{"love":6,"agree":6,"disagree":3},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":15,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Thanks for the helpful comment – I had not seen John's dialogue and I think he is making a valid point.

Fair point that the lack of impact might not be due to attention span but instead things like having competing messages.

In case you missed it: Angelina Li compiled some growth metrics about EA here; they seem to indicate that FTX's collapse did not \"strangle\" EA (though it probably wasn't good).

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"sdjDDGDBioEqSNjbh","postedAt":"2023-11-29T22:54:22.219Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:54.106Z","score":0.00965270958840847,"baseScore":32,"voteCount":22,"extendedScore":{"agree":15,"disagree":5,"insightful":2},"parentCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":12,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

I've commented before that FTX's collapse had little effect on the average person’s perception of EA

Just for the record, I think the evidence you cited there was shoddy, and I think we are seeing continued references to FTX in basically all coverage of the OpenAI situation, showing that it did clearly have a lasting effect on the perception of EA.

Reputation is lazily-evaluated. Yes, if you ask a random person on the street what they think of you, they won't know, but when your decisions start influencing them, they will start getting informed, and we are seeing really very clear evidence that when people start getting informed, FTX is heavily influencing their opinion.

","reactors":{"insightful":["niplav","Buck"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"bHBv5unvnLdxMCeTL","postedAt":"2023-11-29T23:58:20.887Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:54.106Z","score":0.0019398716976866126,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"sdjDDGDBioEqSNjbh","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":10,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

we are seeing really very clear evidence that when people start getting informed, FTX is heavily influencing their opinion.

Thanks! Could you share said evidence? The data sources I cited certainly have limitations, having access to more surveys etc. would be valuable.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"42A8cWvZjsRR2bmos","postedAt":"2023-11-30T00:42:29.756Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:54.106Z","score":0.004078037105500698,"baseScore":13,"voteCount":8,"extendedScore":{"agree":4},"parentCommentId":"bHBv5unvnLdxMCeTL","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":7,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

Software Developer at Giving What We Can, trying to make giving significantly and effectively a social norm.

The Wikipedia page on effective altruism mentions Bankman-Fried 11 times, and after/during the OpenAI story, it was edited to include a lot of criticism, ~half of which was written after FTX (e.g. it quotes this tweet https://twitter.com/sama/status/1593046526284410880 )

It's the first place I would go to if I wanted an independent take on \"what's effective altruism?\" I expect many others to do the same.

","reactors":{"helpful":["Ben_West🔸","Linch","Aaron Gertler 🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"AGaxmN5kb5ovHkvDR","postedAt":"2023-11-30T01:19:40.672Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:54.106Z","score":0.0012235220056027174,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"42A8cWvZjsRR2bmos","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":6,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Ah yeah sorry, the claim of the post you criticized was not that FTX isn't mentioned in the press, but rather that those mentions don't seem to actually have impacted sentiment very much.

I thought when you said \"FTX is heavily influencing their opinion\" you were referring to changes in sentiment, but possibly I misunderstood you – if you just mean \"journalists mention it a lot\" then I agree.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"cPejkNodZdz6dZPQA","postedAt":"2023-11-30T02:11:39.231Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:54.106Z","score":0.0007610474713146687,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":"AGaxmN5kb5ovHkvDR","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":5,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

You are also welcome to check Twitter mentions or do other analysis of people talking publicly about EA. I don't think this is a \"journalist only\" thing. I will take bets you will see a similar pattern.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"DadzyezushwG8abMd","postedAt":"2023-11-30T02:40:13.913Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:54.106Z","score":0.003129633143544197,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":2},"parentCommentId":"cPejkNodZdz6dZPQA","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":4,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

There are a lot of recent edits on that article by a single editor, apparently a former NY Times reporter (the edit log is public). From the edit summaries, those edits look rather unfriendly, and the article as a whole feels negatively slanted to me. So I'm not sure how much weight I'd give that article specifically.

\n","reactors":{"helpful":["Ben_West🔸","NickLaing","Linch"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"RFxMsY2i23W4z2tXQ","postedAt":"2023-11-30T03:50:40.746Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:54.106Z","score":0.0012236216571182013,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"DadzyezushwG8abMd","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

I used the default sort (\"Top\").

(No opinion on which is more useful; I don't use Twitter much.)

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"nZ7fqxwJoJcvK5BG6","postedAt":"2023-11-30T05:35:26.747Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:54.106Z","score":0.0012236908078193665,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"agree":3},"parentCommentId":"w4jQKE33tgqjEhFhk","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

Top was mostly showing me tweets from people that I follow, so my sense is it was filtered in a personalized way. I am not fully sure how it works, but it didn't seem the right type of filter.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"Mucd5zQpL447j8sPD","postedAt":"2023-12-01T14:19:48.381Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-01T14:19:48.384Z","score":0.0007733073434792459,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":"sdjDDGDBioEqSNjbh","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"RCd6bMJxLwK29NWFH","slug":"nathan","displayName":"Nathan Young","username":"nathan","createdAt":"2019-05-03T06:27:48.177Z","profileImageId":"Profile/nnysonhnlmvidf7kt1ov","karma":17820,"jobTitle":"Project manager/Director","organization":"Frostwork (web app agency)","postCount":146,"commentCount":2650,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Builds web apps (eg viewpoints.xyz) and makes forecasts. Currently I have spare capacity.

I would guess too that these two events have made it much easier to reference EA in passing. eg I think this article wouldn't have been written 18 months ago. https://www.politico.com/news/2023/10/13/open-philanthropy-funding-ai-policy-00121362

So I think there is a real jump of notoriety once the journalistic class knows who you are. And they now know who we are. \"EA, the social movement involved in the FTX and OpenAI crises\" is not a good epithet.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"wnL5Xh3Hr3kRR6NLB","postedAt":"2023-12-05T00:38:53.603Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2023-12-05T00:38:53.611Z","score":0.0012997739249840379,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"nZ7fqxwJoJcvK5BG6","topLevelCommentId":"uomtjZSRrguo86jsC","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Yeah, makes sense. Although I just tried doing the \"latest\" sort and went through the top 40 tweets without seeing a reference to FTX/SBF.

My guess is that this filter just (unsurprisingly) shows you whatever random thing people are talking about on twitter at the moment, and it seems like the random EA-related thing of today is this, which doesn't mention FTX.

Probably you need some longitudinal data to have this be useful.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"SdoNgiDLbExCJsvma","postedAt":"2024-01-23T16:01:03.927Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-01-23T16:01:03.933Z","score":0.004868607968091965,"baseScore":15,"voteCount":10,"extendedScore":{"love":3},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

New Netflix show ~doubles search traffic for plant-based eating

h/t Lewis Bollard.

","reactors":{"love":["Toby Tremlett🔹","ChanaMessinger"]},"tags":[{"core":true,"name":"Animal welfare","slug":"animal-welfare","postCount":3290,"shortName":null,"description":"

Animal welfare is a core focus area within effective altruism. It focuses on ways to improve the wellbeing of nonhuman animals, primarily..."}]},{"_id":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","postedAt":"2024-03-05T01:24:45.422Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-11T05:04:54.897Z","score":0.002457559108734131,"baseScore":7,"voteCount":8,"extendedScore":{"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":9,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

EA Three Comma Club

I'm interested in EA organizations that can plausibly be said to have improved the lives of over a billion individuals. Ones I'm currently aware of:

Shrimp Welfare Project – they provide this Guesstimate, which has a mean estimate of 1.2B shrimps per year affected by welfare improvements that they have pushed
Aquatic Life Institute – they provide this spreadsheet, though I agree with Bella that it's not clear where some of the numbers are coming from.

Are there any others?

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"brgkyH8jcRRKkwLXE","postedAt":"2024-03-05T03:11:35.208Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-11T05:04:54.897Z","score":0.003094431711360812,"baseScore":9,"voteCount":10,"extendedScore":{"agree":7,"helpful":1,"disagree":8},"parentCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","topLevelCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","descendentCount":6,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

This is a nitpick, but somehow someone \"being an individual\" reads to me as implying a level of consciousness that seems a stretch for shrimps. But IDK, seems like a non-crazy choice under some worldviews.

","reactors":{"helpful":["niplav"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"Kmhern9DQ7isgnbon","postedAt":"2024-03-06T02:17:21.866Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-11T05:04:54.897Z","score":0.0006281592650339007,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":4},"parentCommentId":"brgkyH8jcRRKkwLXE","topLevelCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","descendentCount":5,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

That's fair. I personally like that this forces people to come to terms with the fact that interventions targeted at small animals are way more scalable than those targeted at larger ones. People might decide on some moral weights which cancel out the scale of small animal work, but that's a nontrivial philosophical assumption, and I like prompting people to think about whether it's actually reasonable.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"xyyLnRRMYmFiGrtdE","postedAt":"2024-03-06T02:42:48.799Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-06T22:37:21.963Z","score":0.0008093305514194071,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","topLevelCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"z9YQK84zJTvjmWRNZ","slug":"calebp","displayName":"calebp","username":"calebp","createdAt":"2018-10-16T00:05:32.996Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":6080,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":20,"commentCount":502,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":""},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

If the funders get a nontrivial portion of the impact for early-stage projects then I think the AWF (inc. its donors) is very plausible.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"xioaoqLq9JBqYe23N","postedAt":"2024-03-06T03:19:40.528Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-11T05:04:54.897Z","score":0.0017954022623598576,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":{"agree":4,"disagree":4},"parentCommentId":"Kmhern9DQ7isgnbon","topLevelCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","descendentCount":4,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

I think \"animals that have more neurons or are more complex are morally more important\" is not a \"nontrivial philosophical assumption\".

It indeed strikes me as a quite trivial philosophical assumption the denial of which would I think seem absurd to almost anyone considering it. Maybe one can argue the effect is offset by the sheer number, but I think you will find almost no one on the planet who would argue that these things do not matter.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"cLr2Xmh6H5FGDLKtd","postedAt":"2024-03-06T22:36:04.209Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-11T05:04:54.897Z","score":0.0011838620994240046,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":7,"extendedScore":{"agree":3,"disagree":7},"parentCommentId":"xioaoqLq9JBqYe23N","topLevelCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Yeah, I am not sure how to treat meta. In addition to funders, Charity Entrepreneurship probably gets substantial credit for SWP, etc.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"cAzc8fKvCKzu6dEFJ","postedAt":"2024-03-07T17:59:07.651Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-11T05:04:54.897Z","score":0.0022570807486772537,"baseScore":7,"voteCount":8,"extendedScore":{"agree":4,"disagree":2},"parentCommentId":"cLr2Xmh6H5FGDLKtd","topLevelCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

Come on, you know you are using a hilariously unrepresentative datapoint here. Within humans the variance of neuron count only explains a small fraction of variance in experience and also we have strong societal norms that push people's map towards pretending differences like this don't matter.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"Y6d2Wm6Mwakadnhg9","postedAt":"2024-03-07T19:48:59.402Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-11T05:04:54.897Z","score":-0.0007033065194264054,"baseScore":-2,"voteCount":6,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":"cAzc8fKvCKzu6dEFJ","topLevelCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Unrepresentative of what? At least in my University ethics courses we spent way more time arguing about the rights of anencephalic children or human fetuses than insects. (And I would guess that neuron count explains a large fraction of the variance in experience between adult and fetal humans, for example.)

In any case: I think most people's moral intuitions are terrible and you shouldn't learn a ton from the fact that people disagree with you. But as a purely descriptive matter, there are plenty of people who disagree with you – so much so that reading their arguments is a standard part of bioethics 101 in the US.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"uSxCBACbGiSudzc5m","postedAt":"2024-03-11T05:04:54.495Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-11T05:04:54.498Z","score":0.0014269487001001835,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"Y6d2Wm6Mwakadnhg9","topLevelCommentId":"XDFds2hDoywqpN4sc","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

It's unrepresentative of the degree to which people believe that corollaries like neuron count and brain size and behavior complexity are an indicator of moral relevance across species (which is the question at hand here).

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"YuuoWWGKgLaBGSqqN","postedAt":"2024-03-27T17:20:25.916Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-03-27T17:20:25.919Z","score":0.0007515763281844556,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"FQH3NiPweQiyFzbhj","topLevelCommentId":"5zq4YZz4DHNKrLAQP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"YakMuM4sRNSmaY7E8","slug":"80000_hours","displayName":"80000_Hours","username":"80000_Hours","createdAt":"2017-02-08T05:41:53.145Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":7384,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":219,"commentCount":35,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

We also offer audio version of those highlights for all episodes on the '80k After Hours' feed: https://80000hours.org/after-hours-podcast/

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"PF4nni93zhE63ddAs","postedAt":"2024-04-10T09:46:44.732Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-10T09:46:44.734Z","score":0.0005482423002831638,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"5zq4YZz4DHNKrLAQP","topLevelCommentId":"5zq4YZz4DHNKrLAQP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"iHSQAHHRbCLkcXNKa","slug":"yarrow-bouchard","displayName":"Yarrow Bouchard 🔸","username":"Yarrow Bouchard","createdAt":"2023-05-20T21:55:50.210Z","profileImageId":"Profile/jdtjwtqe2ngmumgeesuo","karma":1580,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":35,"commentCount":802,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I got interested in effective altruism back before it was called effective altruism, back before Giving What We Can had a website. Later on, I got involved in my university EA group and helped run it for a few years. I joined the Effective Altruism Forum to try to figure out where effective altruism could fit into my life these days and what it means to me. You can read my latest thoughts on effective altruism here.

I write on Substack, and used to write on Medium.

Pronouns: she/her or they/them.

To me, economy of words is what’s important, rather than overall length. Long can be wonderful, as long as the writer uses all those words well. Short can be wonderful, if the writer uses enough words to convey their complete thoughts.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"RwRssW5pL3tYb2Bqr","postedAt":"2024-04-17T16:55:01.695Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-18T23:27:56.230Z","score":0.02545945718884468,"baseScore":76,"voteCount":29,"extendedScore":{"love":19,"agree":10},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Marcus Daniell appreciation note

@Marcus Daniell, cofounder of High Impact Athletes, came back from knee surgery and is donating half of his prize money this year. He projects raising $100,000. Through a partnership with Momentum, people can pledge to donate for each point he gets; he has raised $28,000 through this so far. It's cool to see this, and I'm wishing him luck for his final year of professional play!

","reactors":{"love":["M_Allcock","Emma_2","Jason","Linch","Dane Valerie","Kirsten","GraceAdams🔸","Jack","Pete Rowlett","eirine🔸","Jakub Stencel","MaxRa","David Mathers🔸","OllieRodriguez","Vidur Kapur","michel","Lucio","mhendric🔸"]},"tags":[{"core":true,"name":"Effective giving","slug":"effective-giving","postCount":2402,"shortName":null,"description":"

Effective giving is the branch of effective altruism focused on charitable donations.

The main purpose of effective giving is to support a charity or project that can achieve an..."}]},{"_id":"EaGBvXhfgTHPm7PxB","postedAt":"2024-04-18T00:35:10.380Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-18T00:35:10.387Z","score":0.002850711578503251,"baseScore":8,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{"love":2},"parentCommentId":"RwRssW5pL3tYb2Bqr","topLevelCommentId":"RwRssW5pL3tYb2Bqr","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"gtCnDWH6Jb6iwf8nb","slug":"graceadams","displayName":"GraceAdams🔸","username":"GraceAdams","createdAt":"2021-12-23T01:39:47.723Z","profileImageId":"Profile/fvjild1jnjeujcj9dpum","karma":3196,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Effective Altruism Australia","postCount":16,"commentCount":111,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Leading Australia's key place to engaged with effective giving and the effective altruism community in Australia.

I was lucky enough to see Marcus play this year at the Australian Open, and have pledged alongside him! Marcus is so hardworking - in tennis alongside his work at High Impact Athletes! Go Marcus!!!

","reactors":{"love":["Ben_West🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"5uNqiKmaFeRBzsc2S","postedAt":"2024-04-18T23:27:56.074Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-18T23:27:56.076Z","score":0.0006956959841772914,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"RwRssW5pL3tYb2Bqr","topLevelCommentId":"RwRssW5pL3tYb2Bqr","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"QmYHTS6E82ie4W4o2","slug":"nicklaing","displayName":"NickLaing","username":"NickLaing","createdAt":"2018-10-27T19:29:41.333Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":14602,"jobTitle":"CEO and Co-Founder","organization":"OneDay Health","postCount":30,"commentCount":1889,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I'm a doctor working towards the dream that every human will have access to high quality healthcare. I'm a medic and director of OneDay Health, which has launched 53 simple but comprehensive nurse-led health centers in remote rural Ugandan Villages. A huge thanks to the EA Cambridge student community in 2018 for helping me realise that I could do more good by focusing on providing healthcare in remote places.

New Zealand let's go!

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"a4qHKcfoNMaE8xjmw","postedAt":"2024-04-20T19:01:16.131Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-20T19:01:16.133Z","score":0.030125444754958153,"baseScore":90,"voteCount":29,"extendedScore":{"love":9,"agree":7},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Animal Justice Appreciation Note

Animal Justice et al. v A.G of Ontario 2024 was recently decided and struck down large portions of Ontario's ag-gag law. A blog post is here. The suit was partially funded by ACE, which presumably means that many of the people reading this deserve partial credit for donating to support it.

Thanks to Animal Justice (Andrea Gonsalves, Fredrick Schumann,\nKaitlyn Mitchell, Scott Tinney), co-applicants Jessica Scott-Reid and Louise Jorgensen, and everyone who supported this work!

\n","reactors":{"love":["Michael St Jules 🔸","JamesÖz 🔸","David Mathers🔸","Vidur Kapur","Matt Putz","Bella","Spencer R. Ericson","JP Addison🔸"]},"tags":[{"core":true,"name":"Animal welfare","slug":"animal-welfare","postCount":3290,"shortName":null,"description":"

Animal welfare is a core focus area within effective altruism. It focuses on ways to improve the wellbeing of nonhuman animals, primarily..."}]},{"_id":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","postedAt":"2024-04-24T17:22:25.211Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-27T21:42:25.850Z","score":0.02397281490266323,"baseScore":71,"voteCount":31,"extendedScore":{"love":15,"agree":1},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":6,"directChildrenCount":3,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Animal welfare is a core focus area within effective altruism. It focuses on ways to improve the wellbeing of nonhuman animals, primarily..."}]},{"_id":"2fJpd7BGJriNu2ts4","postedAt":"2024-04-24T21:03:04.574Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-24T21:03:04.576Z","score":0.0005595085676759481,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"love":1,"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","topLevelCommentId":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"RCd6bMJxLwK29NWFH","slug":"nathan","displayName":"Nathan Young","username":"nathan","createdAt":"2019-05-03T06:27:48.177Z","profileImageId":"Profile/nnysonhnlmvidf7kt1ov","karma":17820,"jobTitle":"Project manager/Director","organization":"Frostwork (web app agency)","postCount":146,"commentCount":2650,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Builds web apps (eg viewpoints.xyz) and makes forecasts. Currently I have spare capacity.

Wow this is wonderful news.

","reactors":{"love":["Ben_West🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"wdkWyFsYWz4eX2P8n","postedAt":"2024-04-26T06:41:17.521Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-27T19:38:11.822Z","score":0.0011619955766946077,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","topLevelCommentId":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"wHYMwqvhgnsQTDQde","slug":"gina_stuessy","displayName":"Gina_Stuessy🔸","username":"Gina_Stuessy","createdAt":"2014-08-21T01:29:59.813Z","profileImageId":"Profile/h7onvwgrljft0qve3roq","karma":199,"jobTitle":"Finance Director","organization":"Animal Charity Evaluators","postCount":9,"commentCount":51,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I'm the Finance Director at Animal Charity Evaluators. I co-founded and co-led EA Madison (Wis.) and have been involved in effective altruism since 2013.

How many chicks per year will Egg Innovations' change save? (The announcement link is blocked for me.)

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"xwWEduwx8xABDwprt","postedAt":"2024-04-27T17:24:59.513Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-27T17:24:59.517Z","score":0.0007515787146985531,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"wdkWyFsYWz4eX2P8n","topLevelCommentId":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

I don't think they say, unfortunately.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"RpXuQf4DPfe4wrimp","postedAt":"2024-04-27T19:38:11.655Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-27T19:38:11.660Z","score":0.0013962851371616125,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"helpful":1,"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":"wdkWyFsYWz4eX2P8n","topLevelCommentId":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":null,"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Egg Innovations, which sells 300 million free-range and pasture-raised eggs a year

This interview with the CEO suggests that Egg Innovations are just in the laying (not broiler) business and that each hen produces ~400 eggs over her lifetime. So this will save ~750,000 chicks a year?

","reactors":{"helpful":["Ben_West🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"zFx2MmXfszCbL6ivF","postedAt":"2024-04-27T21:10:02.412Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-27T21:42:25.850Z","score":0.002215117681771517,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"helpful":1},"parentCommentId":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","topLevelCommentId":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"2vttqBLW4EfhkbxE8","slug":"julia_wise","displayName":"Julia_Wise🔸","username":"Julia_Wise","createdAt":"2014-08-21T01:29:44.041Z","profileImageId":"Profile/cdj7x6ssxfxnh0cbyxp9","karma":15474,"jobTitle":"Community liaison","organization":"Centre for Effective Altruism","postCount":81,"commentCount":568,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I'm one of the contact people for the effective altruism community. I work at CEA as the head of the Community Health team, trying to support the EA community in addressing problems and being a healthy and welcoming community.

Please feel free to contact me at julia.wise@centreforeffectivealtruism.org.

Besides effective altruism, I'm interested in folk dance and trying to keep up with my three children.

For others who were curious about what time difference this makes: looks like sex identification is possible at 9 days after the egg is laid, vs 21 days for the egg to hatch (plus an additional ~2 days between fertilization and the laying of the egg.) Chicken embryonic development is really fast, with some stages measured in hours rather than days.

","reactors":{"helpful":["Ben_West🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"mzzF4zMAN4hBKcCoi","postedAt":"2024-04-27T21:42:25.527Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-04-27T21:42:25.531Z","score":0.0022596833296120167,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"helpful":3},"parentCommentId":"zFx2MmXfszCbL6ivF","topLevelCommentId":"buqNbY4nnPtfL2nYt","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":null,"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

I asked Google when chicken embryos start to feel pain and this was the first result (i.e. I didn't look hard and I didn't anchor on a figure):

A recent study by the Technical University of Munich in Germany measured chicken embryos' heart rate, brain activity, blood pressure and movements in response to potentially painful stimuli like heat and electricity and concluded that they didn't seem to feel them until at least day 13. (14 Oct 2023)

","reactors":{"helpful":["Ben_West🔸","Nathan Young","Julia_Wise🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","postedAt":"2024-11-19T18:20:28.042Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-22T02:00:19.838Z","score":0.017888210713863373,"baseScore":43,"voteCount":27,"extendedScore":{"agree":7},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":37,"directChildrenCount":7,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

EA in a World Where People Actually Listen to Us

I had considered calling the third wave of EA \"EA in a World Where People Actually Listen to Us\".

Leopold's situational awareness memo has become a salient example of this for me. I used to sometimes think that arguments about whether we should avoid discussing the power of AI in order to avoid triggering an arms race were a bit silly and self important because obviously defense leaders aren't going to be listening to some random internet charity nerds and changing policy as a result.

Well, they are and they are. Let's hope it's for the better.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"wMXyEXtHqHkKcSJ5C","postedAt":"2024-11-20T07:05:01.702Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T04:35:10.223Z","score":0.002425410784780979,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":11,"extendedScore":{"agree":3,"disagree":4},"parentCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":7,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"MCiXDyQLsSBiPbYNT","slug":"charlie_guthmann","displayName":"Charlie_Guthmann","username":"Charles_Guthmann","createdAt":"2020-08-03T19:25:28.315Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":1273,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":17,"commentCount":344,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

pre-doc at Data Innovation & AI Lab
previously worked in options HFT and tried building a social media startup
founder of Northwestern EA club

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

(I think the issue with Leopold is somewhat precisely that he seems to be quite politically savvy in a way that seems likely to make him a deca-multi-millionaire and politically influental, possibly at the cost of all of humanity. I agree Eliezer is not the best presenter, but his error modes are clearly enormously different)

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"CZJkWMoqnKDDoSLXL","postedAt":"2024-11-20T07:52:43.479Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T08:25:32.792Z","score":0.024560093879699707,"baseScore":59,"voteCount":23,"extendedScore":{"agree":16,"disagree":2},"parentCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"G2BPn6M22ciugvGWm","slug":"jan_kulveit","displayName":"Jan_Kulveit","username":"Jan_Kulveit","createdAt":"2017-12-25T12:28:21.072Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":5018,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":34,"commentCount":228,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Studying behaviour and interactions of boundedly rational agents, AI alignment and complex systems.

Research fellow at Future of Humanity Institute, Oxford.\nOther projects:\nEuropean Summer Program on Rationality.\nHuman-aligned AI Summer School.\nEpistea Lab.

\n"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Seems plausible the impact of that single individual act is so negative that aggregate impact of EA is negative.

I think people should reflect seriously upon this possibility and not fall prey to wishful thinking (let's hope speeding up the AI race and making it superpower powered is the best intervention! it's better if everyone warning about this was wrong and Leopold is right!).

The broader story here is that EA prioritization methodology is really good for finding highly leveraged spots in the world, but there isn't a good methodology for figuring out what to do in such places, and there also isn't a robust pipeline for promoting virtues and virtuous actors to such places.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"hEjCfrwPWCdyYkhEA","postedAt":"2024-11-20T08:03:17.405Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T08:03:17.408Z","score":0.0024458528496325016,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":{"agree":2,"disagree":2},"parentCommentId":"SYYpsd8SdzmSsTRfJ","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"MCiXDyQLsSBiPbYNT","slug":"charlie_guthmann","displayName":"Charlie_Guthmann","username":"Charles_Guthmann","createdAt":"2020-08-03T19:25:28.315Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":1273,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":17,"commentCount":344,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

pre-doc at Data Innovation & AI Lab
previously worked in options HFT and tried building a social media startup
founder of Northwestern EA club

| and there also isn't a robust pipeline for promoting virtues and virtuous actors to such places.

this ^

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"c2YBQDn55dKYzwyDK","postedAt":"2024-11-20T08:25:32.621Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T08:25:32.624Z","score":0.003950865939259529,"baseScore":9,"voteCount":8,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":4},"parentCommentId":"CZJkWMoqnKDDoSLXL","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"zdMPbdfh24ehgNfgq","slug":"deluks917","displayName":"sapphire","username":"deluks917","createdAt":"2017-10-26T20:22:07.118Z","profileImageId":"Profile/zsdtkloorrwft4apcry9","karma":1512,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":14,"commentCount":138,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

I spent all day in tears when I read the congressional report. This is a nightmare. I was literally hoping to wake up from a bad dream.

I really hope people don't suffer for our sins.

How could we have done something so terrible. Starting an arms race and making literal war more likely.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"sAgYwnZopdGyQxxhm","postedAt":"2024-11-20T08:38:15.714Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T08:38:15.717Z","score":0.0012618458131328225,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"uurFmKn6u3ehwtWPC","slug":"david-mathers","displayName":"David Mathers🔸","username":"Dr. David Mathers","createdAt":"2021-12-22T17:51:30.252Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":6151,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":11,"commentCount":759,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Superforecaster, former philosophy PhD, Giving What We Can member since 2012. Currently trying to get into AI governance.

How do you know Leopold or anyone else actually influenced the commission's report? Not that that seems particularly unlikely to me, but is there any hard evidence? EDIT: I text-searched the report and he is not mentioned by name, although obviously that doesn't prove much on its own.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"QjmDH65fkBqXTwtQq","postedAt":"2024-11-20T08:40:13.516Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T07:29:40.134Z","score":0.004406039137393236,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":{"agree":4,"disagree":3},"parentCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"3feHTEELEyvQMYCzd","slug":"jws","displayName":"JWS 🔸","username":"JWS","createdAt":"2023-01-11T13:00:54.235Z","profileImageId":"Profile/asfnn1gxsqga0nhwmkfk","karma":4950,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":12,"commentCount":379,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

On the way out of EA.

🔸 10% Pledger.

Likes pluralist conceptions of the good.

Dislikes Bay Culture being in control of the future.

Superforecaster, former philosophy PhD, Giving What We Can member since 2012. Currently trying to get into AI governance.

I think he is pretty clearly an EA given he used to help run the Future Fund, or at most an only very recently ex-EA. Having said that, it's not clear to me this means that \"EAs\" are at fault for everything he does.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"R4PJb89m6poi22gZC","postedAt":"2024-11-20T09:01:41.428Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T09:01:41.431Z","score":0.0023669658694416285,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":2,"disagree":3},"parentCommentId":"EJmzqmZ79mwdGB47L","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"3feHTEELEyvQMYCzd","slug":"jws","displayName":"JWS 🔸","username":"JWS","createdAt":"2023-01-11T13:00:54.235Z","profileImageId":"Profile/asfnn1gxsqga0nhwmkfk","karma":4950,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":12,"commentCount":379,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

On the way out of EA.

🔸 10% Pledger.

Likes pluralist conceptions of the good.

Dislikes Bay Culture being in control of the future.

Yeah again I just think this depends on one's definition of EA, which is the point I was trying to make above.

Many people have turned away from EA, both the beliefs, institutions, and community in the aftermath of the FTX collapse. Even Ben Todd seems to not be an EA by some definitions any more, be that via association or identification. Who is to say Leopold is any different, or has not gone further? What then is the use of calling him EA, or using his views to represent the 'Third Wave' of EA?

I guess from my PoV what I'm saying is that I'm not sure there's much 'connective tissue' between Leopold and myself, so when people use phrases like \"listen to us\" or \"How could we have done\" I end up thinking \"who the heck is we/us?\"

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"vbHCsxYfW5BLo23iw","postedAt":"2024-11-20T09:59:50.415Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T04:35:10.223Z","score":0.004311472177505493,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":{"agree":4},"parentCommentId":"wMXyEXtHqHkKcSJ5C","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":4,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"uurFmKn6u3ehwtWPC","slug":"david-mathers","displayName":"David Mathers🔸","username":"Dr. David Mathers","createdAt":"2021-12-22T17:51:30.252Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":6151,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":11,"commentCount":759,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Superforecaster, former philosophy PhD, Giving What We Can member since 2012. Currently trying to get into AI governance.

The thing about Yudkowsky is that, yes, on the one hand, every time I read him, I think he surely must be coming across as super-weird and dodgy to \"normal\" people. But on the other hand, actually, it seems like he HAS done really well in getting people to take his ideas seriously? Sam Altman was trolling Yudkowsky on twitter a while back about how many of the people running/founding AGI labs had been inspired to do so by his work. He got invited to write on AI governance for TIME despite having no formal qualifications or significant scientific achievements whatsoever. I think if we actually look at his track record, he has done pretty well at convincing influential people to adopt what were once extremely fringe views, whilst also succeeding in being seen by the wider world as one of the most important proponents of those views, despite an almost complete lack of mainstream, legible credentials.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"9jCAZjHKTHbitNprN","postedAt":"2024-11-20T16:10:45.027Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-22T02:00:19.838Z","score":0.004135151393711567,"baseScore":9,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{"agree":4,"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":18,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"jBF5BB7DMfJAzJ8Xf","slug":"michaeldickens","displayName":"MichaelDickens","username":"MichaelDickens","createdAt":"2014-09-10T16:22:19.751Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":8653,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":105,"commentCount":1124,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I do independent research on EA topics. I write about whatever seems important, tractable, and interesting (to me).

I have a website: https://mdickens.me/ Much of the content on my website gets cross-posted to the EA Forum, but I also write about some non-EA stuff over there.

I used to work as a software developer at Affirm.

I don't want to claim all EAs believe the same things, but if the congressional commission had listened to what you might call the \"central\" EA position, it would not be recommending an arms race because it would be much more concerned about misalignment risk. The overwhelming majority of EAs involved in AI safety seem to agree that arms races are bad and misalignment risk is the biggest concern (within AI safety). So if anything this is a problem of the commission not listening to EAs, or at least selectively listening to only the parts they want to hear.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"5WsDMFeZYBZR8gwKM","postedAt":"2024-11-20T16:49:19.098Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-22T02:00:19.838Z","score":0.01094031147658825,"baseScore":26,"voteCount":10,"extendedScore":{"agree":4,"helpful":3,"disagree":1,"insightful":2,"changed-mind":1},"parentCommentId":"9jCAZjHKTHbitNprN","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":15,"directChildrenCount":3,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

I do independent research on EA topics. I write about whatever seems important, tractable, and interesting (to me).

I have a website: https://mdickens.me/ Much of the content on my website gets cross-posted to the EA Forum, but I also write about some non-EA stuff over there.

I used to work as a software developer at Affirm.

It looks to me like the online EA community, and the EAs I know IRL, have a fairly strong consensus that arms races are bad. Perhaps there's a divide in opinions with most self-identified EAs on one side, and policy people / company leaders on the other side—which in my view is unfortunate since the people holding the most power are also the most wrong.

(Is there some systematic reason why this would be true? At least one part of it makes sense: people who start AGI companies must believe that building AGI is the right move. It could also be that power corrupts, or something.)

So maybe I should say the congressional commission should've spent less time listening to EA policy people and more time reading the EA Forum. Which obviously was never going to happen but it would've been nice.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"Fta5NTBFGeXWctHvt","postedAt":"2024-11-20T17:12:01.215Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T20:39:00.249Z","score":0.004407959524542093,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":6,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":"c9qsJmiJ8k5mXTCmR","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":4,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

Yep, my impression is that this is an opinion that people mostly adopted after spending a bunch of time in DC and engaging with governance stuff, and so is not something represented in the broader EA population.

My best explanation is that when working in governance, being pro-China is just very costly, and especially combining the belief that AI will be very powerful, and there is no urgency to beat China to it, seems very anti-memetic in DC, and so people working in the space started adopting those stances.

But I am not sure. There are also non-terrible arguments for beating China being really important (though they are mostly premised on alignment being relatively easy, which seems very wrong to me).

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"cE5PbDn78Zzemc52z","postedAt":"2024-11-20T17:26:10.112Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T20:39:00.249Z","score":0.0008415873744525015,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":"Fta5NTBFGeXWctHvt","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"jBF5BB7DMfJAzJ8Xf","slug":"michaeldickens","displayName":"MichaelDickens","username":"MichaelDickens","createdAt":"2014-09-10T16:22:19.751Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":8653,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":105,"commentCount":1124,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I do independent research on EA topics. I write about whatever seems important, tractable, and interesting (to me).

I have a website: https://mdickens.me/ Much of the content on my website gets cross-posted to the EA Forum, but I also write about some non-EA stuff over there.

I used to work as a software developer at Affirm.

\n
(though they are mostly premised on alignment being relatively easy, which seems very wrong to me)
\n

Not just alignment being easy, but alignment being easy with overwhelmingly high probability. It seems to me that pushing for an arms race is bad even if there's only a 5% chance that alignment is hard.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"tmBRPnvEXj9oKfRj5","postedAt":"2024-11-20T17:53:48.259Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T20:39:00.249Z","score":0.001696971943601966,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"helpful":1},"parentCommentId":"cE5PbDn78Zzemc52z","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

I think most of those people believe that \"having an AI aligned to 'China's values'\" would be comparably bad to a catastrophic misalignment failure, and if you believe that, 5% is not sufficient, if you think there is a greater than 5% of China ending up with \"aligned AI\" instead.

","reactors":{"helpful":["Linch"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"6zpatPRamuuduw8tc","postedAt":"2024-11-20T18:47:34.088Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T21:47:59.194Z","score":0.004597140941768885,"baseScore":11,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"helpful":1},"parentCommentId":"c9qsJmiJ8k5mXTCmR","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"xyafhbAGG3uLrS5e6","slug":"agb","displayName":"AGB 🔸","username":"AGB","createdAt":"2014-09-13T13:39:57.317Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":3960,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":5,"commentCount":308,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$8e","reactors":{"helpful":["David Mathers🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"Ez63mP2ySpZGLuH4T","postedAt":"2024-11-20T19:35:30.848Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T04:35:10.223Z","score":0.0005557828117161989,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"vbHCsxYfW5BLo23iw","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"MCiXDyQLsSBiPbYNT","slug":"charlie_guthmann","displayName":"Charlie_Guthmann","username":"Charles_Guthmann","createdAt":"2020-08-03T19:25:28.315Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":1273,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":17,"commentCount":344,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

pre-doc at Data Innovation & AI Lab
previously worked in options HFT and tried building a social media startup
founder of Northwestern EA club

Hmm, I hear what you are saying but that could easily be attributed to some mix of

(1) he has really good/convincing ideas

(2) he seems to be a a public representative for the EA/LW community for a journalist on the outside.

And I'm responding to someone saying that we are in \"phase 3\" - that is to say people in the public are listening to us - so I guess I'm not extremely concerned about him not being able to draw attention or convince people. I'm more just generally worried that people like him are not who we should be promoting to positions of power, even if those are de jure positions.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"J8g9SbnoEdu9swq6s","postedAt":"2024-11-20T19:59:34.878Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T19:59:34.881Z","score":0.0019774173852056265,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"6zpatPRamuuduw8tc","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"jBF5BB7DMfJAzJ8Xf","slug":"michaeldickens","displayName":"MichaelDickens","username":"MichaelDickens","createdAt":"2014-09-10T16:22:19.751Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":8653,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":105,"commentCount":1124,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I do independent research on EA topics. I write about whatever seems important, tractable, and interesting (to me).

I have a website: https://mdickens.me/ Much of the content on my website gets cross-posted to the EA Forum, but I also write about some non-EA stuff over there.

I used to work as a software developer at Affirm.

Scott's last sentence seems to be claiming that avoiding an arms race is easier than solving alignment (and it would seem to follow from that that we shouldn't race). But I can see how a politician reading this article wouldn't see that implication.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"muRakDcWPgwe4nb4D","postedAt":"2024-11-20T20:03:21.093Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T20:39:00.249Z","score":0.0015971269458532333,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"agree":3},"parentCommentId":"tmBRPnvEXj9oKfRj5","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"jBF5BB7DMfJAzJ8Xf","slug":"michaeldickens","displayName":"MichaelDickens","username":"MichaelDickens","createdAt":"2014-09-10T16:22:19.751Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":8653,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":105,"commentCount":1124,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I do independent research on EA topics. I write about whatever seems important, tractable, and interesting (to me).

I have a website: https://mdickens.me/ Much of the content on my website gets cross-posted to the EA Forum, but I also write about some non-EA stuff over there.

I used to work as a software developer at Affirm.

I think that's not a reasonable position to hold but I don't know how to constructively argue against it in a short comment so I'll just register my disagreement.

Like, presumably China's values include humans existing and having mostly good experiences.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"ybahBrERcZsoGbh67","postedAt":"2024-11-20T20:39:00.044Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T20:39:00.048Z","score":0.001645927899517119,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":"muRakDcWPgwe4nb4D","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

Yep, I agree with this, but it appears nevertheless a relatively prevalent opinion among many EAs working in AI policy.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"v3KzWQERyD6o6iPsi","postedAt":"2024-11-20T22:36:16.167Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T00:01:50.598Z","score":0.0027829206082969904,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":7,"extendedScore":{"helpful":4,"insightful":1},"parentCommentId":"5WsDMFeZYBZR8gwKM","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"sMveyqiNPpPJmo7WF","slug":"dicentra","displayName":"Dicentra","username":"Dicentra","createdAt":"2020-10-09T16:55:31.902Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":652,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":0,"commentCount":49,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

This is inconsistent with my impressions and recollections. Most clearly, my sense is that CSET was (maybe still is, not sure) known for being very anti-escalatory towards China, and did substantial early research debunking hawkish views about AI progress in China, demonstrating it was less far along than ways widely believed in DC (and that EAs were involved in this, because they thought it was true and important, because they thought current false fears in the greater natsec community were enhancing arms race risks) (and this was when Jason was leading CSET, and OP supporting its founding). Some of the same people were also supportive of export controls, which are more ambiguous-sign here.

","reactors":{"helpful":["Habryka [Deactivated]","Ben_West🔸","Ozzie Gooen","akash 🔸"],"insightful":["David Mathers🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"noKYi52FJyZkZWMwx","postedAt":"2024-11-20T23:07:24.052Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-20T23:07:24.055Z","score":0.003910896833986044,"baseScore":9,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"helpful":2},"parentCommentId":"5WsDMFeZYBZR8gwKM","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"jBF5BB7DMfJAzJ8Xf","slug":"michaeldickens","displayName":"MichaelDickens","username":"MichaelDickens","createdAt":"2014-09-10T16:22:19.751Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":8653,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":105,"commentCount":1124,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I do independent research on EA topics. I write about whatever seems important, tractable, and interesting (to me).

I have a website: https://mdickens.me/ Much of the content on my website gets cross-posted to the EA Forum, but I also write about some non-EA stuff over there.

I used to work as a software developer at Affirm.

I looked thru the congressional commission report's list of testimonies for plausibly EA-adjacent people. The only EA-adjacent org I saw was CSET, which had two testimonies (1, 2). From a brief skim, neither one looked clearly pro- or anti-arms race. They seemed vaguely pro-arms race on vibes but I didn't see any claims that look like they were clearly encouraging an arms race—but like I said, I only briefly skimmed them, so I could have missed a lot.

\n","reactors":{"helpful":["Habryka [Deactivated]","David Mathers🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"hjtx6mqbPRwHJdW2H","postedAt":"2024-11-20T23:14:34.747Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T00:01:50.598Z","score":0.004099683370441198,"baseScore":9,"voteCount":6,"extendedScore":{"agree":2,"helpful":1},"parentCommentId":"v3KzWQERyD6o6iPsi","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

The export controls seemed like a pretty central example of hawkishness towards China and a reasonable precursor to this report. The central motivation in all that I have written related to them was about beating China in AI capabilities development.

Of course no one likes a symmetric arms race, but the question is did people favor the \"quickly establish overwhelming dominance towards China by investing heavily in AI\" or the \"try to negotiate with China and not set an example of racing towards AGI\" strategy. My sense is many people favored the former (though definitely not all, and I am not saying that there is anything like consensus, my sense is it's a quite divisive topic).

To support your point, I have seen much writing from Helen Toner on trying to dispel hawkishness towards China, and have been grateful for that. Against your point, at the recent \"AI Security Forum\" in Vegas, many x-risk concerned people expressed very hawkish opinions.

","reactors":{"helpful":["David Mathers🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"EmavCekhKAvJKvu2f","postedAt":"2024-11-21T00:01:50.389Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T00:01:50.391Z","score":0.001646301825530827,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"helpful":2,"insightful":1},"parentCommentId":"hjtx6mqbPRwHJdW2H","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"sMveyqiNPpPJmo7WF","slug":"dicentra","displayName":"Dicentra","username":"Dicentra","createdAt":"2020-10-09T16:55:31.902Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":652,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":0,"commentCount":49,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Yeah re the export controls, I was trying to say \"I think CSET was generally anti-escalatory, but in contrast, the effect of their export controls work was less so\" (though I used the word \"ambiguous\" because my impression was that some relevant people saw a pro of that work that it also mostly didn't directly advance AI progress in the US, i.e. it set China back without necessarily bringing the US forward towards AGI). To use your terminology, my impression is some of those people were \"trying to establish overwhelming dominance over China\" but not by \"investing heavily in AI\".

","reactors":{"helpful":["Habryka [Deactivated]","Ben_West🔸"],"insightful":["Rebecca"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"TMWAGfwXggzJXr3NH","postedAt":"2024-11-21T01:24:30.193Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T01:24:30.220Z","score":0.001142060849815607,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":null,"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"

Hi Ben! You might be interested to know I literally had a meeting with the Assistant Defence Minister in Australia about 10 months ago off the back of one email. I wrote about it here. AI Safety advocacy is IMO still low extremely hanging fruit. My best theory is EAs don't want to do it because EAs are drawn to spreadsheets etc (it isn't their comparative advantage).

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"mXBpqqpZrTYCb2Tdo","postedAt":"2024-11-21T03:03:49.980Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T04:35:10.223Z","score":0.0012600503396242857,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"Ez63mP2ySpZGLuH4T","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"uurFmKn6u3ehwtWPC","slug":"david-mathers","displayName":"David Mathers🔸","username":"Dr. David Mathers","createdAt":"2021-12-22T17:51:30.252Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":6151,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":11,"commentCount":759,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Superforecaster, former philosophy PhD, Giving What We Can member since 2012. Currently trying to get into AI governance.

Yeah, I'm not a Yudkowsky fan. But I think the fact that he mostly hasn't been a PR disaster is striking, surprising and not much remarked upon, including by people who are big fans.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"mEoS5ZG9GpydeQmNM","postedAt":"2024-11-21T03:53:34.211Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T04:35:10.223Z","score":0.0005560979479923844,"baseScore":1,"voteCount":1,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"mXBpqqpZrTYCb2Tdo","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"MCiXDyQLsSBiPbYNT","slug":"charlie_guthmann","displayName":"Charlie_Guthmann","username":"Charles_Guthmann","createdAt":"2020-08-03T19:25:28.315Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":1273,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":17,"commentCount":344,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

pre-doc at Data Innovation & AI Lab
previously worked in options HFT and tried building a social media startup
founder of Northwestern EA club

I guess in thinking about this I realize it's so hard to even know if someone is a \"PR disaster\" that I probably have just been confirming my biases. What makes you say that he hasn't been?

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"w9hFfJiEaBcosbrfF","postedAt":"2024-11-21T04:35:10.040Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T04:35:10.043Z","score":0.002353768330067396,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"mEoS5ZG9GpydeQmNM","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"uurFmKn6u3ehwtWPC","slug":"david-mathers","displayName":"David Mathers🔸","username":"Dr. David Mathers","createdAt":"2021-12-22T17:51:30.252Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":6151,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":11,"commentCount":759,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Superforecaster, former philosophy PhD, Giving What We Can member since 2012. Currently trying to get into AI governance.

Just the stuff I already said about the success he seems to have had. It is also true that many people hate him and think he's ridiculous, but I think that makes him polarizing rather than disastrous. I suppose you could phrase it as \"he was a disaster in some ways but a success in others\" if you want to.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"A9dH7chfN3FuTLkQu","postedAt":"2024-11-21T05:17:02.866Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T05:21:35.930Z","score":0.005380194168537855,"baseScore":13,"voteCount":7,"extendedScore":{"agree":4},"parentCommentId":"9jCAZjHKTHbitNprN","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Maybe instead of \"where people actually listen to us\" it's more like \"EA in a world where people filter the most memetically fit of our ideas through their preconceived notions into something that only vaguely resembles what the median EA cares about but is importantly different from the world in which EA didn't exist.\"

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"p6NFschJYaN2mxzy8","postedAt":"2024-11-21T05:21:35.696Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T05:21:35.698Z","score":0.001720090163871646,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"A9dH7chfN3FuTLkQu","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"jBF5BB7DMfJAzJ8Xf","slug":"michaeldickens","displayName":"MichaelDickens","username":"MichaelDickens","createdAt":"2014-09-10T16:22:19.751Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":8653,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":105,"commentCount":1124,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I do independent research on EA topics. I write about whatever seems important, tractable, and interesting (to me).

I have a website: https://mdickens.me/ Much of the content on my website gets cross-posted to the EA Forum, but I also write about some non-EA stuff over there.

I used to work as a software developer at Affirm.

On that framing, I agree that that's something that happens and that we should be able to anticipate will happen.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"ocdkeXQAgvhTm9hLp","postedAt":"2024-11-21T07:29:39.900Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T07:29:39.904Z","score":0.005173122975975275,"baseScore":12,"voteCount":6,"extendedScore":{"agree":2,"helpful":3},"parentCommentId":"QjmDH65fkBqXTwtQq","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

In my post, I suggested that one possible future is that we stay at the \"forefront of weirdness.\" Calculating moral weights, to use your example.

I could imagine though that the fact that our opinions might be read by someone with access to the nuclear codes changes how we do things.

I wish there was more debate about which of these futures is more desirable.

(This is what I was trying to get out with my original post. I'm not trying to make any strong claims about whether any individual person counts as \"EA\".)

\n","reactors":{"helpful":["JWS 🔸","Habryka [Deactivated]","Linch"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"jRxtcrEQvvgFvrBFM","postedAt":"2024-11-21T21:22:25.955Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T21:47:59.194Z","score":0.002154384506866336,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"6zpatPRamuuduw8tc","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Huh, fwiw this is not my anecdotal experience. I would suggest that this is because I spend more time around doomers than you and doomers are very influenced by Yudkowsky's \"don't fight over which monkey gets to eat the poison banana first\" framing, but that seems contradicted by your example being ACX, who is also quite doomer-adjacent.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"h5QhW6SueePhBrLGj","postedAt":"2024-11-21T21:27:51.403Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T21:27:51.406Z","score":-0.00044089200673624873,"baseScore":-1,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{"agree":1,"disagree":1},"parentCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"KFkknyEkkpo5HXjg8","slug":"matrice-jacobine","displayName":"Matrice Jacobine🔸🏳️‍⚧️","username":"Matrice Jacobine","createdAt":"2024-08-28T17:59:04.651Z","profileImageId":"Profile/a0lgosmowh4hueynzqlw","karma":1259,"jobTitle":"Student in fundamental and applied mathematics","organization":"University of Poitiers","postCount":60,"commentCount":156,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I am also a member of Altruisme Efficace France, the main EA organization in France, where I volunteer as translator, and AFT-Technoprog, an organization advocating for democratic transhumanist ideas.

It seems to plausible that, much like Environmental Political Orthodoxy (reverence for simple rural living as expressed through localism, anti-nuclear sentiment, etc.) ultimately led the environmental movement to be harmful for its own professed goals, EA Political Orthodoxy (technocratic liberalism, \"mistake theory\", general disdain for social science) could (and maybe already had, with the creation of OpenAI) ultimately lead EA efforts on AI to be a net negative by its own standards.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"XJmr9nNW9CEgnKYrm","postedAt":"2024-11-21T21:47:58.824Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-21T21:47:58.828Z","score":0.003873357782140374,"baseScore":9,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":{"agree":2,"helpful":1},"parentCommentId":"jRxtcrEQvvgFvrBFM","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"xyafhbAGG3uLrS5e6","slug":"agb","displayName":"AGB 🔸","username":"AGB","createdAt":"2014-09-13T13:39:57.317Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":3960,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":5,"commentCount":308,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":null},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$8f","reactors":{"helpful":["Ben_West🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"oxmjzupczMGcTDFoh","postedAt":"2024-11-22T02:00:19.471Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-11-22T02:00:19.475Z","score":0.0018507869681343436,"baseScore":4,"voteCount":2,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"c9qsJmiJ8k5mXTCmR","topLevelCommentId":"SXATCmFFSgopBtgYP","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"b7PzPpNdjTQtPAYnD","slug":"habryka-deactivated","displayName":"Habryka [Deactivated]","username":"Habryka","createdAt":"2014-09-18T16:59:01.523Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":22454,"jobTitle":"CEO","organization":"Lightcone Infrastructure","postCount":32,"commentCount":1443,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

You can find me on LessWrong or Twitter.

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

Adult film star Abella Danger apparently took an class on EA at University of Miami, became convinced, and posted about EA to raise $10k for One for the World. She was PornHub's most popular female performer in 2023 and has ~10M followers on instagram. Her post has ~15k likes, comments seem mostly positive.

I think this might be the class that @Richard Y Chappell🔸 teaches?

Thanks Abella and kudos to whoever introduced her to EA!

","reactors":{"love":["Will Aldred","Karthik Tadepalli","Neel Nanda","Richard Y Chappell🔸","ramekin","Mo Putera","mhendric🔸","Kaleem","Eevee🔹","akash 🔸","Holly Elmore ⏸️ 🔸","mjkerrison🔸️","isabel🔸","Angelina Li","Nathan Young","Yi-Yang"],"insightful":["MHR🔸","niplav","Mo Putera","T_W"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"c8g3uJhZmhfiPmjzQ","postedAt":"2024-12-24T21:48:29.794Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-12-24T21:48:29.797Z","score":0.013938079588115215,"baseScore":32,"voteCount":12,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"RzJd9aKkLkFNSaEHA","topLevelCommentId":"RzJd9aKkLkFNSaEHA","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

It looks like she did a giving season fundraiser for Helen Keller International, which she credits to the EA class she took. Maybe we will see her at a future EAG!

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"Gk4u8XmydnYqopFKF","postedAt":"2024-12-26T07:55:52.330Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2025-01-06T20:34:49.521Z","score":0.0027734593022614717,"baseScore":6,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"RzJd9aKkLkFNSaEHA","topLevelCommentId":"RzJd9aKkLkFNSaEHA","descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"QsKuaiKGKkejxWfsm","slug":"satpathyakash","displayName":"akash 🔸","username":"satpathyakash","createdAt":"2022-09-09T18:09:51.367Z","profileImageId":"Profile/d10uadqe8yjbi7v7p7ud","karma":869,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":2,"commentCount":113,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I have a master's in Information Science. Before switching to the master's, I was a Ph.D. student in Planetary Science where I used optimization models to physically characterize asteroids (including potentially hazardous ones).

Historically, my most time-intensive EA involvement has been organizing Tucson Effective Altruism, the EA university group at the University of Arizona. If you are a movement builder, let's get in touch!

I am broadly interested in economic growth, abundant futures, and earning-to-give for animal welfare. Always happy to chat about anything EA!

(Tangential but related) There is probably a strong case to be made for recruiting the help of EA sympathetic celebrities to promote effective giving, and maybe even raise funds. I am a bit hesitant about \"cause promotion\" by celebrities, but maybe some version of that idea is also defensible. Turns out, someone wrote about it on the Forum a few years ago, but I don't know how much subsequent discussion there has been on this topic since then.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"wRpuDSxKHsgNDFAyP","postedAt":"2024-12-26T17:58:24.494Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2024-12-26T17:58:24.497Z","score":0.0021906443871557713,"baseScore":5,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"Gk4u8XmydnYqopFKF","topLevelCommentId":"RzJd9aKkLkFNSaEHA","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"s9goRsKr8pvZgs9N4","slug":"karthik-tadepalli","displayName":"Karthik Tadepalli","username":"therealslimkt","createdAt":"2021-04-06T22:02:57.189Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":4481,"jobTitle":"Economics PhD","organization":"UC Berkeley","postCount":18,"commentCount":510,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

I think about technological progress, global development, and AI's economic impacts. I write about these topics on my blog, Beyond Imitation.

I follow a lot of YouTubers and streamers who run large-scale charitable events (example, example, example) and I've always thought about how great it would be to convince them to give the money to an effective charity.

\n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"icwKi4zwwCPK65yjn","postedAt":"2025-01-06T20:34:49.330Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2025-01-06T20:34:49.334Z","score":0.003398216562345624,"baseScore":7,"voteCount":4,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"Gk4u8XmydnYqopFKF","topLevelCommentId":"RzJd9aKkLkFNSaEHA","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"2vttqBLW4EfhkbxE8","slug":"julia_wise","displayName":"Julia_Wise🔸","username":"Julia_Wise","createdAt":"2014-08-21T01:29:44.041Z","profileImageId":"Profile/cdj7x6ssxfxnh0cbyxp9","karma":15474,"jobTitle":"Community liaison","organization":"Centre for Effective Altruism","postCount":81,"commentCount":568,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Please feel free to contact me at julia.wise@centreforeffectivealtruism.org.

Besides effective altruism, I'm interested in folk dance and trying to keep up with my three children.

High Impact Athletes is one effort in this direction.

","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"oDiCs5qSiTrvngHCt","postedAt":"2025-01-18T19:15:18.511Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2025-01-19T23:31:38.325Z","score":0.015699632465839386,"baseScore":35,"voteCount":20,"extendedScore":{"agree":7},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"

Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.

EA Awards

I feel worried that the ratio of the amount of criticism that one gets for doing EA stuff to the amount of positive feedback one gets is too high
Awards are a standard way to counteract this
I would like to explore having some sort of awards thingy
I currently feel most excited about something like: a small group of people solicit nominations and then choose a short list of people to be voted on by Forum members, and then the winners are presented at a session at EAG BA
I would appreciate feedback on:
1. whether people think this is a good idea
2. How to frame this - I want to avoid being seen as speaking on behalf of all EAs
Also if anyone wants to volunteer to co-organize with me I would appreciate hearing that

","reactors":null,"tags":[{"core":true,"name":"Building effective altruism","slug":"building-effective-altruism","postCount":7830,"shortName":"Building EA","description":"

Building effective altruism refers to the family of interventions aimed at growing, shaping, or otherwise improving effective altruism as a practical and intellectual community.

Examples of building effective altruism include starting..."},{"core":true,"name":"Community","slug":"community","postCount":7464,"shortName":null,"description":"

The community topic covers posts about the effective altruism community, as well as applying EA in one's personal life. The tag also applies to posts about the Forum itself, since this is a community space. You should use the community tag if one of the following things is true:

The post is about EA a..."}]},{"_id":"BHswdR488HwkvfZX7","postedAt":"2025-01-19T15:48:50.608Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2025-01-19T15:48:50.612Z","score":0.001213776064105332,"baseScore":2,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"love":1},"parentCommentId":"oDiCs5qSiTrvngHCt","topLevelCommentId":"oDiCs5qSiTrvngHCt","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"uCSPrzRNP6Jc4QmSo","slug":"jlemien","displayName":"Joseph Lemien","username":"jlemien","createdAt":"2020-12-26T00:45:11.075Z","profileImageId":"Profile/ckva7qqmmkjw2glygjnc","karma":3363,"jobTitle":"Operations","organization":"MATS","postCount":24,"commentCount":606,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"$91"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"
My gut likes the idea. (but I tend to be biased in favor of community-building, fun, complementary things)
The two concerns that leap to mind are:
- How to prevent this from simply being a popularity contest? What criteria would the voting/selection be based off of?
- Would this simply end up rewarding people who have been lucky enough to be born in the right place, or to have chosen the right college major?
I suspect that there are ways to avoid these stumbling blocks, but I don't know enough about the context/field/area to know what they are. Overall, I'd like to see people explore it and see if it would be workable.
","reactors":{"love":["Ben_West🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"8M8pRjCC8JAsAtCtr","postedAt":"2025-01-19T23:31:38.161Z","lastEditedAt":null,"lastSubthreadActivity":"2025-01-19T23:31:38.163Z","score":0.005803507752716541,"baseScore":13,"voteCount":7,"extendedScore":{"agree":4,"helpful":2},"parentCommentId":"oDiCs5qSiTrvngHCt","topLevelCommentId":"oDiCs5qSiTrvngHCt","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"jBF5BB7DMfJAzJ8Xf","slug":"michaeldickens","displayName":"MichaelDickens","username":"MichaelDickens","createdAt":"2014-09-10T16:22:19.751Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":8653,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":105,"commentCount":1124,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"
I do independent research on EA topics. I write about whatever seems important, tractable, and interesting (to me).
I have a website: https://mdickens.me/ Much of the content on my website gets cross-posted to the EA Forum, but I also write about some non-EA stuff over there.
I used to work as a software developer at Affirm.
"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"
The way they're usually done, awards counteract the negative:positive feedback ratio for a tiny group of people. I think it would be better to give positive feedback to a much larger group of people, but I don't have any good ideas about how to do that. Maybe just give a lot of awards?
\n","reactors":{"helpful":["Ben_West🔸","Linch"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"WPTYwv4WCJLgH2DxH","postedAt":"2025-02-24T18:47:29.370Z","lastEditedAt":"2025-02-24T18:47:29.370Z","lastSubthreadActivity":"2025-02-24T18:47:29.373Z","score":0.014451011084020138,"baseScore":31,"voteCount":15,"extendedScore":{"love":2,"helpful":1},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"
Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.
"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"
If you can get a better score than our human subjects did on any of METR's RE-Bench evals, send it to me and we will fly you out for an onsite interview
Caveats:\n
1. you're employable (we can sponsor visas from most but not all countries)\n
2. use same hardware
3. \nhonor system that you didn't take more time than our human subjects (8 hours). If you take more still send it to me and we probably will still be interested in talking
(Crossposted from twitter.)
","reactors":{"love":["Neel Nanda","Linch"],"helpful":["Linch"]},"tags":[{"core":true,"name":"AI safety","slug":"ai-safety","postCount":7235,"shortName":null,"description":"
AI safety is the study of ways to reduce risks posed by artificial intelligence.
Interventions that aim to reduce these risks can be split into:
- Technical alignment..."},{"core":true,"name":"Opportunities to take action","slug":"opportunities-to-take-action","postCount":2705,"shortName":"Opportunities","description":"
  The EA Forum is mostly about discussing ideas. But ultimately, the reason we discuss those ideas is to help us take actions that improve the world.
  Apply the opportunities to take action topic to posts that offer readers a way to get involved..."}]},{"_id":"xWbdJxWovjFeERMto","postedAt":"2026-02-02T18:43:18.240Z","lastEditedAt":"2026-02-03T18:47:05.901Z","lastSubthreadActivity":"2026-02-04T01:09:25.283Z","score":0.0437227264046669,"baseScore":48,"voteCount":26,"extendedScore":{"love":4,"agree":1,"disagree":4,"insightful":8},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":3,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"
  Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.
  "},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"
  EA Animal Welfare Fund almost as big as Coefficient Giving FAW now?
  This job ad says they raised >$10M in 2025 and are targeting $20M in 2026. CG's public Farmed Animal Welfare 2025 grants are ~$35M.
  Is this right?
  Cool to see the fund grow so much either way.
  ","reactors":{"love":["Ariel Simnegar 🔸","SofiaBalderson","Dion🔸","akash 🔸"],"insightful":["Austin","MHR🔸","Ozzie Gooen","Vidur Kapur","Ariel Simnegar 🔸","MathiasKB🔸","Kashvi Mulchandani 🔸","Mo Putera"]},"tags":[{"core":true,"name":"Effective giving","slug":"effective-giving","postCount":2402,"shortName":null,"description":"
  Effective giving is the branch of effective altruism focused on charitable donations.
  The main purpose of effective giving is to support a charity or project that can achieve an..."},{"core":true,"name":"Animal welfare","slug":"animal-welfare","postCount":3290,"shortName":null,"description":"
  Animal welfare is a core focus area within effective altruism. It focuses on ways to improve the wellbeing of nonhuman animals, primarily..."}]},{"_id":"XqciNsSJzySTfxzL5","postedAt":"2026-02-03T18:02:38.483Z","lastEditedAt":"2026-02-03T18:02:38.483Z","lastSubthreadActivity":"2026-02-03T18:47:21.256Z","score":0.008999304845929146,"baseScore":9,"voteCount":5,"extendedScore":{"agree":5,"helpful":1},"parentCommentId":"xWbdJxWovjFeERMto","topLevelCommentId":"xWbdJxWovjFeERMto","descendentCount":1,"directChildrenCount":1,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"JzT2XGgmvG2nZCfT6","slug":"jeff-kaufman","displayName":"Jeff Kaufman 🔸","username":"Jeff_Kaufman","createdAt":"2014-08-21T01:29:45.712Z","profileImageId":"Profile/d2ov3fs6fmg64pbbxvec","karma":19178,"jobTitle":"Director of Detection","organization":"SecureBio","postCount":125,"commentCount":1108,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"
  Boston-based, Director of Detection at SecureBio, GWWC board member, parent, musician. Switched from earning to give to direct work in pandemic mitigation. Married to Julia Wise. Speaking for myself unless I say otherwise. Full list of EA posts: jefftk.com/news/ea
  "},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"
  \n
  almost as big as Coefficient Giving
  \n
  \n
  Specifically within animal welfare (this wasn't immediately clear to me, and I was very confused how CG's grants could be so low)
  \n","reactors":{"helpful":["Ben_West🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"NHJeJydofBRMrQBBx","postedAt":"2026-02-03T18:47:21.036Z","lastEditedAt":"2026-02-03T18:47:21.036Z","lastSubthreadActivity":"2026-02-03T18:47:21.038Z","score":0.003174742916598916,"baseScore":3,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{},"parentCommentId":"XqciNsSJzySTfxzL5","topLevelCommentId":"xWbdJxWovjFeERMto","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"
  Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.
  "},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"
  Ah yeah good point, I updated the text.
  ","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"rGXPoZuhEBBv79s2S","postedAt":"2026-02-04T01:09:24.534Z","lastEditedAt":"2026-02-04T01:09:24.534Z","lastSubthreadActivity":"2026-02-04T01:09:24.536Z","score":0.024295415729284286,"baseScore":26,"voteCount":13,"extendedScore":{"agree":8,"helpful":2},"parentCommentId":"xWbdJxWovjFeERMto","topLevelCommentId":"xWbdJxWovjFeERMto","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"tnf5eoQHxemk9x3jk","slug":"kierangreig","displayName":"kierangreig🔸","username":"kierangreig","createdAt":"2015-02-17T10:07:24.392Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":2015,"jobTitle":"President","organization":"Rethink Priorities","postCount":27,"commentCount":133,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"$92"},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"
  Agree that it’s really great to see the fund grow so much!
  That said, I don’t think it’s right to say it’s almost as large as Coefficient Giving. At least not yet... :)
  The 2025 total appears to exclude a number of grants (including one to Rethink Priorities) and only runs through August of that year. By comparison, Coefficient Giving’s farmed animal welfare funding in 2024 was around $70M, based on the figures published on their website.
  ","reactors":{"helpful":["Ben_West🔸","akash 🔸"]},"tags":null},{"_id":"CGHqjC6diCrSGpCq9","postedAt":"2026-02-07T06:52:03.476Z","lastEditedAt":"2026-02-07T07:22:49.547Z","lastSubthreadActivity":"2026-02-09T00:14:30.751Z","score":0.024707159027457237,"baseScore":27,"voteCount":11,"extendedScore":{"agree":2},"parentCommentId":null,"topLevelCommentId":null,"descendentCount":2,"directChildrenCount":2,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"
  Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.
  "},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$93","reactors":null,"tags":[{"core":true,"name":"Existential risk","slug":"existential-risk","postCount":4355,"shortName":null,"description":"
  An existential risk is a risk that threatens the destruction of the long-term potential of life.^[1] An existential risk could threaten the..."},{"core":true,"name":"AI safety","slug":"ai-safety","postCount":7235,"shortName":null,"description":"
  AI safety is the study of ways to reduce risks posed by artificial intelligence.
  Interventions that aim to reduce these risks can be split into:
  - Technical alignment..."}]},{"_id":"B9AAHpqrrmKAihwjM","postedAt":"2026-02-08T01:00:37.298Z","lastEditedAt":"2026-02-08T01:05:42.288Z","lastSubthreadActivity":"2026-02-08T01:00:37.299Z","score":0.012263010255992413,"baseScore":13,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":5},"parentCommentId":"CGHqjC6diCrSGpCq9","topLevelCommentId":"CGHqjC6diCrSGpCq9","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"jBF5BB7DMfJAzJ8Xf","slug":"michaeldickens","displayName":"MichaelDickens","username":"MichaelDickens","createdAt":"2014-09-10T16:22:19.751Z","profileImageId":null,"karma":8653,"jobTitle":null,"organization":null,"postCount":105,"commentCount":1124,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"
    I do independent research on EA topics. I write about whatever seems important, tractable, and interesting (to me).
    I have a website: https://mdickens.me/ Much of the content on my website gets cross-posted to the EA Forum, but I also write about some non-EA stuff over there.
    I used to work as a software developer at Affirm.
    "},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"
    Ah yes, this supports my pre-conceived belief that (1) we cannot reliably ascertain whether a model has catastrophically dangerous capabilities, and therefore (2) we need to stop developing increasingly powerful models until we get a handle on things.
    \n","reactors":null,"tags":null},{"_id":"4kGFfePoG6CBYFz26","postedAt":"2026-02-09T00:14:30.448Z","lastEditedAt":"2026-02-09T00:14:30.448Z","lastSubthreadActivity":"2026-02-09T00:14:30.450Z","score":0.009840251877903938,"baseScore":10,"voteCount":3,"extendedScore":{"agree":1},"parentCommentId":"CGHqjC6diCrSGpCq9","topLevelCommentId":"CGHqjC6diCrSGpCq9","descendentCount":0,"directChildrenCount":0,"draft":false,"deleted":false,"deletedDate":null,"deletedReason":null,"tagCommentType":"DISCUSSION","isPinnedOnProfile":false,"shortform":true,"shortformFrontpage":true,"moderatorHat":false,"promoted":null,"forumEventMetadata":null,"authorIsUnreviewed":false,"repliesBlockedUntil":null,"retracted":false,"rejected":false,"user":{"_id":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","slug":"ben_west","displayName":"Ben_West🔸","username":"Ben_West","createdAt":"2014-09-23T13:38:40.722Z","profileImageId":"Profile/hxqdmanja8yv1og9gx1q","karma":16431,"jobTitle":"","organization":"","postCount":81,"commentCount":1268,"deleted":false,"biographyHtml":"
    Non-EA interests include chess and TikTok (@benthamite). Formerly @ CEA, METR + a couple now-acquired startups.
    "},"promotedBy":null,"deletedBy":null,"forumEvent":null,"post":{"_id":"A5mh4DJaLeCDxapJG","slug":"ben_west-s-shortform","title":"Ben_West's Quick takes","userId":"dGXDHWQ9CaLKHRx5Y","frontpageDate":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.346Z","coauthorUserIds":[],"postedAt":"2021-10-17T19:59:24.343Z"},"tag":null,"awards":[],"html":"$94","reactors":null,"tags":null}],"children":["$L95","$L96","$L97","$L98","$L99"]}]